Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • Bay Shore
  • The Penny Pub

What is Grubhub

Through online ordering, we connect hungry people with the best local restaurants. Explore restaurants near you to find what you love.

Next

Why use Grubhub

Order popular dishes from a variety of restaurants. Get your order delivered or pick it up.

Previous
Start your order

The Penny Pub

(631) 969-4061

We make ordering easy. Learn more

Google map
  • 79 West Main Street, Bay Shore, NY 11706
  • Restaurant website
  • No cuisines specified

  • Grubhub.com
  • The Penny Pub

  • (631) 969-4061

    We make ordering easy.

  • Menu
  • Appetizers
    • Chicken Tenders $9.95

      traditional style

    • Irish Nachos $12.95

      waffle fries, mozzarella, bacon, sour cream, and chives

    • Late Night Fries $9.95

      waffle fries smothered in mozzarella cheese and Guinness gravy

    • Waffle Fries $7.95

      a large portion of fries with choice of dipping sauces

    • Steak Fries $6.95

      large portion of steak fries with your choice of dipping sauces

    • Tots $7.95

      a large portion of tots with your choice of dipping sauces

    • Buffalo Chicken Tots $12.95

      bed of tots topped with mozzarella cheese and buffalo chicken with a ranch and buffalo drizzle

    • Breakfast Tots $11.95

      a bed of tots topped with scrambled eggs, American cheese, and bacon

    • Quesadilla $2.00+

      with salsa and sour cream

    • Breakfast Quesadilla $9.95

      scrambled eggs, bacon, and American cheese with a side of spicy ketchup and sour cream

    • Buffalo or Irish Whiskey BBQ Chicken Quesadilla $11.95

      breaded chicken dipped in your choice of buffalo or Irish whiskey BBQ sauce with ranch and sour cream

    • Penny Pretzels $9.95

      eight pretzel sticks lightly salted with your choice of two dipping sauces

    • TPP Wings $9.95+

      Choice of Buffalo (Mild, Medium or Hot), Irish Whiskey BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, Lemon Pepper, Old Bay, Teriyaki

    • Hotzarella Sticks $9.95

      mozzarella sticks tossed in buffalo sauce with ranch for dipping

    • Mozzarella Sticks $9.95

      served with marinara sauce

    • Crispy Green Beans $9.95

      large portion of green beans, battered and fried with a chipotle ranch sauce for dipping

    • Fried Pickles $9.95

      fried pickle chips with a horseradish sauce for dipping

    • Chicken Caesar Salad $2.00+

      grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, rye croutons, and parmesan cheese

    • House Salad $3.00+

      romaine lettuce, bacon, tomatoes, onions, monterey jack cheese, and croutons

    • Boneless Wings $9.95

      choice of wing sauces

    • Homemade Fried Mac & Cheese $10.95

      with chipotle ranch for dipping

  • Entrees
    all entrees are served with fries side of waffle fries +2.50 | side of tots +2.50 | side salad +3
    • Dublin Dip $14.95

      marinated steak, sautéed onions and Irish cheddar on toasted garlic bread with Guinness gravy sauce for dipping, served with fries

    • Penny Reuben $11.95

      corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and Russian dressing on grilled rye bread, served with fries.

    • The B.E.C. $10.95

      bacon, egg, and cheese on a brioche bun, served with a side of tots

    • Chipotle Chicken Sandwich $13.95

      breaded chicken cutlet, bacon, American cheese, chipotle slaw, and chipotle mayo on Texas toast, served with a side of steak fries

    • The Penny Burger $1.00+

      half pound certified angus beef burger on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, and red onion, served with fries

    • Grilled Chicken BLT $12.95

      with truffle mayonnaise on toasted French bread, served with fries

    • Irish Grilled Cheese $10.95

      Irish cheddar and bacon on Texas toast with a side of Guinness gravy

    • Fish & Chips $13.95

      beer battered cod and waffle fries with malt vinegar and tartar sauce, served with fries

  • Dessert
    • Churros Con Chocolate $7.95

      six churros with chocolate dipping sauce

    • Cheesecake $7.95

      a slice of our seasonal cheesecake

    • Lucky Lemonade $11.00

      Tito's Handmade, Fresh Lemon Juice, Simple Syrup and Seltzer

    • The Penny Pub Irish Coffee $9.00

      Powers Irish Whiskey, Baileys Irish Cream and Fresh Coffee, Topped with Whipped Cream creme de Menthe

    • Old Penny $10.00

      Makers Mark Bourbon, bitters, orange bitters, and simple syrup

    • New Penny $12.00

      Jameson Black Barrel Irish Whiskey, Benedictine Liquor, Bitters, Orange Bitters and Simple Syrup

    • Mullinger Mule $11.00

      Jameson Irish Whiskey, Fresh Lime Juice and Ginger Beer

    • Westport Whiskey Sour $11.00

      Irish Mist, Cranberry SImple Syrup, Fresh Lemon Juice and Fresh Lime Juice

  • Irish Whiskey
    • JAMESON (1oz) $7.00+

      round and smooth with sweet, spicy, toasted wood notes, dry yet smooth finish with a lingering crispness from the pot still

    • JAMESON CASKMATES STOUT (1oz) $7.00+

    • JAMESON CASKMATES IPA (1oz) $12.00+

    • PADDY (1oz) $7.00+

      a nutty flavor with a warm long lasting finish

    • TULLAMORE DEW (1oz) $7.00+

      a mild blend of spicy, lemony and malty notes with charred wood undertones. Body notes of sherried peels and spice, grains and vanilla cream

