• New York
  • Bay Shore
  • Nicky's On The Bay

Nicky's On The Bay

(631) 206-3311
  • 150 South Clinton Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

(631) 206-3311
  • Menu
  • Brunch Appetizers
    • Fried Calamari $16

      Served with marinara.

    • Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail $20.5

      Chilled and served with cocktail sauce.

    • Clams Oreganata $10.5

      With garlic bread crumbs.

    • Hot Wings $12

      Served with blue cheese, celery and carrots.

    • Mozzarella Sticks $7.75

    • Steamed Mussels $18.25

      Tossed in your choice of white wine and garlic or marinara. Served with bread for dipping.

    • Baked Clams $9.25

  • S-Brunch Soups & Salad
    • Caesar Salad $13.5

      Crisp romaine, croutons, shaved parmesan, tossed in homemade dressing.

    • Clam Bisque $6

      New england style clam chowder without potatoes.

    • Corn Chowder $6

      Creamy corn soup with vegetables.

    • Greek Salad $15.5

      Mixed greens, feta, kalamata olives, cucumbers, peppers and tomatoes, with a Greek vinaigrette.

    • Seafood Bisque $8.25

      Nicky's ultimate, creamy pink seafood soup with lobster, shrimp and crabmeat.

    • Manhattan Clam Chowder $6

      Tomato based chowder, full of vegetables, chopped clams, bacon and potatoes.

    • Salad Trio $22.5

      Shrimp, tuna and crabmeat salad served open faced on a bed of lettuce and toast.

  • Brunch Entrees
    • Grilled Shell Steak $38.5

      14 oz prime bone in steak, topped with fried onions and served plain or marinated. Served with your choice of side dish.

    • Fried Shrimp (6) $37.5

      Served with your choice of side.

    • Coconut Shrimp (5) $35.5

      Marshmallow-pineapple sauce. Includes choice of side.

    • Fried Bay Scallops $29.25

      Served with your choice of side.

    • Linguine with Red or White Clam Sauce $28.25

      Freshly shucked chopped clams over linguine.

    • Nicky's Burger $17

      Grilled red onions and melted bleu cheese.

    • Stuffed Shrimp $37.5

      (5) enormous shrimp with snow crabmeat stuffing.

    • Lobster Roll $24.95

      Served on toasted brioche bun with chips and cole slaw.

    • Fried Hard Shell Clams $28

      Whole belly clams lightly breaded and fried. Served with your choice of side.

    • Fried Combination Platter $36.25

      Bay scallops, oysters, clams, flounder and 2 jumbo shrimp. Includes choice of side.

    • Eight Ounce Burger $16.5

      Served with French fries, lettuce and tomato.

    • Stuffed Flounder $34.5

      With a snow crabmeat stuffing. Includes choice of side.

  • Lunch Lunch Specials
    • Flatbread Pizza $15

    • Arugula Salad $16

      Burrata cheese, fried eggplant, cherry tomatoes with a balsamic glaze.

    • Fried Mahi Fish Tacos $15.25

      (3) flour tortillas, shredded cabbage with a chipotle cream and pineapple salsa.

    • Lobster Roll $24.95

      Served on toasted brioche bun with chips and coleslaw.

    • Grilled Chicken Sandwich $14.5

      Bacon marmalade, smoked gouda and baby arugula. Served with choice of fries, coleslaw or side salad.

    • Tuna BLT $16

      Fresh seared tuna, bacon, lettuce, tomato and spicy mayo. Served with choice of fries, ,cole slaw or side salad.

  • Lunch Starters
    • Steamed Littleneck Clams (12) $16.75

      Steamed in white wine and garlic.

    • Hot Wings $10.25

      Served with blue cheese, celery and carrots.

    • Baked Stuffed Clams (3) $8.25

      Chopped clams with bread crumbs and bacon.

    • Crab Cakes $17

      Served with chipotle cream.

    • Mozzarella Sticks $6.75

    • Fried Calamari $15.25

      Served with marinara.

    • Clams Oreganata $9.5

      With garlic bread crumbs.

    • Clams Casino $9.5

      With seasoned bread crumbs and bacon.

