• New York
  • Bay Shore
  • Peter Pan Diner

Peter Pan Diner

(631) 665-1788
  • 999 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706
  • Grubhub.com
  • Menu
  • Beverages
    • Coffee $2.25

    • Tea $2.25

    • Decaf Coffee $2.35

    • Hot Chocolate $2.39

      Come with whipped cream.

    • Milk $2.69

    • Chocolate Milk $2.89

    • Iced Coffee $3.25

    • Iced Tea $3.25

    • Soft Drink $3.25

  • Breakfast Wraps
    • 3 Scrambled Eggs Wrap Breakfast $12.39

      3 scrambled eggs with a choice of up to 3 ingredients. Served with home fries and salsa.

  • Eggs and Omelettes
    • 2 Eggs $6.69

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • 2 Eggs with Ham $9.69

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • 2 Eggs with Sausage $9.69

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • 2 Eggs with Bacon $9.69

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • 2 Eggs with Canadian Bacon $10.29

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • 2 Eggs with Corned Beef Hash $10.69

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • American Cheese Omelette $10.29

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • Swiss Cheese Omelette $10.29

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • Mozzarella Cheese Omelette $10.29

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • Cheddar Cheese Omelette $10.29

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • Feta Cheese Omelette $10.29

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • Spanish Omelette $9.79

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • Western Omelette $10.29

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • Tomato and Feta Omelette $11.69

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • Ham Omelette $10.59

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • Bacon Omelette $10.59

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • Sausage Omelette $10.59

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • Ham and Cheese Omelette $11.69

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • Bacon and Cheese Omelette $11.69

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • Sausage and Cheese Omelette $11.69

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • Greek Omelette $11.69

      Comes with spinach, feta and herbs. Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • Farmer Omelette $10.59

      Come with bacon, ham and sausage. Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

    • Mexican Omelette $11.79

      Comes with chili, cheddar cheese and sour cream. Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

  • Create Your Own Omelette
    • Create Your Own Omelette $13.69

      Served with home fries or french fries and toast.

  • Peter Pancakes
    • Pecan Nut Peter Pancakes $10.99

    • Peanut Butter and Chocolate Chip Peter Pancakes $10.99

    • Cinnamon and Raisin Peter Pancakes $10.99

    • Granola Peter Pancakes $10.99

    • Baked Apple and Cinnamon Peter Pancakes $10.99

    • Peter Pancakes Topped with Fresh Fruit $10.99

    • Cranberry and Walnut Peter Pancakes $10.99

    • Banana and Nut Peter Pancakes $10.99

    • Blueberry Almond Peter Pancakes $10.99

    • Banana and Nut Short Peter Pancakes $7.59

    • Blueberry Almond Short Peter Pancakes $7.59

    • Cinnamon and Raisin Short Peter Pancakes $7.59

    • Cranberry and Walnut Short Peter Pancakes $7.59

    • Granola Baked Apple and Cinnamon Short Pancakes $7.59

    • Peanut Butter and Chocolate Chip Short Peter Pancakes $7.59

    • Pecan Nut Short Peter Pancakes $7.59

    • Short Peter Pancakes Topped with Fresh Fruit $7.59

    • Pecan Nut Short Peter Pancakes $9.39

    • Peanut Butter and Chocolate Chip Short Peter Pancakes $9.39

    • Cinnamon and Raisin Short Peter Pancakes $9.39

    • Granola Short Peter Pancakes $9.39

    • Baked Apple and Cinnamon Short Peter Pancakes $9.39

    • Short Peter Pancakes Topped with Fresh Fruit $9.39

    • Cranberry and Walnut Short Peter Pancakes $9.39

    • Banana and Nut Short Peter Pancakes $9.39

    • Blueberry Almond Short Peter Pancakes $9.39

  • Griddle Specialties
    • Traditional Pancakes $7.99

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Traditional Pancakes with Ham $10.99

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Traditional Pancakes with Bacon $10.99

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Traditional Pancakes with Sausage $10.99

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Traditional Pancakes with Ham and 1 Egg $11.99

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Traditional Pancakes Bacon and 1 Egg $11.99

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Traditional Pancakes with Sausage and 1 Egg $11.99

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Traditional Pancakes with Canadian Bacon $11.99

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Short Stack $6.19

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Short Stack with Ham $10.49

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Short Stack with Bacon $10.49

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Short Stack with Sausage $10.49

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Short Stack with Ham and 1 Egg $10.79

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Short Stack with Bacon and 1 Egg $10.79

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Short Stack with Sausage and 1 Egg $10.79

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Pancakes Deluxe $13.79

      Come with 1 egg and ham, bacon and sausage. Served with butter and syrup.