    • POWERS JOHN LANE 12 YEAR (1oz) $9.00+

      uniquely smooth, sweet spice finish that sparkles on the tongue

    • TEELING SMALL BATCH (1oz) $7.00+

    • REDBREAST 12 YEAR (1oz) $10.00+

      chewy mouth feel with lots of brown sugar and dried coconut finish

    • THE SEXTON SINGLE MALT (1oz) $7.00+

      aged in oloroso sherry butts, warm apple pie a la mode on the nose leads into a body that is heavier on the vanilla and heath bar notes

  • Bourbon
    2oz POUR NEAT OR ROCKS
    • BUFFALO TRACE $11.00

      a complex aroma of vanilla, mint and molasses, sweet to the taste with notes of brown sugar and spice that give way to oak, toffee, dark fruit and anise

    • BASIL HAYDEN $12.00

      spice, tea, hint of peppermint with a dry clean finish

    • TIN CUP $12.00

      made using a blend of rye, corn and malt, a bold and spicy bourbon aged in American white oak casks and cut with pure Rocky Mountain water

    • EAGLE RARE SINGLE BARREL 10 YEAR $12.00

      aromas of toffee, hints of orange peel... bold, dry, oaky flavors with notes of candied almonds and very rich cocoa

    • WOODFORD RESERVE $13.00

      this is an elegant style of bourbon with bright aromas of citrus peel, star anise, and seared wood. the palate has freshness and picks up more fruit tones of maraschino cherry and milk chocolate. a bit of wood smoke appears on the dry, fresh finish

    • ANGELS ENVY $14.00

      this bourbon is adored for its port, creamy vanilla, sweet and ripe fruit flavor notes

    • MAKER’S MARK $11.00

      roasted almonds, vanilla, toffee, and praline-this is a tried-and-true classic for a reason

    • FOUR ROSES SMALL BATCH $13.00

      pleasing aromas of candied pecans, baked apples, milk chocolate, and honey permeate the nose of this bourbon. with bold flavors of caramel, maraschino cherries, vanilla, grated nutmeg, and cinnamon

    • BLANTONS SINGLE BARREL $16.00

      a deep, satisfying nose of nutmeg and spices. powerful dry vanilla notes in harmony with hints of honey amid strong caramel and corn. a medium finish composed of returning corn and nutmeg flavors

    • Evan Williams $4.00

      $4 Green Label Shots, All Day, All Night

  • Scotch
    2oz POUR NEAT OR ROCKS
    • LAPHROAIG, ISLAY $10.00

      surprising sweetness with hints of salt & layers of peatiness

    • AUCHENTOSHEN AMERICAN OAK, LOWLANDS $18.00

      lively with vanilla cream, coconut and white peach

    • AUCHENTOSHEN THREE WOOD, LOWLANDS $18.00

      hazelnut with hints of cinnamon and lemon

    • CHIVAS REGAL 18 YEAR $18.00

      medium body, marmalade, dark chocolate, touch of wood

    • MACALLEN 12 YEAR, HIGHLANDS $22.00

      deliciously smooth, rich dried fruits and sherry balanced with wood, smoke and spice

    • JOHNNIE WALKER BLUE LABEL $38.00

      supple and balanced, good toffee and hints of very wistful smoke... chocolate, hints of grass and a good hint of malt

    • Energy Drink $5.00

      8.4 oz can

    • Bottle Water $2.50

    • Seltzer with Cranberry Juice $2.50

      16oz

    • Cranberry Juice $2.50

      16oz

    • Ginger Ale $2.50

      16oz

    • Sierra Mist $2.50

      16oz

    • Pink Lemonade $2.50

      16oz

    • Tonic $2.50

      16oz

    • Orange Juice $2.50

      16oz

    • Cherry Pepsi $2.50

      16oz

    • Pepsi $2.50

      16 oz

    • Diet Pepsi $2.50

      16oz

    • Seltzer $2.50

      16oz

  • Rye
    2oz POURS NEAT OR ROCKS
    • SAZERAC RYE $11.00

      aromas of clove, vanilla, anise and pepper. subtle notes of candies spices and citrus... the big finish is smooth with hints of licorice

    • KNOBB CREEK RYE $12.00

      robust, mature flavor more pronounced flavors of vanilla, nuts and oak with a smokier aroma and a finish that’s smooth and complex best enjoyed in stages

    • HIGH WEST DOUBLE RYE $12.00

      long and spicy with bold notes of dark sweets, fruit, wood and char… but no smoke

    • WOODFORD RESERVE RYE DISTILLERS SELECT $12.00

      bold flavors of pepper and tobacco with a long fruit and sweetly spiced finish

  • Tequila
    • ESPOLON BLANCO (1oz) $7.00+

      this is a light-bodied and dry tequila that has accents of white flowers, lime peel, vanilla, fresh-turned earth, and green bell pepper

    • PATRON SLIVER (1oz) $9.00+

      light, crystal clear tequila with fresh agave aromas & hints of citrus.

    • CASAMIGOS SILVER (1oz) $7.00+

      rests for two months. crisp and clean with hints of citrus, vanilla and sweet agave, with a long smooth finish

    • CASAMIGOS ANEJO (1oz) $9.00+

      aged for fourteen months, pure and complex aroma, with soft caramel and vanilla notes, subtle hints of spice and barrel oak, with a lingering smooth finish

    • SAUZA HORNITOS REPOSADO (1oz) $7.00+

      rests for two months in large oak vats, it’s light in color with a floral-vanilla scent and has a distinct, smoky finish

    • 1800 COCONUT (1oz) $7.00+

      the signature double-distilled 1800 silver tequila infused with natural, ripe coconut flavor

Menu for The Penny Pub provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.