• New York
  • Islip
  • The Gatsby

The Gatsby

(631) 581-1900
  • 712 Main St, Islip, NY 11751
  • Website
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • Italian
(631) 581-1900
  • Main
  • Catering
  • Lunch
  • Prix Fixe
  • Desserts
    • Apple Cobbler Vanilla Ice Cream $8

    • Creme Brulee $8

    • Chocolate Souffle Cake $8

      bruleed banana, vanilla ice cream

    • Homemade Tiramisu $8

    • Basmati Rice Pudding $7

    • Ice Cream & Sorbets $6

    • Seasonal Fruit $8

    • Angel Food Cake $7

      key lime custard marinated berries

    • Pastry Chef Josue Ramos

  • Antipasti (Appetizers)
    • Clam Chowder $6.95

      chopped clams, potato, onion, celery, carrots with clam stock & touch of tomato

    • Zuppa Di Cozze $9.95

      cultivated mussels, white wine, lemon herb butter broth

    • Calamari Fritti $10.95

      crispy calamari with spicy arrabiatta tomato sauce

    • Gamberi & Calamari Alla Griglia $11.95

      garlic herb marinade, lemon oil, arugula salad

    • Cocktail Di Gamberi $12.95

      4 jumbo shrimp served with cocktail sauce

    • Torte Di Crab $9.95

      sauteed lump crab cakes with corn relish, sauce remoulade & lemon

    • Mozzarella En Carozza $8.95

      egg battered bread & cheese melt with tomato vinaigrette

    • Vongole Orreganata $9.95

      6 thyme scented chopped middlenecks baked with seasoned bread crumbs

    • Torta Primavera Rollatini $8.95

      sauteed seasonal vegetables wrapped in thin phyllo dough, baked and served with roasted peppered tomato sauce

  • Antipasti (Appetizers)
    • Seared Yellowfin Tuna $10.95

      served rare with tomato caper relish

  • Insalate (Salads)
    • Insalata Nico $9.95

      baby greens tossed with white balsamic vinaigrette, mandarin oranges, toasted sunflower seeds, dried cranberry & provolone cheese

    • Beef Carpaccio $10.95

      seared & cured filet mignon with roasted pepper salad, capers, dijon mustard sauce

    • Caesar Salad $7.95

      romaine hearts, croutons, pecorino, traditional dressing

    • Insalata Di Spinaci $8.95

      sherry vinaigrette, bacon crisps, crimini mushrooms, red onion

    • Hearts Of Romaine $7.95

      crisp pancetta, blue cheese dressing

    • Insalata Tricolore $9.95

      baby arugula, radicchio & endive with balsamic vinaigrette & gorgonzola

    • Insalata Con Pomodoro $7.95

      baby field greens tossed with tomatoes & balsamic vinaigrette

    • Layered Heirloom Tomato & Fresh Mozzarella $9.95

      balsamic reduction, basil oil & herb crostini

    • Insalata Di Mar $9.95

      calamari, shrimp & scallops with red onion, tomato & olives, tossed with a lemon vinaigrette dressing

  • Entrees Pesci (Fish)
    • Salmona Alla Griglia $25.95

      grilled atlantic salmon, black olive tapenade, asparagus & fingerling potatoes, dijon vinaigrette

    • Pan Seared Yellow Fin Tuna $27.95

      roasted tomato & garlic relish, warm lentils, basil oil sushi grade tuna with balsamic marinade

    • Pistachio Herb Roasted Gamberi $21.95

      jumbo shrimp, nut & herb crust served with cous-cous salad & lemon oil

    • Crispy Branzino $27.95

      warm eggplant caponata, sauteed broccoli rabe

    • Risotto Al Frutti Di Mare $21.95

      sauteed shrimp, scallops, diced plum tomato, finished with parmesan cheese & fresh herbs

    • Gamberi Fra Diablo $19.95

      striped bass with warm eggplant caponata, sauteed broccoli rabe

    • Pesci Del Giorno

  • Carni En Pollo (Meats & Chicken)
    • Costata Di Maiale $27.95

      panco crusted pork chop, parmesan crushed potato, braised escarole, white beans, roasted garlic, pork jus

