• Indiana
  • Evansville
  • Pie Pan Restaurant & Bakery

Pie Pan Restaurant & Bakery

(812) 425-2261
  • 905 North Park Drive, Evansville, IN 47710
  • Website
  • $$$$$
  • Grubhub.com
  • From the Garden
    Dressing Choices: Bleu Cheese Fat-free French Honey Mustard Light Italian Poppyseed Ranch Raspberry Vinaigrette Pie Pan Sweet & Sour French
    • Chicken Pecan Salad $8.99

      Grilled chicken on fresh greens with pecans, shredded cheese, carrots, tomatoes and house-made croutons

    • Crispy Chicken Tender Salad $8.99

      Fried chicken tenders on fresh greens with shredded cheese, carrots, tomatoes, and house-made croutons.

    • Pie Pan Chicken Salad $7.49

      Our house-made chicken salad on leaf lettuce served with tomato and a cup of soup or seasonal fruit

    • Chef Salad $8.99

      Ham, turkey and bacon on fresh greens with shredded cheese, tomatoes, and house-made croutons

    • Spinach Side Salad $5.29

      Fresh spinach topped with sliced egg, onion, crumbled bacon and house-made croutons

    • Side Salad $4.29

      Fresh greens with shredded cheese, tomatoes, carrots and house-made croutons

  • Quiche
    • Spinach Quiche $7.89

      Spinach, onion, Swiss and parmesan cheese served with a cup of soup or fresh fruit

    • Quiche Lorraine $8.29

      Ham, onion, Swiss and parmesan cheese served with a cup of soup or fresh fruit

  • Seasonal Soups
    • Vegetable Beef

    • Soup of the Day $4.69

    • Soup and Salad $7.49

      A cup of our soup served with a side salad and our famous hot roll

  • Soup & Sandwich
    • 1/2 Sandwich and Cup of Soup $8.49

      Choose 1/2 Sandwich: BLT Grilled Cheese Tuna Salad Chicken Salad Turkey Bacon Avocado Grilled Pimento Cheese Choose Cup of Soup: Vegetable Beef Soup of the Day

  • Sandwiches
    All sandwiches served with French Fries or Chips. *Dress it your way: lettuce, tomato, pickle, onion and mayonnaise
    • Pie Pan Classic Club $8.49

      Smoked ham and turkey, bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on toasted Artisan wheat bread

    • Chicken Salad $7.49

      Our house-made chicken salad, lettuce and tomato on toasted wheat bread

    • Philly Cheesesteak $8.49

      Grilled steak topped with sautéed mushrooms, green peppers, onions and melted cheese on a hoagie roll

    • Grilled Pimento Cheese $7.49

      Our house-made pimento cheese on grilled Artisan wheat bread

    • Tuna Melt $8.49

      Our house-made tuna salad and cheese on grilled Artisan wheat bread

    • Turkey Bacon Avocado $9.99

      Turkey, bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on Artisan wheat bread

    • French Dip $7.99

      Thinly sliced roast beef piled high on a hoagie roll served with au jus

    • B. L. T. $7.49

      Thick sliced bacon with lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on grilled Texas Toast

    • Fish Sandwich $7.99

      Breaded and fried cod filet with tartar sauce, dressed on a Kaiser roll

    • Fried Pork Tenderloin $7.99

      Deep fried pork tenderloin with Mayonnaise, dressed as you choose on grilled Texas Toast

    • Chicken Wrap $8.49

      Fried tenders, cheddar cheese, lettuce and tomatoes, wrapped in a flour tortilla served with ranch or honey mustard dressing

    • Grilled Chicken $8.49

      Grilled chicken breast dressed as you choose on a Kaiser roll

    • Maple Bacon Chicken $9.99

      Grilled chicken breast topped with maple bacon, melted cheese, dressed as you choose on a Kaiser roll

  • Appetizers
    • Pie Pan Poppers $4.49

      Our house-made cheesy casserole and crumbled bacon, rolled in breading and fried until golden served with sour cream 3 large poppers

    • Pick a Pair $7.99

      Choose 2: Pie Pan poppers, onion rings breaded mushrooms or corn nuggets served with choice of dipping sauce

    • Appetizer Basket $8.99

      A generous basket of Pie Pan poppers, breaded mushrooms, onion rings and corn nuggets served with your choice of dipping sauce

