Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe
(631) 424-4034

We make ordering easy.

Custom Order

Please call the store first to place your order. Enter invoice number in special instructions.
- Custom Order $5.00
  
  Please call the store first to place your order. Enter the invoice number in special instructions.

Breakfast Pastries
- Apple Horn $12.95
- Pecan Ring $12.95
- Philly Fluff $10.95
  
  Pound cake.
- Sfogliatella $3.95
- Scone $3.50
- Elephant Ear $3.95
  
  Puff pastry.
- Hamantash $3.95
- Linzer Tart $3.50
  
  Cookie.
- Small Turnover $2.95
- Almond Horn $3.95
  
  Ends both dipped in chocolate.
- Donuts $2.00
- Muffin $3.75
- Diet Pastry $3.75
- Crumb Cake $3.00
- Crumb Bun $2.00
- Assorted Danish $24.00+
- Donuts $12.00+
- Croissants $4.50
- Filled Croissant $4.75
  
  Almond or chocolate.
- Fruit Danish $3.75
- Cheese Danish $3.75
- Cigar $4.00

Large Cookie
- M&M Cookie $4.50
- Sugar Cookie $4.50
- Rainbow Cookie $4.50
- Chinese Cookie $4.50
- Peanut Butter Cookie $4.50
- Oatmeal Cookie $4.50
- Chocolate Chip Cookie $4.50

Gluten Free Items
- Cheese Cake $5.25
- Macaroons $2.50
- Almond Horns $4.00
- Coconut Macaroons Dipped in Chocolate $2.50
- Gluten Free Cookie $2.95

Cookie Trays
- Cookie Box $22.95
  
  1 lb.
- 1 lb. Assorted Biscotti $22.95
  
  Cranberry walnut, double chocolate and pistachio.
- 1 lb. Sugar Free Cookie Box $21.95
- Cookie Tray $30.00+

Bread
- Salt Stick Bread $0.95
- Bagel $1.50
- Whole Wheat Bread $5.50
- White Bread $5.50
- Kaiser Roll $0.95
- Semolina Bread $5.00
- Large Rye Bread $6.50
  
  No seeds.
- Egg Rolls $0.95
- Pumpernickel Round Bread $5.50
- Italian Bread $2.95
- French Baguette Bread $3.50
- Cinnamon Raisin Loaf Bread $6.50
- Challah Bread $6.50
- Rustic Sourdough Bread $6.50
- Rye Bread $5.00
  
  No seed.

Cake Pop
- Chocolate Cake Pop $2.95
- Vanilla Cake Pop $2.95
- Red Velvet Cake Pop $2.95

Coffee
- Coffee $2.50+
- Large Iced Coffee $2.75
- Tea $2.00+
- Espresso $2.15
- Cappuccino $3.00
- Latte $2.75

Buttercream and Whip Cream Cakes

Serves 5 to 7 people.
- Strawberry Shortcake Cake $25.00
- Brown Derby Cake $25.00
- Black Forrest Cake $25.00
- Cannoli Cake $25.00
- Mocha Buttercream Cake $25.00
- Oreo Buttercream Cake $25.00
- Carrot Cake $25.00
- Vanilla Shadow Cake $25.00
- Chocolate Shadow Cake $25.00
- Fresh Fruit Salad Cake $25.00
- Lemon Buttercream Cake $25.00
- Funfetti Cake $25.00
- Chocolate Cake Chocolate Fudge Cake $25.00
- Vanilla Cake Chocolate Fudge Cake $25.00
- Vanilla Flower Cake $25.00
- Chocolate Flower Cake $25.00
- Vanilla Mini Birthday Cake $12.95
- Chocolate Mini Birthday Cake $12.95

French Pastry

Easter Bunnies

Chocolate Easter bunnies.
- Large Bunny $24.95
- Medium Easter Bunny $13.95
- Running Easter Bunny $16.95
- Easter Egg $12.95
- Easter Bread $12.95

Italian Pastry
- Lobster Tail $4.95
- Cannoli $4.95
- Chocolate Cannoli $4.95
- Napoleon Slice $4.95
- Tiramisu Slice $4.95
- 7 Layer Slice $4.95
- Carrot Cake Slice $4.95
- Custard Eclair $4.95
- Whip Cream Eclair $4.95

Log Cakes

Serves 5 to 7 people.
- 7 Layer Cake $24.95
- White Chocolate Fudge 7 Layer $24.95
- Rainbow Log Cake $24.95
- Checkerboard Log Cake $24.95

Mousse Cakes

Pies

Cheesecake

Fruit Cheesecake

Macaroons
- Coconut Macaroon $2.50
- Pistachio Macaroon $2.50
- Strawberry Macaroon $2.50
- Raspberry Macaroon $2.50
- Blueberry Macaroon $2.50
- Lemon Macaroon $2.50
- Caramel Macaroon $2.50

Cupcakes
- Hostess Cupcake $3.25
- Vanilla Cake Vanilla Buttercream Cupcake $3.25
- Chocolate Cake Chocolate Buttercream Cupcake $3.25
- Red Velvet Cupcake $3.25
- Carrot Cake Cupcake $3.25
- Themed Cupcake $3.25
- Cookie Monster Cupcake $3.25
- Funfetti Cupcake $3.25

Menu for Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

What is Grubhub

Why use Grubhub

Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe