• New Jersey
  • Califon
  • Nicola's Pizza

Nicola's Pizza

(908) 832-0024
  • 427 County Rd 513, Califon, NJ 07830
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

(908) 832-0024
  • Menu
  • Appetizers
    Appetizers
    • Appetizers for 2 $9.95

      Mozzarella sticks, chicken fingers, fried mushrooms, zucchini sticks and onion rings. No substitutions.

    • Bruschetta $5.25

      Fresh tomatoes, basil and onions.

    • Garlic Bread $2.5

    • Garlic Knots $2.25

      With sauce.

    • Garlic Bread with Cheese $3.5

    • French Fries $3

    • French Fries with Cheese $4

    • French Fries with Gravy and Cheese $4.5

    • French Fries with Bacon and Cheese $4.7

    • Beef Patties $2.5

    • Fried Calamari $8.5

      With lemon.

    • Buffalo Calamari $9.5

    • Calamari Marinara $8.5

    • Fresh Mozzarella Bella $6.95

    • Jalapeno Poppers $5.75

    • 10 Piece Mussels Marinara $8

    • 6 Mozzarella Sticks $6

    • Wings $7

      Plain, hot or BBQ.

    • Boneless Wings $7

      Plain, hot or BBQ.

    • Zucchini Sticks $6

    • Onion Rings $6

    • Fried Mushrooms $6

    • 4 Piece Pierogies $4

    • Chicken Fingers and Fries $7.5

    • Shrimp in a Basket $8.75

    • Stuffed Eggplant $7.25

      Tomatoes, onions, basil, ziti and mozzarella cheese.

  • Homemade Soup
    Homemade Soup
    • Pasta Fajiola Zuppe $3.95

    • Chicken Tortellini Zuppe $3.95

    • Minestrone Zuppe $3.95

    • Chicken Noodle Zuppe $3.95

    • Italian Wedding Zuppe $3.95

    • Chicken Noodle Soup Bowl $3.95

    • Chicken Tortellini Soup Bowl $3.95

    • Italian Wedding Soup Bowl $3.95

    • Minestrone Soup Bowl $3.95

  • Fresh Salads
    Fresh Salads
    • Antipasto Salad $7

    • Caesar Salad $5.75

    • Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato Salad $8.25

    • Garden Salad $5

      Served with your choice of dressing.

    • Chef Salad $7.75

      Topped with roast turkey, American cneese and fresh veggies.

    • Italian Salad $8

      Mixed lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, onion, green olives, roasted peppers, sun-dried tomato, mushrooms and fresh mozzarella.

    • Mixed Salad a la Nicola's $8.95

      Mixed lettuce, cucumber, tomatoes, olives, grilled portobello mushrooms, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella and capicola.

    • Misto Salad $8.75

      Prosciutto, salami, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, artichokes, tomatoes and olives with romaine lettuce.

    • Buffalo Chicken Salad $8.25

    • Greek Salad $7.95

      Tomatoes, onions, black olives and grape leaves, with feta cheese and Greek dressing.

    • Grilled Chicken and Shrimp Salad $9.95

    • Tuna Salad $7.75

    • Turkey Salad $7.75

    • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad $7.95

    • Grilled Chicken Salad $7.75

    • Fresh Mozzarella and Roasted Peppers Salad $8.25

    • Grilled Salmon Salad $8.75

    • Grilled Shrimp Salad $8.75

  • 10" Cold Subs
    10" Cold Subs
    • 10" Italian Sub $6

      Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and vinegar.

    • 10" Ham and Cheese Sub $5.75

      Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and vinegar.

    • 10" Turkey and Cheese Sub $6.5

      Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and vinegar.

    • 10" Caprese Sub $6.75

      Prosciutto, roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella. Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and vinegar.

    • 10" Tuna Fish Sub $6

      Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and vinegar.

    • 10" Roast Beef Sub $6

      Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and vinegar.

    • 10" Roast Beef Sub with Cheese $6.75

      Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and vinegar.

  • 10" Hot Subs
    10" Hot Subs
    • 10" Chicken Cutlet Parm Sub $7

    • 10" Veal Cutlet Parm Sub $7.95

    • 10" Eggplant Parm Sub $6.75

    • 10" Sausage Parm Sub $6.5

    • 10" Shrimp Parm Sub $7.75

    • 10" Meatball Parm Sub $6.5

    • 10" Meatball Sub $6

    • 10" Sausage Sub $7

      Sausage, peppers and onions.

