Bennison's Bakery
(847) 328-9434

We make ordering easy.

Sandwiches & Soup
- Caprese Sandwich $8.19
  
  Basil, fresh mozzarella cheese, tomato, oil and vinegar on a French baguette. Add giardiniera or pickles for an additional charge.
- Monaco Sandwich $8.59
  
  Boar's Head cracked pepper turkey, Board's Head smoked Gouda cheese and Bennison's coarse ground mustard on a croissant. Add sliced tomato, giardiniera or pickles for an additional charge.
- Jaconde Sandwich $8.59
  
  Boar's Head London broil roast beef, Boar's Head brie, Boar's Head pub horseradish sauce and caramelized onions on a French baguette. Add sliced tomato, giardiniera or pickles for an additional charge.
- Sebastopol Sandwich $8.59
  
  Boar's Head black forest ham, Boar's head swiss cheese, gherkin pickles and bennison's smooth mustard on a French baguette.Add sliced tomato, guardiniera or pickles for an additional charge.
- Italian Sandwich $8.59
  
  Boar's head deluxe ham, Boar's head capicola, Boar's head mortadella, Boar's head dry salami, Boar's head provolone cheese, Boar's head pickles, giardiniera with Bennison's grain mustard on a French baguette(We are currently out of french bread so the sandwich is being made on Ciabatta). Add sliced tomato for an additional charge.
- Toulouse Breakfast Sandwich $8.99
  
  Boar's Head black forest ham, Boar's Head bacon, Boar's Head breakfast sausage, Boar's Head black wax cheddar cheese, 2 scrambled eggs, bechamel sauce and Boar's Head Munster cheese on a croissant. Add mushrooms or sliced tomato for an additional charge.
- Steak, Egg and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich $9.79
  
  Boar's Head top round filet, Boar's Head black wax cheddar cheese, Boar's Head muenster cheese, 2 fried eggs, caramelized onions, Bennison's horseradish sauce on a brioche bun. Add mushrooms or giardiniera for an additional charge.
- Breakfast Panini $9.79
  
  Boar's Head bacon, fried egg, board's head black wax Cheddar cheese, boar's head Munster cheese, sliced tomato, and bechamel sauce on sourdough bread.
- 12 oz Boar's Head Soup $3.09
- Breakfast Slider Trio $13.99
  
  3 breakfast sliders with Boar's Head sausage(currently out of sausage, will double up bacon), Boar's Head bacon, Boar's Head cheddar, pan fried egg, Bechamel on brioche buns

Tea Cookies
- 1 lb. Assorted Tea Cookies $17.95
- 1 lb. Florentines Cookies $20.95
  
  Caramelized almonds dipped in chocolate.
- 1/2lb Assorted Tea Cookies $8.95
- 1lb Mini Chocolate Chip Cookies $12.95

Big Cookies
- Smiley Face Cookie $2.79
- Frowney Face Cookie $2.79
- Black and White Cookie $2.99
- Oatmeal Raisin Cookie $1.85
- M&M Cookie $1.85
- Sugar Cookie $1.85
- Chocolate Chip Cookie $1.85
- Sprinkle Cookie $1.85
- Evanston High School Cookie $3.19
  
  Image cookie with ETHS logo
- Covid-19 cookie $2.79

Croissants
- Plain Croissant $2.99
- Almond Croissant $3.49
- Ham & Cheese Croissant $3.49
- Chocolate Croissant $3.49
- Raisin Croissant $3.49
- Spinach & Feta Croissant $3.49
- Chocolate Almond Croissant $3.49

Cupcakes
- Large Red Velvet Cupcake $4.09
- Large Carrot Cake Cupcake $4.09

Sprinkle Cupcake
- Yellow Cake and Vanilla Icing Cupcake $1.65
- Yellow Cake and Chocolate Icing Cupcake $1.65
- Chocolate Cake and Chocolate Icing Cupcake $1.65
- Chocolate Cake and Vanilla Icing Cupcake $1.65

