• New York
  • Brooklyn
  • Extra Fancy

Extra Fancy

(347) 422-0939
  • 302 Metropolitan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • American (New) ,  Cocktails ,  Seafood
  • $$$$$
(347) 422-0939
  • Menu
  • Small Plates
    • Caesar Salad Plate $12.5

      Bonito, chervil and Parmesan.

    • 'Bama Fried Chicken Plate $15

      Charred scallions and white BBQ

    • Salt and Pepper Shrimp Plate $17

      Chili, lime, scallion, garlic and peanuts.

    • Fisherman's Board $15

      Cider glazed, sunchoke and carrot tops.

    • Herb + Baby Lettuces $9

      pistachios, citrus vinaigrette

    • Tuna Poke $15

      radish, cucumber, ponzu, puffed rice

    • Roasted Kabocha Squash Salad $9

      marinated kale, radish, pumpkin seed, green goddess dressing (contains sesame seeds)

    • Little Gem Caesar (Chopped) $10

      parmesan, garlic herb croutons (can be made dairy free or gluten free)

    • Spicy Vegan Yam "Chowder" $10

      corn, coconut milk, green curry, sweet potato, yukon golds, fresh herbs (contains cilantro)

    • New England Clam Chowder Cup $6

      Served with everything crackers.

    • Rare Seared Blackened Tuna Salad $15

      bibb lettuce, persian cucumbers, puffed rice, furikake, yuzu kosho dressing

    • NE Clam Chowder Fries $15

      sweet potato fries, chowda, chopped bits o' bacon, chives

    • Lobster Bisque Fries $16

      Hon Shimeji mushrooms, creme fraiche, fancy fries

  • Big Plates
    • Steamed Mussels $17

      Served with white wine, spring onion butter and garlic.

    • Smoked Trout Sandwich $16

      Served with tomatoes, avocado, and chips with a choice of side.

    • Buttermilk Fried Chicken $18

      Fried oysters and 'bama sauce.

    • Lobster Bisque Soup $9

      Served with country bread.

    • Soft Shell Crab Sandy $18

      Tempura battered crab, pickled green tomato, and tartar sauce on a brioche bun.

    • Extra Fancy Healthy Bowl $15

      wild rice, roasted beets, harissa hummus, kale, 6 minute egg

    • New England Lobster and Clam Bake $37

      Lobster tail, mussels, shrimp, chorizo, clams, potatoes, corn, and butter.

    • Fish + Chips $18

      beer battered hake, slaw, tartar sauce

    • Slow Roasted 5 Spice Ribs $19

      cabbage, bok choy, hoisin, sesame

  • Raw Bar and Chilled Seafood
    • Peel & Eat Shrimp (4 piece) $12

    • Jonah Stone Claw and Mustard $11

    • Tuna Poke $15

      radish, cucumber, ponzu, puffed rice

    • Tuna Ceviche $17

      Cilantro, salsa fresca, and pickled fresno chilies.

  • Sandwiches + Tacos
    • Yam'wich $12

      Roasted yams, goat cheese and tomato. Served with Deep River Kettle Cooked potato chips and a drink.

    • Grilled Chicken Sandwich $12

      Pickled apple, chicken liver mousse and cilantro. Served with Deep River Kettle Cooked potato chips and a drink.

    • Smoked Trout Sandwich $16

      Served with tomatoes, avocado, and chips (choice of salad or fries)

    • Fried Chicken Salad Sammy $12

      Cold fried chicken tossed in bleu cheese mayo, celery and bibb lettuce. Served with Deep River Kettle Cooked potato chips and a drink.

    • Beef Brisket Sandwich $13

      Mustard, pickles and black pepper. Served with Deep River Kettle Cooked potato chips and a drink.

    • Brandade Sandwich $14

      Salted cod, potato, olive tapenade and egg. Served with Deep River Kettle Cooked potato chips and a drink.

    • Crispy Fish Tacos $13

      jalapeno + apple slaw, chipotle mayo

    • Blackened Shrimp Tacos $14

      smoked paprika + morita rub, avocado, celery + onion buttermilk slaw

    • Fried Chicken Bacon 'Bama $14

      OG recipe, cheddar, tomato, white BBQ

    • Fancy Tuna Melt $15

      pimento cheese, arugula, texas toast

    • Mushroom Tacos $13

      Shitake and Cremini Mushrooms, Epazote, Tomatillo, Avocado Salsa, Radish

    • Extra Fancy Backyard Burger $15

      Grass-fed new york beef, cheddar, pickles, shredded lettuce and special sauce.

