Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • Brooklyn
  • Shelsky's Of Brooklyn

Shelsky's Of Brooklyn

(718) 855-8817

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 141 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
  • Eastern European ,  Sandwiches ,  Seafood
  • $$$$$
  • Shelsky's Of Brooklyn

  • (718) 855-8817
  • Menu
  • Cold Smoked And Cured
    • Eastern Gaspe Nova $9.99

    • Irish Double Cured Organic Salmon $10.99

    • Mild Scottish Salmon $10.99

    • Forman And Field London Cure Scottish Salmon $12.49

    • David Burke Pastrami Salmon $12.49

    • House-Cured Gravlax $11.99

    • House-Cured Mexican Achiote Salmon $11.99

    • House-Cured Jamaican Jerk Salmon $11.99

    • House-Cured Szechuan Kung Pao Salmon $11.99

    • Western Wild King Salmon $12.99

    • Belly Lox $9.99

    • Sable (Black Cod) $14.99

  • Hot Smoked
    • Blue Fish $6.49

    • Fatty Kippered Salmon $10.99

    • Lean Kippered Salmon $9.99

    • Fancy Lake Sturgeon $16.49

    • Whole Smoked Trout $4.99

    • Smoked Peppered Mackerel $3.99

    • Door County White Fish $19.96

    • Lake Superior Cisco $23.75

    • Bering Cisco $23.75

      seasonal

  • Herring
    • House Pickled Herring $3.50

      with or without cream sauce & onions

    • Roll Mops $3.50

    • Matjes Herring $5.50

    • Kippered Herring $11.00

      per pack of 2 whole fish

    • Schmaltz Herring $5.50

    • Fiery Jamaican Jerk Herring $3.75

    • House Mustard Herring $3.75

    • House Pickled Lox $35.96

    • French Oak-Smoked Herring $4.25

    • New Catch Holland Herring $5.00+

  • Salads And Spreads
    • Cucumber Salad $6.99

    • Citrus Roasted Beet Salad $9.99

    • Egg Salad $9.99

    • Pickled Herring Salad $17.99

    • Smoked Whitefish Salad $22.00

    • Baked Salmon Salad $22.00

    • Smoked Bluefish Salad $19.96

      with roasted hazelnuts, orange, and fennel

    • Chopped Liver $12.99

    • Plain Cream Cheese $7.25

    • Scallion Cream Cheese $8.25

    • Lox Cream Cheese $12.25

    • Olive Cream Cheese $12.25

    • Ben's All Natural Cream Cheese $11.99

    • Ben's All Natural Vegetable Cream Cheese $11.99

  • Guss' Pickles
    • Half Or Full Sour $1.00+

    • Sour Tomatoes $1.00

    • Sauerkraut $4.00

  • Sandwiches
    • Member Of The Tribe $11.50

      gaspe nova, scallion or plain cream cheese, served on a bagel or bialy

    • The Fancy Pants $15.00

      fatty lake sturgeon, house-cured gravlax, ben's cream cheese, tomato and red onion served on a bagel or bialy

    • Peter Shelsky $13.50

      gaspe nova, sable, pickled herring with cream sauce & onion, scallion cream cheese, served on bagel or bialy

    • Brooklyn Native $13.50

      gaspe nova, smoked whitefish salad, pickled herring, sour pickle, served on bagel or bialy

    • Brooklyn Transplant $13.00

      fatty kippered salmon, apple horseradish, cream cheese, pickled herring salad, served on pumpernickel or rye

    • Shelsky's Pastrami $13.25

      pastrami salmon, mustard herring, riesling braised sauerkraut, served on pumpernickel or rye

    • Dr. Goldstein Special $11.00

      duck fat-laced chopped liver & apple horseradish sauce, served between 2 schmaltz fried potato latkes

    • The Great Gatsby $12.50

      pastrami cured salmon, honey mustard, horseradish cream cheese & red onion, served on caraway seeded rye

    • El Vincente $15.50

      lake sturgeon, plain cream cheese, fresh jalapenos, & heirloom tomato (sour pickle when tomato is out of season), served on bagel or bialy

    • The Spicy Red, Spicy White or Spicy Blue $12.00

      your choice of baked salmon salad, smoked whitefish salad or smoked bluefish salad with roasted hazelnuts, fennel, & oranges, cucumber salad & sriracha chili sauce, served on rye or pumpernickel