Snoopy Cupcake
- Snoopy Chocolate Cake $2.09
- Snoopy Yellow Cake $2.09

Cake Donuts
- Chocolate Iced Donut $1.69
- Vanilla Iced Donut $1.69
- Lemon Poppy Seed Donut $1.69
  
  Glazed lemon poppy seed donut with with icing and yellow sprinkles
- Blueberry Donut $1.69
  
  Glazed blueberry donut with white icing and purple sprinkles
- Cherry Donut $1.69
  
  Glazed cherry donut with white icing and red sprinkles
- Sour Cream Donut $1.69
- Devils Food $1.69
  
  Glazed chocolate donut with chocolate icing
- Powdered Sugar Donut $1.69
- Sprinkle Donut $1.69
- Coconut Topped Donut $1.69
- Plain Donut $1.69
- Oreo Donut $1.99
- Birthday Cake Donut $1.89
  
  Glazed cake donut with confetti and topped with buttercream
- Red Velvet Donut $1.89
- Chocolate Chip $1.69

Yeast Donuts
- Chocolate Long John Donut $1.69
- Vanilla Long John Donut $1.69
- Raspberry Bismark Donut $1.69
- Chocolate Iced Custard Bismark Donut $1.69
- Cinnamon Swirl Donut $1.69
- Maple Bacon Long John Donut $2.69
  
  Yeast Long John with a strip of glazed Boar's Head bacon
- Apple Fritter Donut $1.69
- Chocolate Iced Yeast Donut $1.69
- Sugar Twist Donut $1.69
- Glazed Donut $1.69

Danish
- Apple Danish $1.89
- Apricot Danish $1.89
- Cheese Danish $1.89
- Lemon Danish $1.89
- Plain Danish $1.89
- Prune Danish $1.89
- Blueberry Danish $1.89
- Coconut Custard Danish $1.89
- Pineapple Danish $1.89

Muffins
- Chocolate Chip Muffin $2.69
- Chocolate Chocolate Chip Muffin $2.69
- Carrot Raisin Muffin $2.69
- Pumpkin Muffin $2.69
- Lemon Poppyseed Muffin $2.69
- Blueberry Muffin $2.69
- Cranberry Orange Muffin $2.69
- Hawaiian Muffin $2.69

Breakfast Pastries
- Mixed Fruit Scone $2.59
- Mixed Fruit Scone with Raspberry Jam $2.59
- Cinnamon Scone $2.59
- Chocolate Chip Scone $2.59
- Blueberry Scone $2.59
- Cinnamon Roll $2.89
- Almond Bear Claw $1.89
- Pecan Roll $2.89

Sweets
- Lemon Bar $2.59
- Apple Pie Slice $2.59
- Cherry Slice $2.59
- Éclair $3.49
- Brownie with Nuts $1.99
- Brownie without Nuts $1.99
- Cannoli $2.49
- Napolean Slice $3.99
- Petit Fors $1.89
- Marzipan Pastry Slice $3.79
  
  Marzipan
- Rum Ball $3.50
- Pound Cake $8.09
- Cherry Pie Slice $2.59
- Peach Pie Slice $2.59
  
  Peach filling layered with sweet almond paste on top of a cookie crust.
- 7" New York cheesecake $15.99
- Lemon Cake $12.99
  
  Lemon Bundt cake filled with lemon zest and topped with vanilla icing.
- Louisiana Crunch Cake $12.99
- Granny's Funeral Cake $12.99
  
  Cinnamon crunch topped bundt shaped pound cake.