    • Cololetta Milanese $17.95

      lightly breaded veal cutlet topped with arugula salad, tomato, basil, pecorino romano

    • Pollo Alla Francese $16.95

      egg battered, sauteed & finished with white wine, lemon butter sauce, stacked potato & sauteed spinach

    • Pollo Alla Parmigiana $16.95

      lightly breaded cutlet fried then baked with mozzarella served with angel hair pasta

    • Pollo Alla Griglia $15.95

      lemon rosemary marinated breast grilled & topped with arugula salad & tomato

    • Marinated Skirt Steak $27.95

      grilled and sliced, topped with arugula salad, tomato, lemon vinaigrette, mashed potato

    • Costoletta D'Agnello Alla Griglia $31.95

      grilled lamb chops, rosemary, garlic marinade, white beans, escarole, tomato & olives

    • Pollo Alla Milanese $15.95

      lightly breaded cutlet topped with arugula salad, tomato, basil, pecorino romano

    • Scaloppini Di Vitello $18.95

      sauteed veal with artichoke puree, mozzarella cheese, bordelaise sauce, stacked potato & sauteed spinach

    • Pollo Alla Scarpariello $21.95

      french cut breast with sausage, caramelized peppers, onions & mushrooms, chicken jus

    • Filetto Di Manzo $35.95

      grilled filet mignon , sauteed spinach, cheese & spinach ciambella, port wine demi-glace, gorgonzola fondutta

    • Classic Surf & Turf $44.95

      filet mignon & broiled lobster tail served with mashed potatoes

    • Scaloppina Di Vitello Alla Sorrentino $18.95

      veal scaloppini, topped with eggplant, fresh mozzarella, bordelaise sauce, stacked potato & sauteed spinach

    • Cololetta Parmigiana $17.95

      lightly breaded veal fried then baked with mozzarella served with angel hair pasta

  • Contorni (Sides)
    • Potato Puree $6

    • Sauteed Spinach $7

    • Braised Escarole & Beans $7

    • Brocolli Rape $7

  • Catering Menus - Cold
    Cocktail hour passed hors-d'oeuvres. Please choose three from each category.
    • Marinated Vegetable Salad

      fresh herbs, e.v.o., cucumber cup

    • prosciutto Wrapped Melon

      midori mint syrup

    • Spiced Yellowfin Tuna

      pickled ginger, seaweed salad, wonton crisp

    • Tomato Bruschetta

      aged balsamic, e.v.o. crostini

    • Chilled Beef Tortilla

      cilantro oil, tortilla crisp

    • White Bean Bruschetta

      roasted garlic, black olive tapenade

    • Tomato Basil Chicken Salad

      grilled chicken, tomato relish, water cracker

    • Herb Goat Cheese Crostini

      seasoned cheese, roasted peppers, crostini

  • Catering Menus - Hot
    Cocktail hour passed hors-d?oeuvres. Please choose three from each category.
    • B.b.q. Duck Confit

      tortilla crisp, cilantro

    • Scallop & Bacon

      applewood smoked bacon, balsamic reduction

    • Veal & Fennel Meatballs

      tomato basil sauce

    • Wild Mushroom Arancini

      risotto rice ball, herb aioli

    • Garlic & Basil Chicken Skewers

      roasted tomato vinaigrette

    • Mozzarella En Corozza "Fingers"

      fresh cheese melt, basil oil

    • Mini Lump Crab Cakes

      maryland style, sauce remoulade

    • Pigs-N- Blanket

      kosher dog, puff pastry, dijon mustard

  • Buffet - Salad
    All buffets are served with chef's daily vegetable & starch of the day
    • House Field Green Salad

      with balsamic vinaigrette & tomato

    • Classic Caesar Salad

      with romaine hearts, creamy garlic dressing, parmesan cheese

  • Buffet - Chicken
    All buffets are served with chef?s daily vegetable & starch of the day. Please select one from each category:
    • Sauteed Breast Of Chicken

      with wild mushroom port wine demi- glace

    • Grilled Chicken

      with tomato, black olives & herbs

    • Lemon Chicken

      with sauteed artichoke & caper butter sauce

    • Chicken Parmigiana

      with mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce

  • Buffet - Pasta
    All buffets are served with chef?s daily vegetable & starch of the day. Please select one from each category:
    • Penne Carbonara