  • Burgers
    Served with French Fries. Add avocado, fried egg or grilled mushrooms to any burger $0.99. *Dress it your way: lettuce, tomato, pickle, onion and mayonnaise
    • Pie Pan Burger $8.29

      Our hand pattied beef grilled with cheese, dressed as you choose and served on a toasted Kaiser roll

    • Patty Melt $8.49

      Our hand pattied beef with melted cheese and sautéed onions served on grilled Texas Toast

    • Bacon Cheese Burger $9.49

      Our hand pattied beef topped with crispy thick cut bacon, American cheese, dressed as you choose and served on a toasted Kaiser roll

    • Smokey Burger $9.99

      Our hand pattied beef topped with crispy thick cut bacon, American cheese and BBQ sauce topped with onion rings and served on a toasted Kaiser roll

  • Dinner Entrées
    Add a cup of soup or Pie Pan salad 2.29
    • Chicken Tender Platter $9.99

      A generous portion of our hand breaded fried tenders served with two sides, your choice of dipping sauce and a Pie Pan roll

    • Chicken and Waffles $9.99

      Our house-made waffle topped with three fried chicken tenders served with warm syrup and mashed potatoes

    • Pie Pan Chicken Breast $9.99

      Two grilled chicken breasts grilled with our house seasoning served with two sides and a Pie Pan roll

    • Grilled Chicken Alfredo $9.49

      Grilled chicken, penne pasta and creamy alfredo sauce garnished with parmesan cheese and parsley served with garlic bread

    • Chicken Fried Chicken $8.99

      Country fried chicken breast served with mashed potatoes, one side and a Pie Pan roll

    • Chicken Livers $8.99

      A hearty serving of our hand breaded chicken livers fried to order served with two sides, gravy and a Pie Pan roll

    • Open Faced Roast Beef $9.49

      Roast beef piled high on Texas Toast smothered in brown gravy served with mashed potatoes and one side

    • Old Fashion Meat Loaf $8.99

      House-made meat loaf topped with our traditional ketchup sauce or brown gravy served with mashed potatoes, one side and a Pie Pan roll

    • Liver & Onions $8.99

      Grilled liver & sautéed onions served with brown gravy, two sides and a Pie Pan roll

    • Pot Roast $9.99

      Seasoned and roasted choice beef slow cooked until tender served with two sides and a Pie Pan roll

    • Country Fried Steak $9.49

      Our battered, fried steak served with white gravy, mashed potatoes, one side and a Pie Pan roll

    • Shrimp Basket $10.49

      A generous portion of breaded shrimp served with cocktail sauce, coleslaw and French fries

    • Grilled Salmon $12.99

      Seasoned and grilled salmon served with two sides and a Pie Pan roll

  • Sides
    Substitute a premium side for 1.49. Substitute a Side Salad 2.49.
    • Southern Green Beans

    • Buttered Corn

    • French Fries

    • Idaho Mashed Potatoes

    • Cheesy Hashbrown Casserole

    • Cole Slaw

    • Fresh Broccoli

    • Hot Cinnamon Apples

    • Macaroni and Cheese

    • Glazed Carrots

  • Premium Sides
    • Corn Fritters $2.49

    • Fried Okra $2.49

    • Onion Rings $2.49

    • Breaded Mushrooms $2.49

  • Kid's Menu
    ( 10 years and under ) Served with one side item and Milk, Apple Juice or soft drink
    • Chicken Tenders $4.99

    • Grilled Cheese $4.99

    • Grilled Chicken Breast $4.99

    • Junior Burger $4.99

  • Beverages
    • Fresh Coffee

    • Coffee Decaf

    • Fresh Brewed Tea

    • Sweet Tea

    • Milk

    • Lemonade

    • Orange Juice

    • Apple Juice

    • Iced Coffee* $3.69

      Made daily with a custom blend of brewed 100% Arabica beans and fresh whole milk, sweetened with pure cane sugar and served over ice. *Sorry no refills

  • Desserts
    Ask your server about taking a whole pie home today! Call us for your special occasion and holiday desserts.
    • Slice of Pie $3.99

    • Slice of Cake or Cheesecake $4.99

  • Award Winning Breakfast
    • Big Country $8.49

      Batter fried steak, gravy and two eggs served with choice of potato and toast or biscuit & gravy

    • All-American $7.99

      Two eggs, two pancakes or French toast, choice of bacon, sausage or ham

    • Libby's Special $6.99

      Two eggs, bacon, sausage or ham served with toast or biscuit & gravy

    • The Scrambler $7.99

      Three scrambled eggs with diced ham and cheese served with choice of potato and toast or biscuit & gravy