    • French Toast $7.99

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • French Toast with Ham $10.99

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • French Toast with Bacon $10.99

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • French Toast with Sausage $10.99

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • French Toast with Ham and 1 Egg $11.99

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • French Toast with Bacon and 1 Egg $11.99

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • French Toast with Sausage and 1 Egg $11.99

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • French Toast with Canadian Bacon $11.99

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Short French Toast $6.19

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Short French Toast with Ham $10.49

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Short French Toast with Bacon $10.49

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Short French Toast with Sausage $10.49

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Short French Toast with Ham and 1 Egg $10.79

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Short French Toast with Bacon and 1 Egg $10.79

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Short French Toast with Sausage and 1 Egg $10.79

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • French Toast Deluxe $13.79

      Comes with 1 egg and ham, bacon and sausage. Served with butter and syrup.

    • Belgian Waffle $8.19

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Belgian Waffle with Ham $10.89

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Belgian Waffle with Bacon $10.89

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Belgian Waffle with Sausage $10.89

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Belgian Waffle with Canadian Bacon $11.99

      Served with butter and syrup.

    • Belgian Waffle with Fresh Fruit $10.79

      Served with butter and syrup.

  • Appetizers
    • Fried Calamari $13.69

      Served with marinara sauce.

    • Baked Clams $10.79

    • Chicken Wings $11.69

    • Chicken Tenders $11.69

    • Mozzarella Sticks $11.29

    • Potato Skins $9.49

    • Spinach Pie $9.69

    • Cheese Quesadilla $9.59

    • Stuffed Mushrooms $10.79

    • French Fries $5.89

    • French Fries with Melted Cheese $5.89

      Served with your choice of cheese.

    • Sweet Potato Fries $6.49

    • Curly Fries $6.49

    • Onion Rings $6.49

    • Loaded Nachos $12.79

      Topped with chili.

  • Tantalizing Salads
    • Chef's Salad $17.99

      Assorted greens with turkey, ham, roast beef and Swiss with hard boiled egg. Served with toasted pita bread.

    • Fruit-Aki Salad $16.99

      Teriyaki chicken, Mandarin oranges, grape tomatoes, pineapple ring and sliced almonds served over mixed greens. Served with toasted pita bread.

    • California Salad $11.39

      With Jell-O, cottage cheese and fruit salad.

    • Spinach Salad $14.59

      Spinach, mushrooms, bacon, boiled egg and red onion. Served with toasted pita bread.

    • Cobb Salad $17.99

      Diced chicken, bacon, avocado, bleu cheese, hard boiled egg and tomato with red wine vinaigrette. Served with toasted pita bread.

    • Our Famous Greek Salad $13.99

      Topped with feta cheese and Greek olives. Served with toasted pita bread.

    • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad $16.99

      Crisp romaine lettuce, garlic croutons and creamy Caesar dressing over Caesar salad. Served with toasted pita bread.

    • Grilled Salmon Caesar Salad $19.99

      Grilled salmon over Caesar salad. Served with toasted pita bread.

    • Crispy Chicken Salad $16.99

      Fried chicken cutlet strips, romaine lettuce, bacon, cheddar, black olives and cherry tomatoes. Served with toasted pita bread.

    • Santa Fe Cajun Chicken Salad $16.99

      Grilled cajun chicken, crisp romaine lettuce, garlic croutons, Monterey Jack cheese blend, guacamole, sour cream and salsa. Served with toasted pita bread.

    • Diet Grilled Chicken Breast Plate Salad $11.89

      With cottage cheese, broccoli and carrots.

