What is Grubhub
Through online ordering, we connect hungry people with the best local restaurants. Explore restaurants near you to find what you love.
Why use Grubhub
Order popular dishes from a variety of restaurants. Get your order delivered or pick it up.
Bagel Jay's
We make ordering easy. Learn more
- 2130 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216
-
No cuisines specified
-
Grubhub.com
-
Bagel Jay's
-
We make ordering easy.
- Menu
-
Eggel BagelsFarm fresh favorites-all day long!
-
No. 1. Egg and Cheese Bagel $3.39
-
No. 2. Egg, Ham and Cheese Bagel $4.39
-
No. 3. Egg, Bacon and Cheese Bagel $4.39
-
No. 4. Egg, Chicken Sausage and Cheese $4.39
-
-
ShmearsIt doesn't come any better than this! Our spreads are made with the freshest cream cheese available. You'll find plenty of hand-chopped vegetables, pure honey, strawberries and smoked salmon.
-
Plain Shmear on a Bagel $2.99
-
Tub of Plain Shmear $3.29
-
Plain Lite Shmear on a Bagel $2.99
-
Tub of Plain Lite Shmear $3.29
-
Flavored Shmear on a Bagel $3.49
-
Tub of Flavored Shmear $4.59
-
Lox Shmear on a Bagel $4.19
-
Tub of Lox Shmear $5.29
-
Bagel with Butter $2.19
-
Bagel with Smart Balance $2.19
-
Bagel with Jelly $1.89
-
Bagel with PB&J $3.19
-
-
Oven FreshThe way they're supposed to be! Jay's secret recipe- New York style, hearth baked fresh throughout the day!
-
Single Bagel $1.40
-
1/2 Dozen Bagel $7.49
-
Baker's Dozen Bagel $13.49
-
Sack of Bagels and More $16.99
Baker's dozen with a tub of butter and tub of shmear.
-
Cinnamon Stick $1.79
-
Asiago $1.89
-
Oatmeal $1.75
-
-
Soup of the Day
-
Regular Soup du Jour $2.69
-
Large Soup du Jour $3.39
-
Regular Chili $3.99
-
Large Chili $4.99
-
Regular Chili with Buttered Bagel $4.99
-
-
Salads
-
Whitefish Salad $8.29
-
Cream Cheese and Nova $8.99
-
Greek Salad $5.49
-
Caesar Salad $5.49
-
Classic Salad Plate $7.99
Choice of 2 scoops of our classic salads - tuna, egg or chicken, with lettuce, tomato, cukes and bagel chips.
-
-
Deli FavoritesAny deli sandwich made on your choice of bagel, wheat wrap, NY rye, Asiago, wheatberry bread or focaccia with your choice of lettuce, tomato, cukes, red onion, hot banana peppers and alfalfa sprouts.
-
Roasted Turkey Breast Sandwich $6.35
-
Ham Sandwich $6.35
-
Roast Beef Sandwich $7.30
-
Corned Beef Sandwich $7.30
-
BLT Sandwich $5.39
-
-
Jay's ClassicsAvailable on your choice of bagel, or wheat wrap.
-
Tuna Salad Sandwich $6.35
-
Tuna Melt Sandwich $6.95
-
Chicken Salad Sandwich $6.95
-
Egg Salad Sandwich $6.35
-
Cheese Melt Sandwich $2.99
-
Pizza Bagel Sandwich $4.69
-
Veggie Delight Sandwich $4.69
Lettuce, tomato, cukes, onions, alfalfa sprouts and deli mustard.
-
Hummus Sandwich $5.79
-
Cream Cheese and Nova Sandwich $8.99
-
Greek Salad Sandwich $5.49
-
Caesar Salad Sandwich $5.49
-
Green Salad with Tuna Sandwich $7.29
-
Chicken Caesar Salad Sandwich $7.49
-
Classic Salad Plate Sandwich $7.99
Choice of 2 scoops of our classic salads - tuna, egg or chicken, with lettuce, tomato, cukes and bagel chips.
-
-
Taste Tempting Specialties
-
The Delaware $7.79
Roasted turkey, Swiss cheese, coleslaw and Russian dressing.
-
The Buffalo Club $7.79
Roasted turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise.
-
Albuquerque Turkey $7.79
Roasted turkey, a shmear of red pepper jalapeno, lettuce and tomato.
-
Athens Turkey $7.79
Turkey breast, hummus with feta, lettuce, tomato and special dressing.
-
Mediterranean Tuna Spectacular $7.79
Our classic tuna, provolone cheese, sliced black olives, special dressing, lettuce and tomato.
-
Hummus Wrap Spectacular $7.79
Hummus, feta, black olives, red onion and special dressing.
-
The Snyder $7.79
Sahlen's ham with scallion shmear, lettuce and tomato.
-
The Reuben $8.29
Hot corned beef or roasted turkey, melted Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and Russian dressing.
-
The Hopkins $8.29
Hot corned beef, Swiss cheese, coleslaw and Russian dressing.
-
The Downtowner $8.29
Rare roast beef, red onion, hot banana peppers and a shmear of garlic and herb.
-
Athens Chicken $8.29
Marinated chicken, hummus with feta, lettuce tomato and special dressing.
-
Chicken Club Wrap $8.29
Wheat wrap with marinated chicken, bacon, lettuce and tomato on ranch dressing.
-
Chicken Caesar Wrap $8.29
Marinated chicken breast, Asiago cheese, lettuce, tomato and Caesar dressing.
-
The Hertel $8.29
Turkey, ham, pepperoni, melted provolone, tomato, banana pepper and special dressing on a toasted foccaccia.
-
-
Side Orders
-
Chips $1.45
-
Potato Salad $1.85
-
Coleslaw $1.85
-
Yogurt Parfait $4.19
With blueberries and strawberries
-
-
Desserts
-
Cookie $1.95
Chocolate chip or M&M with chocolate.
-
Chocolate Covered Macaroon $1.95
-
Brownie $2.79
-
Crumb Cake $2.79
Apple, Blueberry, and Coffee
-
Pound Cake $2.79
Iced Lemon, Chocolate, Marbled, Plain, Banana Nut, Cinnamon Swirl, and Orange Poppy cakes
-
Black and White Cookie $2.79
-
Yogurt Parfait $3.99
-
Muffin with Butter $2.99
Blueberry and Chocolate Muffins
-
Muffin $2.29
Blueberry and Chocolate Muffins
-
Pastry Heart $2.69
-
Cinnamon Twist $2.69
-
-
Beverages
-
Jakee's Java $2.19+
Our finest dark roast.
-
Iced Coffee $2.99
-
Hot Chocolate $2.19+
-
Hot Tea $2.19
-
French Vanilla Cappuccino $2.79+
-
Fountain Beverages $2.19+
-
Pure Leaf Bottle $2.85
-
Dr Brown's $2.85
-
Juice $2.85
-
Gatorade $2.85
-
Milk $1.60
-
Aquafina Water $1.80
-
-
Java To Go Box
-
Java to Go Box $17.99
Includes cream, sugar, stirrers and cups.
-
Menu for Bagel Jay's provided by Allmenus.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.