    • 10" Meatball and Peppers Sub $7

      Onions.

    • 10" Sausage and Broccoli Rabe Sub $7

    • 10" Chicken California Sub $7

      Breaded chicken with lettuce, tomato, onions and mayo.

    • 10" Sausage and Egg Sub $6

    • 10" Peppers and Egg Sub $6

    • 10" Sausage Sandwich $6

  • Parmigianas
    Parmigianas
    • Eggplant Rollatini $11.75

      Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, linguini or angel hair.

    • Eggplant Parmigiana $11.5

      Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, linguini or angel hair.

    • Sausage Parmigiana $11.5

      Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, linguini or angel hair.

    • Sausage and Peppers $11.75

      Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, linguini or angel hair.

    • Meatballs and Peppers $11.75

      Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, linguini or angel hair.

    • Meatballs Parmigiana $11.5

      Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, linguini or angel hair.

  • Specialty Pasta
    Specialty Pasta
    • Cavatelli and Broccoli $11.75

      Red or white and oil. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Tortellini and Broccoli $11.75

      Red or white and oil. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Fettuccini Alfredo Sauce $11.75

      Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Fettuccini Primavera $11.75

      With cream sauce or red sauce. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

  • Pasta
    Pasta
    • Pasta with Tomato Sauce $9

      Includes soup or salad and garlic bread. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread. Your choice of spaghetti, penne, linguini or angel hair.

    • Pasta with Marinara $9

      Includes soup or salad and garlic bread. Your choice of spaghetti, penne, linguini or angel hair.

    • Pasta with Meat Sauce $10.5

      Includes soup or salad and garlic bread. Your choice of spaghetti, penne, linguini or angel hair.

    • Pasta with Vodka Sauce $11.25

      Includes soup or salad and garlic bread. Your choice of spaghetti, penne, linguini or angel hair.

    • Pasta with Broccoli $11

      White or red. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread. Your choice of spaghetti, penne, linguini or angel hair.

    • Pasta with Garlic and Oil $9

      Includes soup or salad and garlic bread. Your choice of spaghetti, penne, linguini or angel hair.

    • Pasta with Garlic, Oil and Anchovies $10

      Includes soup or salad and garlic bread. Your choice of spaghetti, penne, linguini or angel hair.

    • Pasta with Meatball $11.25

      Includes soup or salad and garlic bread. Your choice of spaghetti, penne, linguini or angel hair.

    • Pasta with Sausage $11.25

      Includes soup or salad and garlic bread. Your choice of spaghetti, penne, linguini or angel hair.

    • Pasta Arrabbiata $9.5

      Includes soup or salad and garlic bread. Your choice of spaghetti, penne, linguini or angel hair. Hot and spicy.

    • Pasta with Butter Sauce $9

      Includes soup or salad and garlic bread. Your choice of spaghetti, penne, linguini or angel hair.

    • Penne Rustico $11.25

      Sauteed garlic, mushrooms, roasted peppers, basil, eggplant, wine and light marinara sauce. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Rigatoni Sicilian $11.25

      Sauteed mushrooms, spinach, sausage, spices and pink sauce with brandy. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

  • Baked Pasta
    Baked Pasta
    • Manicotti $11.75

      3 pieces. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Baked Penne $11.75

      Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Baked Ziti $11.75

      With ricotta and mozzarella. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Penne Sicilian Style $11.75

      Eggplant, mozzarella and ricotta cheese. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • 6 Piece Stuffed Shells $11.75

      Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Lasagna $11.75

      With meat sauce and mushrooms. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Tortellini Alfredo $11.75

      Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Spinach Ravioli $11.75

      Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Cheese Ravioli $11.75

      Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Baked Tortellini $11.75

      With Alfredo or red sauce. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Cavatelli $11.75

      With red sauce. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Gnocchi $11.75

      With red sauce. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Lobster Ravioli $11.75

      With vodka sauce. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Penne Formaggio $11.75

      Penne pasta tossed in Gorgonzola, Pecorino Romano, provolone and mozzarella cheese in a white cream sauce then baked. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

  • Wraps
    Wraps
    • Caprese Wrap $7.75

      Prosciutto, roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella. With french fries, lettuce, tomato and onion.