  • Peter Pan Wraps
  • Paninis
    • 1. Peter Pan Panini $14.39

      Chicken, fresh mozzarella, grilled spinach and roasted red peppers. Served with cup of soup or french fries.

    • 2. Veggie Panini $13.79

      Portobello mushrooms, fresh mozzarella, onion, roasted red peppers, black olives and a balsamic glaze. Served with cup of soup or french fries. Vegetarian.

    • 3. Turkey Club Panini $14.39

      Roasted turkey, bacon, tomato, cheddar and roasted red peppers with choice of dressing. Served with cup of soup or french fries.

    • 4. Black Forest Ham Panini $14.39

      Honey maple ham, sharp cheddar and tomato with honey Dijon mustard. Served with cup of soup or french fries.

    • 5. Tuscany Panini $13.79

      Fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella and grilled red peppers served with balsamic vinaigrette dressing. Served with cup of soup or french fries.

  • Hot Dog Heaven and Sandwiches
    • 2 Classic Hot Dogs $7.19

      Comes with choice of toppings. Served with french fries.

    • 2 Chili Cheese Dogs $8.59

      Topped with homemade chili and melted cheddar. Served with french fries.

    • Texas Smoke Sandwich $14.29

      Grilled or fried BBQ chicken with cheddar cheese and bacon on toasted sourdough bread topped with our smoke flavored BBQ sauce. Served with french fries and coleslaw.

    • Reuben Sandwich $13.79

      Corned beef with tangy sauerkraut and melted Swiss grilled on rye bread. Served with potato salad, coleslaw and pickle.

    • The New Champ Sandwich $15.09

      Sliced oven roasted prime rib with melted cheddar cheese and sauteed mushrooms on a toasted hero. Served with french fries.

    • Meatball Parmigiana Hero $12.29

      Served with choice of soup.

    • Black Bean Burrito $12.29

      Rice, beans, guacamole and melted cheddar. Served with french fries.

    • Taco Wrap $13.39

      Choice of meat with lettuce, tomato, cheddar, sour cream and salsa on the side. Served with choice of side.

    • Roman Holiday Quesadilla $16.99

      Grilled shrimp with tomatoes, onions, garlic, mozzarella, olive oil, salsa and sour cream. Served with french fries.

    • Pepperoni Pizza Fries $9.09

      Pepperoni, olive oil and pizza sauce.

    • Fruit-Aki Salad $16.99

      Teriyaki chicken, Mandarin oranges, grape tomatoes, pineapple ring and sliced almonds served over mixed greens.

    • Souvlaki $15.99

      Served with rice pilaf, Greek salad and french fries.

    • Chicken Souvlaki $15.99

      Served with rice pilaf, Greek salad and french fries.

    • Gyro $12.99

      On pita. Served with rice pilaf or french fries and Greek salad.

    • Chicken Gyro $12.99

      On pita. Served with rice pilaf or french fries and Greek salad.

    • Cowboy Burger $12.89

      Mushrooms, fried onions, bacon and pepper jack cheese. Served with french fries.

    • Sliced London Broil Sandwich Deluxe $19.49

      On garlic bread with french fries, lettuce, tomato and coleslaw.

    • Tuna Melt $10.69

      Topped with choice of cheese.

  • Specialty Sandwiches
    • Grilled Chicken Italian Style Sandwich $12.99

      Served with bacon and mozzarella on a roll with lettuce, tomato, french fries, coleslaw and a pickle.

    • Grilled Chicken American Style Sandwich $12.99

      Served with ham and American cheese on a roll with lettuce, tomato, french fries, coleslaw and a pickle.

    • Grilled Chicken Parmigiana Style Sandwich $12.99

      Tomato sauce and mozzarella on a roll with lettuce, tomato, french fries, coleslaw and a pickle.

  • Triple Deckers
    • Sliced Turkey and Bacon Triple Decker $13.79

      Served with coleslaw and a pickle.

    • Chicken Salad and Bacon Triple Decker $13.79

      Come with lettuce and tomato. Served with coleslaw and a pickle.

  • Burger Corner
    • Jumbo Burger $7.49

      Served on a toasted bun with coleslaw and a pickle.

