Nicky's menu - Bay Shore NY 11706 - (631) 206-3311

Menu

Barges
- Clam Barge $14.5
  
  Plate of fresh shucked fried hard shell clams
- Clam Barge with French Fries or Cole Slaw $16.5
- Flounder Barge $15
  
  2 Fried filets
- Flounder Barge with French Fries or Cole Slaw $17
- Scallop Barge $17
  
  Fried bay scallops
- Scallop Barge with French Fries or Cole Slaw $17
- Oyster Barge $15
  
  Shucked fried oysters
- Oyster Barge with French Fries or Cole Slaw $17
- Shrimp Barge $17
  
  4 Enormous fried shrimp
- Shrimp Barge with French Fries or Cole Slaw $19
- Crab Cake Barge $13.75
  
  2 Fried maryland style crab cakes served over cole slaw
- Crab Cake Barge with French Fries $15.75

Super Starters
- Clams on the 1/2 Shell $7.5
  
  Your choice of little necks, top necks or cherry stones
- Freshly Shucked Oysters on the 1/2 Shell $10
- Cold Combo $17
  
  3 Little neck clams, 3 oysters and 3 jumbo shrimp cocktail
- Clams Casino $8.25
  
  Baked whole little neck clams with bread crumbs and bacon
- Steamed Little Neck Clams $8.25
  
  Steamed in white wine and garlic sauce.
- Clams Oreganata $8.25
  
  Little neck clams baked with garlic bread crumbs
- Baked Stuffed Clams (3) $6.75
- Crab Cakes $13.75
  
  2 Maryland style crab cakes served over a bed of cole slaw with texas petal sauce.
- Fried Calamarl $12.25
  
  Lightly fried, served with lemon & marinara sauce
- Fried Mozzarella Sticks (6) $6
  
  Served with marinara sauce
- Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail (4) $16
  
  Jumbo chilled shrimp served with cocktail sauce
- Mussels $15
  
  Choice of white wine and garlic or marinara, served with fresh italian bread for dipping
- Steamers $19.75
  
  Tastiest steamers on the island served with our famous broth and drawn butter
- Specialty Platter for Two $17.75
  
  Clams, oysters and shrimp oreganata, chicken fingers, mozzarella sticks, calamari and chicken wings
- Boneless Buffalo Chicken Tenders $9.5
  
  Served with bleu cheese, carrots and celery
- Hot Wings (12 wings) $8.75
  
  Served with bleu cheese, carrots and celery
- Chicken Fries $6.75
  
  Chicken in the shape of french fries served with marinara sauce for dipping

Salads

Homemade house dressings: bleu cheese, thousand island, creamy garlic, french onion, balsamic vinaigrette
- Greek Salad $8
- Greek Salad with Chicken $9.5
- Greek Salad with Shrimp $18
- Caesar Salad $8
- Caesar Salad with Chicken $10.5
- Caesar Salad with Shrimp $18
- Tossed Garden Salad $5

Cold Salads

Served open style with small side garden salad, with potato salad and cole slaw.
- Shrimp Salad $15.75
- Crab Meat Salad $15.75
- Tuna Salad $12.5
- Combination Shrimp and Crab $15.75
- Chicken Salad $12.5

Soups
- Manhattan Clam Chowder $5
  
  Famous red clam chowder
- Clam Bisque $5
  
  Creamy white style clam chowder
- Corn Chowder $5
  
  Creamy corn and vegetable soup
- Black Bean Soup $5
- Seafood Bisque Nicky's Ultimate $6.75
  
  Creamy pink seafood soup with lobster, shrimp and crabmeat
- Soup of the Day $5

Sandwiches

Served on white, whole wheat, rye, roll or wrap with potato salad and cole slaw
- Shrimp Salad $11
- Crab Meat Salad $11.5
- Tuna Salad $10
- Chicken Salad $9
- Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato $8
- Turkey Club $10.25
- Turkey and Cheese $8.5
- Ham and Cheese $8.5
- Roast Beef and Cheese $8.5

Seafood Sandwiches

Served open style with small side garden salad, with potato salad and cole slaw
- Fried Shrimp (5) $21.5
- Fried Scallops $17.5
- Fried Flounder $17.5
- Fried Oysters $18.5
- Fried Hard Shell Clams $18.5
  