    • Fried Whole Belly Top Neck Clams $16.25

      Freshly shucked and fried.

    • Steamed Mussels $16

      Tossed in your choice of white wine and garlic or marinara. Served with bread for dipping.

  • Lunch Nicky's Homemade Soups
    • Seafood Bisque $8.25

      Nicky's ultimate, creamy pink seafood bisque with lobster, shrimp and crabmeat.

    • Manhattan Clam Chowder $6

      Tomato based chowder, full of vegetables, chopped clams, bacon and potatoes.

    • Corn Chowder $6

      Creamy corn soup with vegetables.

    • Clam Bisque $6

      New england style clam chowder without potatoes.

  • Lunch Salads
    • Caesar Salad $13.5

      Crisp romaine, croutons, shaved parmesan, tossed in homemade dressing.

    • Greek Salad $15.5

      Mixed greens, feta, kalamata olives, cucumbers, peppers and tomatoes, with a Greek vinaigrette.

    • Salad Trio $21.5

      Shrimp, tuna and crabmeat salad served open faced on a bed of lettuce and toast.

    • Garden Salad $11.5

      Mixed greens topped with fresh cut veggies, with homemade dressing.

  • Lunch Raw Bar
    • Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail $19.5

      Chilled and served with cocktail sauce.

  • Lunch Burgers & Sandwiches
    Includes choice of: French fries, cole slaw, side salad, sweet fries.
    • Tuna Salad $14.5

      Served on your choice of roll, white or whole wheat.

    • Grilled Cheese $8.25

    • Crabmeat Salad $17.25

      Fresh snow crabmeat salad, served on your choice of roll, white or whole wheat.

    • Shrimp Salad $17.25

      Freshly made shrimp salad, served on your choice of roll, white or whole wheat.

    • Flounder Roll $13.75

      Fresh flounder fried and served on a roll with lettuce and tomato.

    • Eight Ounce Burger $14.5

      Served with lettuce and tomato and your choice of French fries,sweet fries or side salad.

    • Veggie Burger $10.75

      Served with lettuce, tomato.

    • Nicky's Burger $16

      Grilled red onions and melted bleu cheese.

    • Grilled Chicken $11.75

      Served on a roll with lettuce and tomato.

  • Lunch Fried Seafood
    Includes choice of: French fries, cole slaw, side salad, sweet fries.
    • Fried Shrimp (4) $22

    • Fried Hard Shell Clams $18.25

    • Fried Bay Scallops $21.25

    • Fresh Fried Flounder $21.25

    • Fried Oysters $21.25

  • Dinner Appetizers Specials
    • Flatbread Pizza $15

    • Tuna Taco $19

      Marinated raw tuna served in a corn tortilla with an Asian mango slaw and spicy mayo.

    • Arugula Salad $16

      Burrata cheese, fried eggplant, cherry tomatoes with a balsamic glaze.

    • Blue Cheese Mussels $18

      Crumbled blue cheese, crisp pancetta with roasted garlic, shallots and tomatoes.

  • Dinner Starters
    • Steamed Littleneck Clams (12) $16.75

      Steamed in white wine and garlic.

    • Crab Cakes $17

      Served with chipotle cream.

    • Fried Calamari $15.25

      Served with marinara.

    • Clams Oreganata $9.5

      With garlic bread crumbs.

    • Fried Whole Belly Top Neck Clams $16.25

      Freshly shucked and fried.

    • Steamed Mussels $16

      Tossed in your choice of white wine and garlic or marinara. Served with bread for dipping.

    • Hot Wings $10.25

      Served with blue cheese, celery and carrots.

    • Clams Casino $9.5

      With seasoned bread crumbs and bacon.

    • Baked Stuffed Clams $8.25

      Chopped clams with bread crumbs and bacon.

    • Mozzarella Sticks $6.75

  • Dinner Nicky's Homemade Soups
    • Manhattan Clam Chowder $6

      Tomato based chowder, full of vegetables, chopped clams, bacon and potatoes.

    • Corn Chowder $6

      Creamy corn soup with vegetables.

    • Seafood Bisque $8.25

      Nicky's ultimate, creamy pink seafood bisque with lobster,shrimp and crabmeat.