      crisp bacon, fresh peas in a parmesan cream sauce

    • Rigatoni A La Vodka

      light tomato cream with pecorino romano

    • Orecchiette & Broccoli Rabe

      roasted garlic, flakes, chicken broth

    • Farfalle Fileto De Pomodoro

      crusted tomato basil sauce

  • Buffet - Seafood
    All buffets are served with chef?s daily vegetable & starch of the day. Please select one from each category:
    • Oven Roasted Atlantic Salmon

      with white wine herb jus

    • Panco Crusted Chatham Codfish

      with lemon thyme voloute

    • Sauteed Cultivated Mussels

      in a spicy arrabiatta sauce

    • Herb "Dusted" Mahi Mahi

      plum tomato caper butter sauce

  • Buffet - Meat
    All buffets are served with chef?s daily vegetable & starch of the day. Please select one from each category:
    • Marinated Skirt Steak

      with tomato basil relish, italian parsley oil

    • Sweet & Hot Sausage & Peppers

      with tomato & caramelized onions

    • Sliced Boneless Pork Loin

      with roasted tomato pork jus

    • Grilled Hanger Steak

      with fresh herb bordelaise sauce

  • Nico Carving Station Supplement
    • Roasted Breast Of Turkey

      with pan gravy

    • Boneless Leg Of Lamb

      with rosemary mint rub in merlot lamb jus

    • Roasted Roast Beef

      with horseradish cream

  • Three Course Sit Down - Appetizer
    Choice of one.
    • Nico Tri Color Salad Of Endive

      radicchio, baby arugula with balsamic vinaigrette & gorgonzola cheese

    • Classic Caesar Salad

      with hearts of romaine, creamy garlic dressing, seasoned croutons & parmesan cheese

    • Simple Field Green Salad

      baby greens dressed with plum tomatoes, lemon herb vinaigrette

    • Cheese Ravioli

      with roasted tomato basil butter sauce

    • Pan Seared Atlantic Salmon Cakes

      with lemon caper aioli

    • Wild Mushroom Tart

      with creamy leeks, parmesan cream port wine sauce

    • Rigatoni Fileto De Pomodoro

      crushed tomato fresh basil sauce

    • Maryland Lump Crab Cakes

      roasted corn relish spicy remoulade sauce

    • Roasted Tiger Shrimp

      sweet bell pepper vinaigrette, warm white bean stew

  • Sit Down Dinner Entrees: Chicken
    • Herb "Dusted" Breast Of Chicken

      summer ratatouille vegetable, fresh basil oil

    • Chicken & Wild Mushroom Sautee

      potato puree with a thyme scented chicken jus

    • Marinated Grilled Chicken Breast

      aged balsamic marinade, sauteed asparagus, roasted tomato compote

  • Sit Down Dinner Entrees: Fish
    • Grilled Mahi Mahi Filet

      roasted corn relish, sauteed bell pepper vinaigrette

    • Pan Seared Swordfish Steak

      tomato caper butter sauce

    • Roasted Atlantic Salmon Filet

      asparagus & mushroom hash, white wine lemon veloute

  • Sit Down Dinner Entrees: Meat
    • Grilled Center Cut Pork Chop

      rib chop with white bean & escarole, parmesan crust & pork jus

    • Marinated Skirt Steak

      topped with arugula tomato salad, gorgonzola fondutte

    • Peppered Hanger Steak

      sliced steak, potato puree, bordelaise sauce

    • Seared Yellowfin Tuna

      roasted tomato & garlic relish, warm lentils

    • Grilled Filet Mignon

      red onion marmalade, potato puree, port wine demi- glace

    • Rack Of Lamb

      rosemary & garlic marinade, white beans, escarole, tomato & olives

  • Occasion Cake- Coffee, Tea & Decafe
    • Occasion Cake- Coffee, Tea & Decafe

  • Antipasti (Appetizers)
    • Clam Chowder $5.95

      chopped clams, potato, onion, celery, carrots with clam stock & touch of tomato

    • Calamari Fritti $9.95

      crispy calamari with spicy arrabiatta tomato sauce

    • Cocktail Di Gamberi $11.95

      4 jumbo shrimp served with cocktail sauce

    • Mozzarella En Carozza $7.95

      egg battered bread & cheese melt with tomato vinaigrette

    • Vongole Orreganata $8.95

      6 thyme scented chopped middlenecks baked with seasoned bread crumbs

    • Torta Primavera Rollatini $7.95

      sauteed seasonal vegetables wrapped in thin phyllo dough, baked, roasted peppered tomato sauce