    • The Holy Mackerel $9.25

      smoked peppered mackerel, ben's vegetable cream cheese & cucumber salad served on a toasted bialy

    • The 20 Dollars Smoked Salmon Sandwich $20.00

      ruby red wild alaskan sockeye salmon, butter, red onion, served on a toasted bialy

    • The Whitefish Club $12.00

      door county whitefish fillet, tomato, onion, jalapeno, cilantro and cream cheese on a bagel or bialyq

    • The Tribute $13.00

      door county smoked whitefish salad, horseradish cream cheese, wasabi tobiko, served on a bagel or bialy

    • The Fishless $8.50

      tomato, pickled tomato, cilantro, jalapeno, red onion, apple horseradish sauce and mayonnaise served on a bagel or bialy

  • Bagels, Bialy's, Onion Pockets, Rye Or Pumpernickel With A Schmear
    • Plain Cream Cheese $3.25

    • Scallion Cream Cheese $3.50

    • Ben's Cream Cheese $4.50

    • Horseradish Cream Cheese $4.25

    • Olive Cream Cheese $4.50

    • Lox Cream Cheese $4.50

    • Smoked Whitefish Salad $8.99

    • Smoked Bluefish Salad $8.50

      contains nuts

    • Baked Salmon Salad $8.99

    • Pickled Herring Salad $7.50

    • Egg Salad $5.00

    • Chopped Liver $8.50

    • Butter $2.50

  • Beverages
    • Ashlawn Farm French-Pressed Coffee $2.00+

    • Dr. Brown's Sodas $1.50

      cel-ray, black cherry, root beer, diet black, cherry diet cream

    • Fizzy Lizzy Sparkling Fruit Juice $2.00

      grapefruit pineapple, grape, apple, tangerine-passion fruit, cranberry

    • Martinelli's Sparkling Apple Cider $3.00

    • Kedem Concord Grape Juice $4.00

    • Fentiman's Sodas $2.50

      tonic water, ginger beer, mandarin & seville orange jigger, dandelion and burdock