    • Clam Bisque $6

      New england style clam chowder without potatoes.

  • Dinner Salads
    • Garden Salad $11.5

      Mixed greens topped with fresh cut veggies, with homemade dressing.

    • Caesar Salad $13.5

      Crisp romaine, croutons, shaved parmesan, tossed in homemade dressing.

    • Greek Salad $15.5

      Mixed greens, feta, kalamata olives, cucumbers, peppers and tomatoes, with a Greek vinaigrette.

    • Salad Trio $21.5

      Shrimp, tuna and crabmeat salad served open faced on a bed of lettuce and toast.

  • Dinner Raw Bar
    • Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail $19.5

      Chilled and served with cocktail sauce.

  • Dinner From The Broiler
    Choice of side: French fries, baked potato, corn on the cob, spinach, sweet potato fries, broccoli.
    • Shrimp Scampi $33.5

      (6) enormous shrimp in a butter garlic wine sauce.

    • Stuffed Shrimp $35.5

      (5) enormous shrimp with snow crabmeat stuffing.

    • Shrimp Oreganata (6) $33.5

      Broiled with light garlic bread crumbs.

    • Seafood Au Gratin $34

      Crabmeat, lobster and 2 jumbo shrimp in a creamy white sauce with cheddar cheese.

    • Linguine with Red or White Clam Sauce $27.25

      Freshly shucked chopped clams over linguine.

    • Stuffed Flounder $33.5

      With a snow crabmeat stuffing.

    • Flounder Oreganata $29.5

      Broiled with light garlic bread crumbs.

  • Dinner Fresh Fried Seafood
    Choice of side: French fries, baked potato, corn on the cob, spinach, sweet potato fries, broccoli.
    • Fried Whole Belly Topneck Clams $25.25

    • Fried Shrimp (6) $36.5

      Served with your choice of side.

    • Fried Oysters $32

      Fresh oysters lightly breaded and fried. Served with your choice of side.

    • Fried Combination Platter $35.25

      Bay scallops, oysters, clams, flounder and 2 jumbo shrimp.

    • Fresh Fried Flounder $28.25

    • Fried Bay Scallops $28.25

      Served with your choice of side.

    • Coconut Shrimp (5) $34.5

      Marshmallow-pineapple sauce. Includes choice of side.

  • Dinner Entrees Specials
    • Parmesan Halibut $35

      Over risotto with parmesan, spinach, roasted tomatoes and basil.

    • Lobster Mac N' Cheese $35

      With roasted asparagus and pancetta.

    • Sesame Seared Tuna $35

      Asian-mango slaw with spicy mayo and teriyaki. Served with choice of side.

    • Fried Mahi Fish Tacos $27

      (3) flour tortillas, shredded cabbage, chipotle cream, cilantro and pineapple salsa. Served with rice and black beans.

    • Wasabi Salmon $30

      With sweet potato wedges, grilled asparagus, soy-maple glaze.

    • Chicken Bucatini $28

      Grilled chicken, roasted asparagus, tomatoes, in smoked gouda cream sauce.

    • Grilled Swordfish $34

      Marinated and grilled served with broccoli rabe, parmesan and cannellini beans.

  • Dinner Land Lover's Entrees
    • Nicky's Burger $16

      Grilled red onions and melted bleu cheese.

    • Grilled Shell Steak $37.5

      14 oz prime bone in steak, topped with fried onions and served plain or marinated. Served with your choice of side dish.

    • Chicken Parmigiana $26.25

      Served with linguine.

    • BBQ Pork Chops $28.25

      Topped with fried onions and served with your choice of side.

    • Eight Ounce Burger $14.5

      Served with lettuce and tomato and your choice of French fries, or side salad.

  • Dinner Sides
    • Onion Rings $6.25

    • Baked Potato $5.25

    • French Fries $5.25

    • Cole Slaw $5.25

    • Fried Shrimp (Each) $5.5

    • Sweet Potato Fries $6.25

    • Sauteed Broccoli $6.5

    • Sauteed Spinach $6.5

    • Fresh Corn On The Cob $5.25

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.