• New York
  • Bay Shore
  • Pizza on the Bay

Pizza on the Bay

(631) 665-0900
  • 316 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
  • Website
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • Pizza
  • $$$$$
(631) 665-0900
  • Menu
  • Pizza
    • Plain Cheese Pizza $14.55

    • White Pizza $19.25

  • Specialty Pizza
    • Pizza on the Bay Cheese Steak Pizza $21.75

      Mozzarella Cheese, Tomato Sauce, Steak Spinach, Mushroom, Roasted Peppers & Garlic.

    • Pizza on the Bay Chicken Steak Pizza $21.75

      Mozzarella Cheese, Tomato Sauce, Chicken, Spinach, Mushroom, Roasted Peppers & Garlic.

    • Cheese Steak Pizza $20

      Mozzarella Cheese, Tomato Sauce, Steak.

    • Cheese Chicken Pizza $20

      Mozzarella Cheese, Tomato Sauce, Chicken.

    • Cheese Steak Sub Pizza $21.75

      Mozzarella Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Steak.

    • Chicken Cheese Sub Pizza $21.75

      Mozzarella Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Chicken.

    • Buffalo Chicken Steak Pizza $20.5

      Mozzarella Cheese, Chicken, Hot Sauce with Blue Cheese.

    • Meat Lover's Pizza $23

      Pepperoni, Ham, Meatball, Sausage, Bacon.

    • The Work's $25

      Onion, Pepperoni, Green Pepper, Meatballs, Sausage, Mushroom.

    • Grand MA Pizza $14

  • Stromboli & Calzone
    • Stromboli $10

      Mozzarella Cheese, Red Sauce or Ricotta Cheese.

    • Stromboli $15.25

      Ham, Salami, Sausage.

    • Stromboli with Steak $15.25

    • Stromboli with the Work's $15.5

      6 Different Toppings: Onion, Pepperoni, Green Pepper, Meatballs, Sausage, Mushroom.

    • Chicken Fajita Stromboli $15

      Grilled Chicken, Green Pepper, Hot Sauce, Fried Onions.

    • Pizza Turnover $5

    • Calzone $5

  • Gourmet Pizza
    • Chicken Pizza $17.75

      Roasted Peppers, Basil & Garlic.

    • Hawaiian Pizza $17.75

      Pineapple, Ham, Cheese, Sauce.

    • Veggie Pizza $19

      Broccoli, Spinach, Tomatoes, Mushroom, Onion.

    • La Classico $14.75

      Plum Tomatoes, Garlic, Basil.

    • Taco Pizza $20.25

      Ground Beef, Hot Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onion.

    • Baked Ziti Pizza $16.75

  • Burgers
    • Hamburger $4.29

    • Cheeseburger $4.79

    • Pizza Burger $5.29

    • Bacon Cheese Burger $5.99

    • Cheeseburger Deluxe with French Fries $6.49

      Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions.

    • Cheeseburger Sub $7.99

      Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onion on a Long Roll.

    • Turkey Burger $5.29

    • Turkey Cheeseburger $5.79

  • Steaks
    • Pizza on the Bay Cheese Steak $7.75

      Spinach, Mushroom, Roasted Pepper, Served on Toasted Garlic Bread.

    • Steak $5.5

    • Cheese Steak $6.25

    • Steak Sub $6.5

    • Cheese Steak Sub $7

    • Pizza Steak $7

    • Steak Special $7.5

      Cheese, Green Pepper, Fried Onion, Mushroom.

  • Chicken Steaks
    • Pizza on the Bay Chicken Steak $7.75

      Spinach, Mushroom, Roasted Pepper, Served on Roasted Garlic Bread.

    • Chicken Steak $5.5

    • Chicken Cheese Steak $6.25

    • Chicken Cheese Steak Sub $7

    • Chicken Pizza Steak $7

    • Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak $7.25

      With Blue Cheese & Hot Sauce.

    • Grilled Chicken Steak Sub $7.28

    • Grilled Chicken BBQ Steak $6.95

    • Grilled Cajun Chicken Steak $6.75

    • Grilled Chicken Caesar $6.98

      With Lettuce, & Caesar Dressing.

  • Subs
    Served with Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Salt, Peppers & Oregano.
    • 3 Cheese Sub $5.95

      Mozzarella, Provolone, American Cheese.

    • American $7.99

      Ham, Salami, American Cheese.

    • Italian Sub $7.99

      Ham, Salami, Cappicola, Provolone Cheese.