    • Twin Burger Deluxe $16.39

      Two Burgers with choice of Fries

  • Specialty Burgers
    • Cubano Burger $12.89

      Jack Daniels pulled pork, Swiss cheese and diced pineapple. Served with choice of side.

    • Cali Burger $12.89

      Fresh sliced avocado, bacon and melted Swiss cheese. Served with choice of side.

    • "Good Ol" Classic Favorite Pattie Melt Burger $12.89

      Served on toasted rye bread, smothered with fried onions, American cheese and Thousand Island dressing. Served with choice of side.

    • Cowboy Burger $12.89

      Mushrooms, fried onions, bacon and pepper jack cheese. Served with choice of side.

    • The Mexi Max Burger $12.89

      Jalapenos, pepper jack cheese, guacamole, bacon and tomatoes. Served with choice of side.

    • The Unique Greek Burger $12.89

      Feta, Kalamata olives and plum tomatoes, all spiced with Greek oregano. Served with choice of sauce and side.

    • Siciliano Burger $12.89

      Fresh grilled spinach, tomato and onion bruschetta, mozzarella cheese and a touch of balsamic glaze. Served with choice of side.

    • Lone Star Chili Cheeseburger $12.89

      Loaded with chili and cheddar cheese served with sour cream and salsa. Served with choice of side.

    • Call the Fire Department Burger $12.89

      Hot chili peppers, pepper jack cheese and sliced ham served with Frank's Red Hot sauce. Served with choice of side.

    • Call My Doctor Burger $13.39

      Chunky bleu cheeseburger with bacon. Served with choice of side.

    • Peter Pan's Classic Sliders $10.29

      4 sliders on warm buns with grilled onions and french fries. Served with choice of side.

  • Quesadillas
    • South of the Border Quesadilla $13.79

      Chili, beans, fresh spinach, 3 cheeses, salsa and sour cream.

    • Chicken Quesadilla $13.79

      Grilled chicken, sauteed peppers, onions, blend of 3 cheeses, salsa and sour cream.

    • Garden of Eatin Quesadilla $14.29

      Grilled fresh spinach with garlic, tomatoes, onions and black beans sauteed in olive oil with choice of cheese, salsa and sour cream. Vegetarian.

    • Roman Holiday Quesadilla $16.99

      Grilled shrimp with tomatoes, onions, garlic, mozzarella, olive oil, salsa and sour cream.

    • Mediterranean Sunset Quesadilla $15.39

      Grilled chicken sauteed with tomatoes, red sweet peppers, mozzarella, salsa and sour cream.

    • Steak Quesadilla $16.99

      Comes with Jack cheese, fried mushrooms and onions.

    • Lo-Carb Grilled Chicken Quesadilla $14.29

      Comes with bacon, Jack cheese, fried mushrooms and onions on a whole wheat quesadilla.

    • Lo-Carb Grilled Steak Quesadilla $17.49

      Comes with bacon, Jack cheese, fried mushrooms and onions on a whole wheat quesadilla.

  • Grilled Cheese Sandwiches
    • Ham and Pickle Grilled Cheese Sandwich $10.69

      Ham, pickle and American cheese. Served with cup of tomato basil soup or choice of fries.

    • Hot and Spicy Grilled Cheese Sandwich $11.99

      Pepperoni, hot peppers, grilled onions and pepper jack cheese. Served with cup of tomato basil soup or choice of fries. Spicy.

    • Greek Grill Grilled Cheese Sandwich $11.99

      Feta, Swiss cheese, Kalamata olives, oregano, hot peppers and diced tomatoes. Served with cup of tomato basil soup or choice of fries.

    • Mac and Cheese Grilled Cheese Sandwich $11.99

      Macaroni and cheese, diced bacon and cheddar cheese. Served with cup of tomato basil soup or choice of fries.

    • That's Italian Grilled Cheese Sandwich $11.99

      Diced tomato bruschetta, fresh mozzarella and garlic seasoning. Served with cup of tomato basil soup or choice of fries.