  • Insalate (Salads)
    • Insalata Di Spinaci $7.95

      sherry vinaigrette, bacon crisps, crimini mushrooms, red onion. all of the above with grilled chicken $4.95. all of the above with grilled shrimp $8.95.

    • Insalate Tricolore $8.95

      baby arugula, radicchio & endive with balsamic vinaigrette & gorgonzola. all of the above with grilled chicken $4.95. all of the above with grilled shrimp $8.95.

    • Caesar Salad $6.95

      romaine hearts, croutons, pecorino. all of the above with grilled chicken $4.95. all of the above with grilled shrimp $8.95.

    • Hearts Of Romaine $6.95

      crisp pancetta, blue cheese dressing.

    • Insalate Con Pomodoro $6.95

      baby field greens tossed with balsamic vinaigrette

    • Layered Heirloom Tomato & Fresh Mozzarella $8.95

      balsamic reduction, basil oil & herb crostini.

    • Insalata Di Mar $8.95

      calamari, shrimp & scallops with red onion, tomato & olives, lemon vinaigrette dressing

  • Farinacei (Pasta)
    • Fettuccini Primavera $12.95

      sauteed zucchini, squash, peppers, mushrooms, sundried tomato & onions, olive oil, fresh herb sauce

    • Orecchiette Con Rape $13.95

      hot & sweet sausage with garlic, broccoli rabe, chicken stock

    • Gnocchi Al Pesto $12.95

      fresh basil, pecorino pine nut puree, tossed with fresh potato gnocchi

    • Rigatoni Bolognese $13.95

      meat sauce with beef & veal finished with a touch of cream & pecorino cheese

    • Aragosta Ravioli Con Gamberi $20.95

      striped fresh lobster filled ravioli with sauteed shrimp in a sherry cream sauce.

  • Sandwiches
    • Grilled Sirloin Burger $12.95

      lettuce, tomato, onion & house cut fries

    • Open Faced Steak Sandwich $14.95

      marinated skirt steak, house cut fries, mozzarella, sauteed onions, balsamic steak sauce on napoli bread

  • Entrees Pesci (Fish)
    • Salmona Alla Griglia $23.95

      black olive tapenade, asparagus & fingerling potatoes, dijon vinaigrette

    • Pan Seared Yellow Fin Tuna $25.95

      sushi grade tuna with balsamic marinade, roasted tomato & garlic relish, warm lentils, basil oil

    • Pistachio Herb Roasted Gamberi $21.95

      jumbo shrimp, nut & herb crust served with cous-cous salad & lemon oil

    • Pesci Di Giorno

  • Carni En Pollo (Meats & Chicken)
    • Pollo Alla Parmigiana $14.95

      lightly breaded cutlet fried then baked with mozzarella served with fresh angel hair

    • Pollo Alla Griglia $13.95

      lemon rosemary marinated breast grilled & topped with arugula salad & tomato

    • Pollo Alla Milanese $13.95

      lightly breaded cutlet topped with arugula salad, tomato, basil, pecorino romano

    • Cololetta Parmigiana $15.95

      lightly breaded veal fried then baked with mozzarella served with fresh angel hair

    • Cololetta Milanese $15.95

      lightly breaded veal cutlet topped with arugula salad, tomato, basil, pecorino romano

  • Contorni (Sides)
    • Potato Puree $5

    • Sauteed Spinach $6

    • Braised Escarole & Beans $6

    • Broccoli Rabe $6

  • Lunch Three Course
    • Appetizer

      caesar salad, soup of the day or goat cheese agnolotti.

    • Main Course

      grilled atlantic salmon, classic chicken milanese, rigatoni bolognese.

    • Dessert

      seasonal fresh fruit, basmati rice pudding, sorbet or ice-cream

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.