    • Mediterranean Scrambler $7.99

      Three scrambled eggs with spinach, tomato, sliced olives and feta cheese served with fresh fruit and toast

    • Breakfast Bowl $8.49

      Our cheesy hash brown casserole layered with bacon or sausage, cheese, two eggs, gravy and served with a biscuit

    • Chorizo Breakfast Bowl $8.99

      Our cheesy hash brown casserole layered with chorizo sausage, cheese, two eggs and served with a warm flour tortilla, salsa and sour cream

    • Breakfast Burrito $7.99

      A warm tortilla filled with scrambled eggs, green peppers, onion, cheese, and choice of bacon or sausage served with cheesy hash brown casserole

    • Breakfast Sandwich $6.99

      Egg, cheese, choice of bacon, sausage or ham on grilled wheat bread served with cheesy hash brown casserole

    • Corned Beef and Hash $8.49

      Lean corned beef hash with cheese and two eggs served with choice of potato and toast or biscuit & gravy

    • Chicken and Waffles $8.99

      Our house-made waffle topped with three fried chicken tenders served with warm syrup and choice of potato

    • Ham Steak & Eggs $8.99

      Two eggs, a thick cut grilled ham steak, served with choice of potato and toast or biscuit & gravy

  • Three Egg Omelettes
    • Western $7.99

      Diced ham, tomatoes, onions, peppers and cheese

    • Pie Pan Classic $7.29

      Cheese and choice of bacon, sausage, or ham

    • The Veggie $6.99

      Diced tomatoes, onions, peppers, mushrooms and cheese

    • Tex-Mex $7.99

      Diced fajita-style chicken, tomatoes, onions, peppers and cheese served with salsa and sour cream

    • Meat Lovers $8.49

      Sausage, ham, bacon and cheese

  • Fruit and Grains
    • Avocado Toast $5.99

      Our thick cut Artisan wheat toast topped with fresh smashed avocado, a squeeze of lemon juice and crumbled feta cheese served with fruit

    • Breakfast Banana Split $7.99

      Banana and vanilla yogurt topped with fresh berries, pineapple and granola then drizzled with honey served with an English Muffin

    • Seasonal Fruit $2.49

      Ask your server about today’s selection

    • Oatmeal or Grits $3.29

      Served warm with butter, brown sugar and milk

    • Yogurt $4.49

      Vanilla yogurt served with seasonal fruit and pecans

    • Pastry/Bread of the Day $2.29

      Ask your server for today’s selection

  • From The Griddle
    Add our house-made fruit topping and whipped cream to any griddle item 1.49
    • Pie Pan Pancakes $6.99

      Our giant, fluffy double stacked pancakes served with whipped butter, warm syrup and choice of bacon or sausage

    • French Toast $6.99

      Three slices of Texas toast dipped in our own cinnamon batter, lightly toasted and dusted with powdered sugar served with warm syrup and choice of bacon or sausage

    • Waffle $6.99

      Our Belgian waffle cooked until golden brown served with warm syrup and choice of bacon or sausage

  • Tag-A-Longs
    • Biscuits (2) & Gravy $4.99

    • Sausage Patties (2) $2.49

    • Bacon Strips (3) $2.99

    • Ham $3.29

    • Cheesy Hashbrown Casserole $1.99

    • Home Fried Potatoes $1.99

    • Toast $1.49

    • Biscuits (2) $2.49

    • Single egg $1.29

  • Kids Menu
    (10 years and under) Served with milk, orange or apple juice
    • Cheese Omelette $4.99

      Made with 1 egg, cheese, served with toast

    • One Egg, Meat, & Toast $4.99

      1 egg, 1 bacon strip or sausage patty

    • 3 Silver Dollar Pancakes $4.99

      3 small pancakes, 1 bacon strip or sausage patty

    • French Toast $4.99

      French toast slice, 1 bacon strip or sausage patty

  • Beverages
    • Fresh Coffee

    • Decaf Coffee

    • Fresh Brewed Tea

    • Sweet Tea

    • Milk

    • Orange Juice

    • Apple Juice

    • Iced Coffee* $3.69

      Made daily with a custom blend of brewed 100% Arabica beans and fresh whole milk, sweetened with pure cane sugar and served over ice. *Sorry no refills

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.