    • Turkey Club Grilled Cheese Sandwich $11.99

      Roast turkey, pesto, bacon and fresh mozzarella. Served with cup of tomato basil soup or choice of fries.

    • Pizza Pepperoni Grilled Cheese Sandwich $11.99

      Pepperoni, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella and oregano. Served with cup of tomato basil soup or choice of fries.

    • Gooey Gouda Grilled Cheese Sandwich $10.69

      Pear slices, fig glaze and smoked Gouda cheese. Served with cup of tomato basil soup or choice of fries.

    • B.L.T.C. Grilled Cheese Sandwich $11.99

      Bacon, lettuce, tomato and cheddar cheese. Served with cup of tomato basil soup or choice of fries.

    • Chili Cheddar Grilled Cheese Sandwich $11.99

      Chili, jalapenos and cheddar cheese. Served with cup of tomato basil soup or choice of fries.

    • The Breakfast Cheese Scramble Grilled Cheese Sandwich $11.99

      Scrambled egg, American cheese, diced sausage and bacon. Served with cup of tomato basil soup or choice of fries.

  • Specialty Selections
    • Teriyaki Combo $29.79

      Shrimp, chicken and beef with oriental vegetables over rice. Served with salad.

    • Key West $25.19

      Chicken breast topped with asparagus, scampi sauce and mozzarella. Served with salad and potato.

    • Oriental Sesame Seed Chicken $25.19

      Come with oriental vegetables over rice. Served with salad.

    • Honey Mustard Chicken $23.29

      Chicken breast topped with our own special Dijon dressing. Served with salad and potato.

    • Chicken a la Greco $25.19

      Broiled in garlic butter sauce with herbs and smothered with fresh green peppers, onions and tomatoes on a bed of rice. Served with salad.

    • Broiled Roumanian Steak and Shrimp Scampi $34.29

      Served with salad, potato and vegetables.

    • Beef and Reef $34.29

      Roumanian steak with 2 stuffed shrimp and 1 baked clam. Served with potato, vegetables and onion rings.

    • Shrimp and Chicken Scampi $28.39

      Served with salad, potato and vegetables.

    • BBQ Ribs and Chicken $22.49

      Served with salad, potato and vegetables.

  • Cereal - Archived
    • Cereal $3.99

    • Cereal with Fruit $5.39

  • Desserts - Archived
    • Lo-Carb Sugar Free Cheesecake $5.89

    • Creamy Cheesecake with Fruit $4.69

    • Fresh Strawberry Cheesecake $5.29

    • Assorted Layer Cakes $4.69

    • Strawberry Shortcake $4.69

    • Carrot Cake $4.69

    • Pound Cake $3.09

    • Assorted Fruit Pies $4.39

    • Assorted Fruit Pie a la Mode $5.69

    • Lemon Meringue Pie $4.39

    • Apple Turnover $3.69

    • Assorted Danish $3.69

    • Brownie $3.39

    • Jumbo Cookies $3.09

    • Creamy Rice Pudding $3.69

    • Bread Pudding $3.69

    • Chocolate Pudding $3.69

    • Jello $2.99

    • Fruit Cup Assorted Fruit $3.79

    • Toasted Almond Italian Dessert $5.89

    • Tiramisu $5.89

      A classic Italian dessert.

    • Ice Cream $4.79

      2 scoops.

    • Rainbow Sherbet $4.79

      2 scoops.

    • Chocolate Sundae $7.59

    • Milk Shake $4.79

    • Ice Cream Soda $4.79

    • Egg Cream $3.39

    • Brownie Sundae $6.99

      Your choice of two scoops of ice cream with walnuts and syrup.

    • Banana Split $7.59

    • Blintzes $12.39

      With fresh fruit and sour cream.

  • Soup - Archived
    • Chicken Noodle Soup $5

    • Onion Soup $5

    • Clam Chowder $5

    • Matzoh Ball Soup $5

    • Tomato Basil Soup $5

    • Tomato and Vegetable Soup $5

    • Lentil Soup $5

    • Yankee Bean Soup $5

    • Split Pea Soup $5

    • Seafood Bisque $5

    • Beef Barley Soup $5

    • Cream of Turkey Soup $5

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.