    • Chicken Bacon Bama $16

      Sandwich served with cheddar, lettuce, and tomato. Comes with choice of side.

    • Sausage and Crab Roll $15

      grilled fennel pork sausage, lump crab meat, green tomato, charred onion, pickled mustard seed, dill, served with potato chips

    • Fried Shrimp Bahn Mi $15

      crispy fried shrimp, cucumber, pickled carrots and daikon, smoked trout pate, cilantro and mint

  • Late Night Menu
    • Shrimp Cocktail $14

    • Trout Roe Deviled Eggs $6.5

    • Cornbread $6

    • Clam Chowder $10

    • Salt and Pepper Shrimp $17

    • Caesar Salad $12.5

      Served with Parmesan cheese and croutons.

    • Fried Chicken $15

    • Burger $16

    • French Fries $7

  • Snacks
    • Fancy Deviled Eggs $7

      smoked trout, roe, celery, pickled mustard seed

    • Island Creek Fried Oysters $14

      esquites, roasted tomato, arugula

    • Charred Shishitos $9

      grilled lime, maldon salt, fish sauce

    • Clam Chowder $9

      Old Bay goldfish crackers.

    • Deviled Eggs with Lobster, Paprika and Dill $9

    • Hush Puppies $8

      Clams, corn and tartar sauce.

    • Smoked Trout Spread $13

      Chervil and saltines.

  • Sides
    • Crispy Brussels Sprouts $8

      fresno chilies, soy, lime

    • Spicy Slaw $6

      Fish sauce and chili.

    • Rosemary French Fries $7

      old bay-onnaise, fried rosemary

    • Cauliflower Salad $9

      Served with capers, parsley, and extra virgin olive oil.

    • Roasted Carrots $10

      Cider glazed, sunchoke, and carrot tops.

    • Sweet Potato Fries $8

      scallion buttermilk dip

    • Salt Cod Fritters $9

      Served with lemon aioli.

    • Country Cornbread $6

      Anson mills and maple butter.

    • Sauteed Kale $8

      chili flake, garlic, lemon

    • Fancy Fries $6

      EF spice blend, Old Bay-onnaise

  • Soups + Salads
    • Herb + Baby Lettuces Salad $9

      With pistachios and citrus vinaigrette.

    • Chopped Caesar Salad $11

      Romaine, Parmesan, and herb croutons.

    • New England Clam Chowder Cup $6

      Everything crackers.

  • Oh Baby, I Like It Raw
    • Peel & Eat Shrimp $3

  • Combos
    • The Raw Deal $25

      4 oysters, 2 clams and 2 shrimp.

    • The Fancy Devil $50

      6 oysters, 6 clams and 6 shrimp.

  • Share-Zies
    • Griddled Corn Bread $5

      Maple butter.

    • Fancy Deviled Eggs $7

      Smoked trout, roe, celery, and pickled mustard seed.

    • Island Creek Fried Oysters $14

      Esquites, roasted tomato, and arugula.

    • Charred Shishitos $8

      Grilled lime and maldon salt.

    • Crispy Burssels Sprouts $8

      Fresno chilies, soy, and lime.

  • Sandwiches
    • Crispy Fish Tacos $12

      Jalapeno + apple slaw and chipotle mayo.

    • Blackened Shrimp Tacos $13

      Pickled onion, avocado, and crema.

    • Backyard Burger $14

      Grass-fed NY beef, cheddar, pickles, shredded lettuce, and special sauce.

    • Fried Chicken Bacon 'Bama $14

      OG recipe, cheddar, tomato, and white BBQ sauce.

  • Supper
    • Extra Fancy Healthy Bowl $15

      Wild rice, roasted beets, harissa hummus, kale, and 6-minute egg.

    • Fish + Chips $18

      Beer-battered hake, slaw, and tartar sauce.

    • Slow Roasted 5 Slice Ribs $19

      Cabbage, bok choy, hoisin, and sesame.

  • Did You Say Fries?
    • Rosemary Fries $6

      Old bay-onnaise and fried rosemary.

    • Sweet Potato Fries $8

      Scallion buttermilk dip.

    • NE Clam Chowder Fries $12

      Sweet potato fries, chowda, chopped bits o' bacon, and chives.

    • Lobster Bisque Fries $17

      Lobster + shrimp gravy and herbs.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.