    • Chicken Caesar Wrap $7.75

      With french fries, lettuce, tomato and onion.

    • Tuna Salad Wrap $7.75

      With french fries, lettuce, tomato and onion.

    • Buffalo Chicken Wrap $7.75

      With french fries, lettuce, tomato and onion.

    • Cheesesteak Wrap $7.75

      With french fries, lettuce, tomato and onion.

    • Roasted Vegetables Wrap $7.75

      With french fries, lettuce, tomato and onion.

    • Shrimp and Broccoli Wrap $7.75

      With french fries, lettuce, tomato and onion.

    • Grilled Turkey Wrap $7.75

      With french fries, lettuce, tomato and onion.

    • Crispy Chicken and Bacon in Ranch Wrap $7.75

      With french fries, lettuce, tomato and onion.

    • New York Wrap $7.75

      Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and fresh basil. With french fries, lettuce, tomato and onion.

  • From the Grill
    From the Grill
    • Steak Sandwich $6

    • Plain Cheesesteak $6.5

    • Cheesesteak and Mushrooms $6.75

    • Cheesesteak and Peppers $6.75

    • Cheesesteak and Onions $6.75

    • House Special Cheesesteak $8

    • Chicken Cheesesteak $7

    • Cheesesteak California $7.75

      Lettuce, tomato, mayo and onion.

    • Grilled Chicken California $7.75

      Lettuce, tomato, mayo and onions.

    • Sausage and Broccoli Rabe $7

    • Grilled Chicken and Eggplant Sandwich $7.5

      With fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and balsamic dressing.

    • Hamburger $4

    • Brooklyn Sub $7.75

      Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella and basil.

    • Gyros $6

      With french fries.

    • Italian Hot Dog $6.5

    • House Italian Sausage $6.75

      With peppers, mushrooms and potatoes.

  • Burgers
    Burgers
    • Trattoria Burger $7.95

      Roasted peppers, mozzarella cheese and pesto mayo. Served with french fries, lettuce, tomato and onions.

    • BBQ Burger $7.95

      Sliced raw onions, bacon, provolone cheese and BBQ sauce. Served with french fries, lettuce, tomato and onions.

    • Mama Mia Burger $7.95

      Grilled mushrooms, provolone cheese and bacon. Served with french fries, lettuce, tomato and onions.

    • Godfather Burger $7.95

      Grilled mushrooms, fried onions, mozzarella and light marinara sauce. Served with french fries, lettuce, tomato and onions.

    • Spicy Buffalo Chicken Burger $7.95

      Bleu cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion. Served with french fries.

    • Chicken Ranch Sandwich $7.95

      Ranch dressing, lettuce, tomato and onion. Served with french fries.

    • Cheeseburger Deluxe $7.95

      With lettuce, tomato and onion. Served with french fries.

  • Paninis
    Paninis
    • 1. Clasico Panini $7.95

      Grilled chicken, roasted peppers and provolone cheese. Grilled and served hot with side of french fries.

    • 2. Godfather Panini $7.95

      Breaded chicken, provolone cheese, salami, oil and vinegar. Grilled and served hot with side of french fries.

    • 3. Capri Panini $7.95

      Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, grilled portobello mushrooms, basil and olive oil. Grilled and served hot with side of french fries.

    • 4. Sicilian Panini $7.95

      Grilled eggplant, portobello mushrooms, prosciutto, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella and Italian spices. Grilled and served hot with side of french fries.

    • 5. Panini a la Roma $7.95

      Breaded chicken, spinach, sun-dried tomatoes and Italian spices. Grilled and served hot with side of french fries.

    • 6. Costra Azzura Panini $7.95

      Grilled shrimp, spinach, tomato and melted provolone cheese. Grilled and served hot with side of french fries.

    • 7. Grilled Veggie Panini $7.95

      Grilled portobello mushrooms, zucchini, eggplant, roasted pepper and balsamic vinegar, sprinkled with Parmigiana cheese. Grilled and served hot with side of french fries.

    • 8. Grilled Roast Beef Panini $7.95

      With American cheese, fresh mozzarella and Italian spices. Grilled and served hot with side of french fries.

    • 9. New York Panini $7.95

      Grilled chicken, eggplant, roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella with Italian spices. Grilled and served hot with side of french fries.

    • 10. Bethlehem Panini $7.95

      Grilled chicken, capicola, portobello mushrooms, ham and provolone cheese. Grilled and served hot with side of french fries.