    • Abita Root Beer $2.50

    • Regata Ginger Beer $2.50

    • Manhattan Special Espresso Soda $2.00

      regular or diet

    • Saratoga Springs Water $2.00

      flat or sparkling

  • Baked Sweets
    • Mama Ilene's Coconut Macaroons $0.75

    • Apricot Or Raspberry Rugelach $14.50

    • Lingonberry & Toasted Spiced Pumpkin Seed Rugelach $14.50

    • Clementine & Ginger Rugelach $14.50

    • Chocolate And Cinnamon Babka $9.50

    • Chocolate Covered Jelly Rings $8.50

    • Chocolate Covered Vanilla Marshmallow Twists $8.50

    • Chocolate Covered Or Marble Halvah Bars $2.50

  • Packaged Sweets
    • Joray Apricot Fruit Roll $1.50

    • Joray Strawberry Fruit Roll $1.50

    • Assorted Life Savers $1.00

    • Halvah $3.50

    • Jelly Beans $8.00

  • From Orwasher's Bakery
    • Ultimate Whole Wheat $8.00

      made w local grain & flour

    • Seeded Or Plain Rye $3.50

    • Raisin Pumpernickel $3.75

    • Sesame Pane Rustico $3.50

    • Giant Onion Pocket $0.75

    • Braided Challah $8.00

      fridays only

  • Basin Bagel Cafe
    • Assorted Bagels

    • Bialys

    • Garlic Bialy Roll

  • Bagel Or Bialy
    • Plain Cream Cheese $3.25

    • Scallion Cream Cheese $3.50

    • Lox Spread $4.50

    • Caviar Cream Cheese $4.50

    • Olive Cream Cheese $4.50

    • Horseradish Cream Cheese $4.50

    • Egg Salad $3.50

    • Pickled Herring Salad $5.50

    • Whitefish Salad $6.00

    • Baked Salmon Salad $6.00

  • Jarred Items
    • Sarabeth's Peach Apricot Preserves $9.99

    • Sarabeth's Blood Orange Marmalade $9.99

    • Sarabeth's Strawberry Raspberry Preserves $9.99

    • Manischewitz Premium Gold Gefilte Fish $9.99

    • Manischewitz Sweet Gefilte Fish $9.99

    • Manischewitz Jarred Borscht $3.99

      with diced beets

    • Manischewitz Wildflower Honey $6.50

    • Tiptree Lemon Curd $9.00

    • BF Salt Packed Capers $4.99

    • BF Capers In Brine $3.99

    • Brooklyn Brine Whiskey Sour Pickles $10.00

    • Brooklyn Brine Damn Spicy Pickles $10.00

    • Brooklyn Brine Lavender Pickled Asparagus $10.00

    • Brooklyn Brine Fennel Beets $10.00

    • La Caperelle Caperberries $5.75

    • Honeycup Honey Mustard $6.49

    • Wild Hibiscus Flowers In Syrup $10.00

    • Portuguese Sardines In Olive Oil $3.75

    • Portuguese Spicy Sardines In Olive Oil $3.75

    • Portuguese Sardines In Tomato Sauce $3.75

    • Ortiz Yellow Fin Tuna Jars $12.00

    • Red Head Canned Salmon $6.25

    • Think Pink Canned Salmon $3.75

    • Unio Extra Virgin Olive Oil $16.99

    • Reniero Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil $13.79

  • Boxed And Bagged
    • Tam Tam Original Crackers $4.99

    • Carrs Sesame Water Crackers $4.50

    • Carrs Cracked Pepper Crackers $4.50

    • Ak-Mak Wheat Crackers $3.50

    • Plain Bremner Wafers $3.75

    • Macy's Cheese Sticks $4.00

    • Diamond Crystal Kosher Salt $4.99

    • David's Kosher Salt $1.99

    • Mashuga Nuts Sweet And Salty Pecans $4.99+

    • Mashuga Nuts Double Chocolate Walnuts $4.99

    • Manischewitz Wide Egg Noodles $3.49

    • Streitz Matzo Meal $3.99

    • Streitz Matzo $3.99

    • Streitz Matzos Flour & Water $4.00

  • Ashlawn Farm Organic Coffee
    • Captain Bill's Bold Blend $12.00+

    • 1730 Blend $12.00+

    • Decaf French Roast $12.50

  • Platters
    • Shelsky's Salmon Platter $10.00

      perfectly balanced and rich eastern gaspe nova beautifully arranged on a platter with red onions, lemons, capers and dill. substitutions available. comes with assorted bagels and bialys, scallion and plain cream cheese. (6pp min.)

    • Shelskys Smoked Goodness $25.00

      rich and smoky gaspe nova, whole filleted white fish, sable, and fatty kippered (hot smoked) salmon beautifully arranged on platters with capers, lemons and sliced red onion. comes with assorted bagels and bialys, scallion and plain cream cheese

    • Shelskys Smoked Goodness $0.50

      add for fresh hot-house tomatoes

    • Shelskys Grand Smoked Plateau $40.00

      rich and smoky gaspe nova, velvety mild scottish salmon, pastrami salmon, whole filleted white fish, shelsky's house pickled herring with cream sauce and onions, and fatty kippered (hot smoked) salmon, beautifully arranged on platters with capers, lemons, and sliced red onion.

    • Shelskys Grand Smoked Plateau $0.50

      add comes with assorted bagels and bialys, scallion and plain cream cheese. for fresh hot-house tomatoes

    • Platter Of Fresh Crudites $69.00

      with fine herbs fromage blanc

    • Platter Of Fresh Seasonal Fruit $49.00

    • Hot Ashlawn Farm Coffee $25.00

      box served with milk, half and half, skim milk, sugar, sweetener, stirrers, and paper cups

    • Shelskys Sweets Platter $10.00

      assorted rugelach (clementine n ginger, apricot, raspberry, and lingonberry w toasted pumpkin seed), chocolate babka, honey cake, and mama ilene's coconut cloud macaroons

  • Shelskys Salad Platter $30 Person
    • Citrus Roasted Beet Salad

    • Cucumber And Onion Salad

    • Roasted Chicken Salad With Pecans And Raisins

    • Egg Salad

    • Pickled Herring Salad

    • Smoked Whitefish Salad

    • Fancy Albacore Tuna Salad

    • Baked Salmon Salad

    • Sliced Guss' Pickles

    • Shelsky's Chopped Liver

    • Shelsky's Vegetarian Chopped Liver

    • Smoked Bluefish Salad

      with fennel, red onion, citrus, and roasted hazelnuts

    • Austrian Potato Salad

    • Treif Salad

      mixed seafood salad

  • Hors D'Oeuvres And Canapes Platter
    • The Great Gatsby

      pastrami salmon, horseradish cream cheese, honey mustard on caraway seeded rye (open face)