    • Tuna Sub with Cheese $7.88

    • Turkey Sub with Cheese $7.58

    • Ham & Cheese sub $7.58

    • Roast Beef with Cheese $7.84

  • Club Sandwiches
    • Roast Beef Club $8.75

    • Turkey Club $8.25

    • B.L.T Club $6.5

    • Chicken Club $8.5

    • Ham Club $8.25

    • Combo Club $9.25

      Ham, Salami, Capicola

  • Hot Sandwiches
    • Hot Roast Beef $6.75

    • Meatball with Sauce $5.45

    • Meatball Parmigiano $6.25

    • Sausage with Sauce $5.45

    • Sausage Parmigiano $6.25

    • Sausage & Green Peppers $6.25

    • Veal Cutlet with Sauce $6.75

    • Veal Cutlet Parmigiano $7.25

    • Chicken Parmigiano $8.96

    • Green Pepper & Egg $5.75

    • Veal & Green Peppers $7.25

    • Eggplant Parmigiano $6.25

    • Hot Veggie Sandwich $6.75

      Broccoli, Spinach, Tomatoes, Mushrooms, Sweet Peppers, Provolone Cheese & Garlic.

    • Chicken Cutlet Sub $7.28

      Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onion.

    • Shrimp Parm $7.75

  • Salads
    Romanian Lettuce, Head Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Black Olives.
    • Antipasto $5.95

      Salami, Ham, Provolone Cheese.

    • Chef Salad $7.55

      Turkey, Ham, American Cheese.

    • 3 Cheese Salad $6.95

      Mozzarella, Provolone, Cheese, American Cheese.

    • House Garden Salad $4.95

    • House Garden Salad with Grilled Chicken $7.34

    • House Garden Salad with Tuna $7.34

    • Caesar Salad $5.95

    • Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken $8.08

    • Greek Salad with Feta Cheese $5.95

  • Baked Dishes
    Served with Salad, Dressing & Roll.
    • Baked Ziti $8.25

    • Manicotti Parm $10

    • Homemade Lasagna with Meat $9.5

    • Ravioli $7.95

    • Ravioli Parm $9.7

    • Stuffed Shells Parm $10

    • Veal Parm $12.5

    • Chicken Parm $11.5

    • Eggplant Parm $11.5

    • Shrimp Parm $13.5

  • Spaghetti, Ziti & Linguini
    Served with Salad & Roll.
    • Pasta with Tomato Sauce $7.5

    • Pasta with Oil & Garlic $7.5

    • Pasta with 3 Sausage $10.25

    • Pasta with 3 Meatballs $10.25

    • Pasta with Clam Sauce $10.5

    • Pasta Alfredo $11.5

      Broccoli, Chicken, Heavy Cream.

    • Pasta Caccitori $9.5

      Green Pepper, Mushroom, Onion & Red or Hot Sauce.

    • Chicken Caccitori $12.25

  • Buffalo Wings
    Served with Blue Cheese & Celery.
    • Buffalo Wings $3.75

    • Buffalo Wings $25

  • Appetizers
    • Garlic Bread $2.25

    • Garlic Bread with Cheese $3

    • Garlic Knots $1.75

      Oil & garlic.

    • Zeppolis $1.75

  • Side Orders
    • French Fries $1.99

    • Cheese Fries $2.75

    • Pizza Fries $3.5

    • Curley Fries $3.5

    • Cheese Curley Fries $4.25

    • Chicken Fingers $7.75

      With French Fries & Honey Mustard.

    • Chicken Nuggets $5.5

      With French Fries.

    • Jalapeno Peppers $5

      With Marinara Sauce.

    • Combo Basket $9.5

      3 Wings, 3 Chicken Fingers, 3 Mozzarella Sticks, 3 Onion Rings, French Fries.

    • Chicken Chips $5.49

    • Fish & Chips $5.99

    • Fried Mushrooms $5.25

      With Ranch or Marinara Sauce.

    • Shrimp Basket with French Fries $7.95

    • Fried Shrimp $6.99

    • Fried Calamari $6.97

    • Small Dinner Salad with Dressing $2.79

  • Kids Menu
    • Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce $4

    • Spaghetti with Butter $4

    • Ravioli $5.25

      4 Cheese Filled Pillows

    • Chicken Fingers $5.5

      With French Fries.

    • Grilled Cheese with French Fries $5.75

    • Hot Don with French Fries $4.25

    • Chicken Nuggets $4.25

      7 Nuggets with French Fries.

  • Beverages
    • Soda $1.75

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.