Macarons
- Macarons $1.99

Bread
- 6 Grain Bread $5.99
- White Bread $5.99
- Wheat Bread $5.99
- Baguette $2.99
- Ciabatta $5.99
- Flaxseed $7.09
- Garlic Asiago $7.09
- California Bread $7.09
- Sourdough Bread $7.09
- Cinnamon Raisin Bread $7.09

Drinks
- Coffee $1.99+
  
  Specify Hot or Iced
- Decaf Coffee $1.99+
  
  Only available Hot
- Hot Tea $1.99+
  
  Black Tea available Iced
- Espresso $2.09+
  
  Specify Hot or Iced
- Latte $3.39+
  
  Specify Hot or Iced
- Capuccino $3.39+
  
  Specify Hot or Iced
- Vanilla Latte $3.39+
  
  Specify Hot or Iced. We offer Sugar Free Vanilla Syrup as well.
- Mocha Latte $3.39+
  
  Specify Hot or Iced
- Caramel Machiatto $3.39+
  
  Specify Hot or Iced
- Milky Way $3.39+
  
  Specify Hot or Iced
- Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice $3.39+
- Smart Water $2.25
- La Croix $1.79
  
  Pamplemousse, mango, berry, lemon or lime.
- Italian Soda $2.09+
  
  Various Flavors, Please specify
- 96 Oz Coffee carrier $23.10
  
  This includes cups,lids,creamer and sugar packets. Please specify any details for your order in the notes.

Brick Oven Pizza

Pie
- 8" Cherry Pie $14.00
- 8" Apple Pie $14.00
- 8" Strawberry Rhubarb Pie $14.00
- 8" Peach Pie $14.00
- 8" Pecan Pie $18.99
- 8" Pumpkin Pie $14.00

Easter
- Bunny Cookie $0.99
- Chick Cookie $0.99
- Bunny Butt Cupcake $4.89
- Lamb Cake $35.95
  
  Lamb Cakes are a Bennison's Easter tradition. We offer three varieties (sorry, no customizing): Buttermilk pound cake with buttercream icing, chocolate pound cake with chocolate icing, and buttermilk poundcake with buttercream icing covered in coconut flake.
- Rainbow Easter Bread $7.00
  
  Each Easter we take our traditional egg bread, and dye the dough different seasonal colors. Braided together and baked, it comes out as a loaf that's perfect for decoration, but even better when eaten.
- Mini Bunny Cake $4.99
  
  Yellow cream cake with buttercream filling
- Easter Egg Cake $31.95

Cakes
- 1 Layer Red Velvet $16.60
  
  If you would like an inscription please leave what you'd like in the special instructions section
- 1 Layer Carrot Cake $16.60
  
  If you would like an inscription please leave what you'd like in the special instructions section
- 7" Store Cake $28.00
  
  If you would like an inscription please leave what you'd like in the special instructions section
- 2 Layer Red Velvet $34.40
  
  If you would like an inscription please leave what you'd like in the special instructions section
- 2 Layer Carrot Cake $34.40
  
  If you would like an inscription please leave what you'd like in the special instructions section
- 9" Store Cake $40.72
  
  If you would like an inscription please leave what you'd like in the special instructions section
- 6" Flourless Chocolate Cake (Gluten Free) $21.52
- 8" Flourless Chocolate Cake (Gluten Free) $31.55
- Princess Torte 7" $34.00
  
  Three layers of golden hot milk-style sponge cake, filled with raspberry jam and lemon curd, each filling topped with generous amounts of crème mousseline, a blend of vanilla bean custard and whipping crème. Iced all over with sweetened cream and topped with a layer of marzipan.
- Princess Torte 9" $52.00
  
  Three layers of golden hot milk-style sponge cake, filled with raspberry jam and lemon curd, each filling topped with generous amounts of crème mousseline, a blend of vanilla bean custard and whipping crème. Iced all over with sweetened cream and topped with a layer of marzipan.

Mother's Day
- Heart Cake $15.76
  
  Chocolate or yellow cake. Buttercream or fudge. buttercream roses. Inscription- Happy Mothers day
- Heart Shaped Petit Four $3.12
  
  Yellow cake, raspberry jam, chocolate coated
- Heart Brownie $3.89
  
  Brownie coated in choclate
- Heart Cheesecake with Strawberries $9.89
  
  For 2-3 people

Father's Day
- XL Maple Bacon Long John $14.29
- XL Eclair $14.29

Menu for Bennison's Bakery provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

What is Grubhub

Why use Grubhub

Bennison's Bakery