    • Brooklyn Brine Co. Pickled Asparagus

      (when in season) wrapped with horseradish cream cheese and pastrami salmon with horseradish cream -cheese to dip (seasonal)

    • Mild Scottish Salmon

      with plain or scallion cream cheese on pumpernickel

    • Western Wild King Salmon $2.00

      with ben's cream cheese on rye

    • Matjes Herring

      with ben's cream cheese on baltic rye

    • French Smoked Herring

      with austrian potato and cucumber salad on ultimate whole wheat

    • Crepes Rolled

      with kippered salmon, apples, and horseradish crème fraiche

    • Cucumber Cups

      with bluefish salad (hazelnuts, fennel, orange) and sriracha chili sauce

    • Door County

      wi smoked whitefish salad on rye or pumpernickel

    • Egg Salad

      with smoky egg spread on rye or pumpernickel

    • Buckwheat Blinis

      served with crème fraiche and whitefish caviar

  • 1 Selection Of The Following
    • Smoked Whitefish Salad

    • Smoked Bluefish Salad

      with hazelnuts, oranges, and fennel

    • Baked Salmon Salad

    • Pickled Herring Salad

    • Chopped Liver

    • 2 Pickled Herring Fillets

      with onions with or without cream sauce

    • 2 Roll Mops

      with onions or sour pickle

  • 1 Selection Of The Following
    • Cucumber Salad

    • Austrian Potato And Cucumber Salad

    • Citrus Roasted Beet Salad

    • Egg Salad With Cornichons

    • 1 Schmaltz-Fried Potato Latke

    • 2 Half Or Full Sour Pickles

    • 1 Sour Pickled Tomato

  • 1 Bread Selection
    • Hand Rolled Mill Basin Bagel

    • Bell Onion Bialy Or Garlic/Everything Bialy Roll

    • Rye Or Pumpernickel

    • Giant Onion Pocket

    • 1 Bag Of Bagel Chips

  • 1 Can Of Soda Or Water
    • Dr. Brown's Soda

    • Diet Coke

    • Poland Spring Water

  • 3 Selection Of The Following
    • Cucumber Salad

    • Austrian Potato And Cucumber Salad

    • Citrus Roasted Beet Salad

    • Egg Salad With Cornichons

    • Chopped Liver

    • 1 Schmaltz-Fried Potato Latke

    • 2 Half Or Full Sour Pickles

    • 1 Sour Pickled Tomato

  • 1 Bread Selection
    • Hand Rolled Mill Basin Bagel

    • Bell Onion Bialy Or Garlic/Everything Bialy Roll

    • Rye Or Pumpernickel

    • Giant Onion Pocket

    • 1 Bag Of Bagel Chips

  • 1 Can Of Soda Or Water
    • Dr. Brown's Soda

    • Diet Coke

    • Poland Spring Water

  • 1 Selection Of The Following
    • Member Of The Tribe

      gaspe nova salmon/plain or scallion cream cheese on a bagel or bialy

    • Spicy Blue

      bluefish salad/cucumber salad/sriracha on rye or pumpernickel

    • Great Gatsby

      pastrami cured salmon/horseradish cream cheese/honey mustard/red onion or caraway seeded rye

    • Shelsky's Pastrami

      pastrami cured salmon/mustard dill herring/riesling braised sauerkraut on rye or pumpernickel

    • Brooklyn Transplant

      fatty kippered salmon/pickled herring salad/apple horseradish sauce/cream cheese on rye or pumpernickel

  • 1 Selection Of The Following
    • Cucumber Salad

    • Austrian Potato And Cucumber Salad

    • Citrus Roasted Beet Salad

    • Egg Salad With Cornichons

    • 1 Schmaltz-Fried Potato Latke

    • 2 Half Or Full Sour Pickles

    • 1 Sour Pickled Tomato

  • 1 Can Of Soda Or Water
    • Dr. Brown's Soda

    • Diet Coke

    • Poland Spring Water

Menu for Shelsky's Of Brooklyn provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.