    • 11. Italian Panini $7.95

      Ham, salami, capicola and provolone. Grilled and served hot with side of french fries.

    • 12. Riviera Panini $7.95

      Grilled chicken, field greens, fresh mozzarella and sun-dried tomatoes. Grilled and served hot with side of french fries.

  • Round Pizza
    Round Pizza
    • Plain Pizza $10.5

    • Plain White Pizza $12.95

      With ricotta.

    • Chicken and Bacon Pizza $15

      In ranch.

    • Seafood Pizza $15.95

    • BLT Pizza $14.5

    • Chicken Salad Pizza $14

    • Nicola's Special Pizza $15

    • Stuffed Pizza $15

      Meat or veggie.

    • White Pizza with Broccoli $13.95

    • White Pizza with Fresh Tomato $13.95

    • Vegetable Special Pizza $15

    • Baked Ziti Pizza $15

    • Taco Pizza $14

    • Tortellini Pizza $15

    • 4-Cheese Pizza $14

    • German Pizza $14

      Steak, onions and hot peppers.

    • Chicken Parmigiana $14

    • Cheesesteak Pizza $14

      Peppers, onions, mushrooms and yellow cheddar cheese.

    • Chicken Vodka Pizza $14

    • Chicken Penne Vodka Pizza $14

    • Margherita Pizza $14

    • Hawaiian Pizza $14

    • White Spinach Pizza $13.95

    • Eggplant Pizza $13

      With ricotta.

    • Pepperoni, Bacon, Onion and Pepper Pizza $15.5

    • Crispino Pizza $15

      Roasted pepper, diced tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil and olive oil. No sauce.

    • Salad Pizza $14

    • Buffalo Pizza $14

  • Sicilian Pizza
    Sicilian Pizza
    • Plain Sicilian Pizza $14

    • Famous Upside Down Pizza $14.95

    • Marinelli's Special Pizza $19

    • Vegetable Special Pizza $19

    • Grandma Pie Sicilian $14

  • Gluten-Free Pizza
    Gluten-Free Pizza
    • Gluten-Free Pizza $10.95

  • Personal Pizza
    Personal Pizza
    • Plain Personal Pizza $6

    • Special Personal Pizza $10

    • Plain White Personal Pizza $7

      With ricotta.

  • 18" Pan Pizza
    18" Pan Pizza
    • 18" Pan Pizza $16

    • 18" Chicken, Broccoli and Tomato Pan Pizza $19.95

    • 18" Buffalo Chicken Pan Pizza $19.95

    • 18" Chicken, Bacon and Ranch Pan Pizza $19.95

    • 18" BBQ Chicken Pan Pizza $19.95

    • 18" Bruschetta Pan Pizza $17.95

      Tomato, basil and garlic.

    • 18" Chicken Marsala Pan Pizza $19.95

    • 18" Cheeseburger with Bacon Pan Pizza $18.5

    • 18" Chicken Parmigiana Pan Pizza $19.95

    • 18" Stuffed Chicken and Vodka Penne Pan Pizza $19.95

  • Calzones
    Calzones
    • Calzone $6

      Filled with mozzarella and ricotta.

    • Meat Lover's Calzone $7.95

      Meatballs, sausage, ham, salami and pepperoni.

  • Strombolis and Rolls
    Strombolis and Rolls
    • Meat Stromboli $7

      Filled with ham, salami, sausage and pepperoni.

    • Sausage Roll $7

      Filled with sausage, peppers, onions and mozzarella.

    • Italian Roll $7

      Filled with ham, salami, pepperoni and mozzarella.

    • Pepperoni Roll $7

    • Chicken and Mozzarella Roll $7

    • Veggie Roll $7

  • Veal and Chicken
    Veal and Chicken
    • Parmigiana $12.95

      Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, or linguini.

    • Francese $12.95

      Dipped in egg batter, sauteed in butter and lemon. Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, or linguini.

    • Marsala $12.95

      Sauteed with mushrooms and Marsala wine. Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, or linguini.

    • Sorrentino $12.95

      Sauteed and topped with spinach, prosicutto, eggplant, mozzarella cheese and laced with a delicate wine sauce. Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, or linguini.

    • Piccata $12.95

      Tender slices of chicken or veal sauteed in white wine and lemon with capers. Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, or linguini.