  Fresh shucked
- Soft Shell Crabs (2) $18
  
  Sauteed or fried

Grilled Ones
- Grilled Cheese Sandwich $5
- Grilled Ham and Cheese Sandwich $5.5
- Hot Dog $3
- Chicken Cuttlet $8.5
  
  Served grilled or fried with lettuce & tomato
- Flounder On a Roll $10
  
  Served broiled or fried.
- Solt Shell Crab $10
  
  Fried or sauteed served on a toll

Burgers Galore
- Hamburger (4 Oz) $5.25
- Cheeseburger (4 Oz) $5.75
- Hamburger Deluxe $9
  
  Served with a side garden salad, french fries and cole slaw.
- Cheeseburger Deluxe $9.5
  
  Served with a side garden salad, french fries and cole slaw.
- Turkey Burger $5.5
  
  Served with lettuce and tomato
- Turkey Cheeseburger $6
  
  Served with lettuce and tomato
- Bison Burger $5.5
  
  Served with lettuce and tomato
- Bison Cheeseburger $6
  
  Served with lettuce and tomato
- BBQ 8 Oz Bacon Cheeseburger $7.25
  
  With our hickory BBQ sauce served on a hard roll

From the Broiler
- Broiled Flounder $24
  
  Fresh and delicately broiled with light garlic and butter
- Stuned Flounder $25
  
  Stuffed with snow crab meat stuffing
- Stuned Shrimp $30
  
  (5) Enormous shrimp with snow crab meat stuffing
- Shrimp Scampi $30
  
  (6) Enormous shrimp in a butter garlic wine sauce
- Sauteed Scallops Oreganata $23
  
  Fresh bay scallops sauteed in garlic and wine sauce
- Seafood Au Gratin $26
  
  Crab meat, lobster meat and (2) jumbo shrimp in a creamy white sauce with melted cheddar and monterey jack cheese
- Fish of the Day $26
- Flounder Oreganata $24.5
  
  Broiled with light garlic bread crumbs

Fresh Fried Seafood Dinners
- Fried Warm Shell Clams $21.75
  
  Freshly shucked and lightly breaded top neck clams
- Fried Oysters $23
  
  Freshly shucked and breaded
- Fried Scallops $23
  
  Fresh bay scallops lightly breaded
- Fried or Sauteed Soft Shell Crabs (3) $23
  
  Frozen, only served when in season
- Fried Flounder $23
  
  Golden filets of fresh flounder lightly breaded
- Fried Combination Planer $30
  
  Scallops, oysters, clams, flounder and two jumbo fried shrimp
- Coconut Fried Shrimp $30
  
  (5) Golden brown enormous battered coconut shrimp
- Fried Shrimp $30
  
  6 Enormous fried shrimp

live from our Tank
- Lobster Dinner
  
  Steamed or broiled, stuffed $5.50 extra

Italian Seafood Dinners

Served with garden salad and garlic bread
- Shrimp Parmigiana $29
  
  Werved with linguini
- Flounder Parmigiana $24
  
  Served with linguini
- Fried Calamari $21
  
  Served with linguini
- Linguini with Red or White Clam Sauce $21.75
  
  freshly shucked chopped clams over a pile of linguini, cooked to perfection

Sides
- Fresh Corn on the Cob $3.5
- Baked Potato $3.5
- Garlic Bread $1.75
- Cajun Fries $4.5
  
  Seasoned not spicy
- Tossed Garden Salad $5.25
- Cole Slaw $2.75
- Potato Salad $2.75
- French Fries $3.5
- Onion Rings $4.5
- Fried Shrimp $4.5
- Sauteed Broccoli $4
- Sauteed Spinach $4
- Rice $3.5

Lover's Specials

Served with garden salad, garlic bread and choice of one: baked potato, french fries, fresh corn on the cob, cajun french fries, spinach, broccoli or rice
- Steak Dinner $30
  
  Marinated or plain giant aged shell steak grilled to your liking
- BBQ Boneless Pork Chops $18.5
  
  Grilled with our hickory BBQ sauce topped with crispy onions
- Roasted Half Chicken $18.5
  
  Roasted in garlic lemon and herbs or hickory BBQ style
- Chicken Parmigiana $19.5
  
  Served with linguini or choice of one side dish listed above