    • A la Doros $12.95

      Sauteed chicken or veal with shrimp, mushrooms, garlic and Italian spices, in lemon sauce with a touch of oregano. Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, or linguini.

    • Caruso $12.95

      Dipped in egg batter, sauteed in butter, artichokes, fresh tomatoes, prosciutto, a brandy brown sauce and baked with mozzarella. Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, or linguini.

    • Leone $12.95

      Sauteed chicken or veal with mushrooms and artichokes in a Francese sauce. Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, or linguini.

    • Madaglina $12.95

      Sauteed mushrooms, asparagus, roasted peppers, Marsala wine and cream sauce over fettuccini. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Broccoli $12.95

      Broccoli sauteed in light marinara sauce. Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, or linguini.

    • Michael $12.95

      Sauteed mushrooms, peas and prosciutto, in a sherry wine pink sauce. Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, or linguini.

    • Saltimbocca a la Romano $12.95

      Prosciutto and spinach, sauteed with delicate wine sauce and topped with mozzarella. Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, or linguini.

    • Reale $12.95

      Topped with eggplant and mozzarella. Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, or linguini.

    • Florentina $12.95

      Sauteed in white wine, topped with fresh tomato, spinach and mozzarella cheese in a light red sauce. Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, or linguini.

    • Alfredo $12.95

      With broccoli and sweet peas in Alfredo sauce. Includes soup or salad, garlic bread and your choice of penne, spaghetti, or linguini.

    • Murphy $12.95

      Mushrooms, onions, peppers and potatoes, in a light wine sauce over penne. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Vodka $12.95

      Chicken or veal with penne in vodka sauce. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

  • Seafood Entrees
    Seafood Entrees
    • Zuppa di Pesce $16.95

      Over linguini, spaghetti or penne, shrimp, calamari, mussels and clams, in a light red sauce. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Shrimp Parmigiana $14.5

      With side order linguini. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Shrimp Marinara Sauce $14.5

      Over linguini. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Shrimp Fra Diavolo $14.5

      With red sauce over linguini. Hot. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Shrimp Scampi $14.5

      With white wine and lemon sauce over linguini. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Shrimp Broccoli $14.5

      White or red sauce over penne. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Shrimp Alfredo Sauce $14.5

      Fresh peas over linguini. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Shrimp del Contadino $15.5

      Shrimp sauteed with artichokes and black olives in garlic and olive oil, over angel hair. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Seafood Frivlani $15.95

      Sauteed shrimp and tilapia with roasted red peppers and mushrooms, in a cream sauce over angel hair. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Mussels and Clams $14.5

      With red sauce over linguini. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Clams and Calamari $14.5

      With red sauce over linguini. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Clams and Shrimp $14.5

      With red sauce over linguini. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Calamari Marinara $14.5

      Over linguini with light sauce. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Linguini $14.5

      With clam sauce. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Mussels $14.5

      In white or red sauce over linguini. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Shrimp Francese $14.5

      With white wine and butter lemon sauce. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Shrimp alla Rudy $14.5

      Sauteed with zucchini, onions and garlic, sun-dried tomatoes and peas in a pink sauce over penne. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Salmon Primavera $14.5

      Pink sauce over linguini. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

    • Shrimp and Scallops Mediterraneo $15.5

      Shrimp and scallops sauteed with garlic, olive oil, capers and fresh plum tomatoes, in a white wine sauce, over angel hair. Includes soup or salad and garlic bread.

  • Sides
    Sides
    • Broccoli $4

      Steamed with olive oil and garlic.

    • Broccoli Rabe $5

    • Spinach $4

      Steamed with olive oil and garlic.

    • Meatballs $4

    • Sausage $4

  • Kids Menu (Children Under 12 Only)
    Kids Menu (Children Under 12 Only)
    • Kid's Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce $4.25

    • Kid's Spaghetti with Meatball $5.5

    • Kid's Spaghetti with Sausage $5.5

    • Kid's Ravioli $5.5

      3 pieces.

    • Kid's Baked Penne $5.5

    • Kid's Penne $5.5

      With broccoli.

    • Kid's Hot Dogs $5

      With french fries.

    • Kid's Stuffed Shells $5.5

      3 pieces.

    • Kid's Chicken Fingers $5

      With french fries.

    • Kid's Cheeseburger $5.75

      With french fries.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.