- New York
- Middle Village
- The Original Carlo's Pizzeria
The Original Carlo's Pizzeria
Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.
-
The Original Carlo's Pizzeria
-
- Menu
-
Big Game Special Packages
-
Package 1 $50.00
1 regular pie, 12 wings, 12 mozzarella sticks, 12 garlic knots and 1liter soda.
-
Package 2 $85.00
2 pies, 1 sicillian pie , 30 wings, 1 free topping and 2 liter soda.
-
Package 3 $60.00
2 pies,24 wings and 2 liter soda.
-
Package 4 $55.00
2 pies,1 free topping , 12 garlic knots and 2 liter soda.
-
Package 6 $45.00
1 regular pie, 12 wings and 12 garlic knots.
-
-
Carlos Homemade Sauce To Go
-
Vodka Sauce
Pint size filled with our homemade vodka sauce
-
Tomato & basil Sauce
Pint size filled with our homemade Tomato & basil sauce
-
Fra Diavolo sauce
Pint size filled with our spicy marinara sauce
-
Marinara sauce
Pint size filled marinara sauce with tomato and fresh garlic
-
-
Beverages
-
Coffee $4.00
-
Espresso $3.50
-
Cappuccino $5.00
-
Tea $3.00
-
Can Soda $2.00
-
1 Liter Soda $3.00
-
2 Liter Soda $4.00
-
Snapple $2.50
-
Juice $2.00
-
Bottled Water $2.00
-
-
Salads
-
Cold Antipasto
-
Seafood Salad $19.00
-
House Salad
-
Grilled Chicken Salad
-
Caesar Salad
-
Caesar Salad with Chicken
-
Avocado Salad
-
Chef Salad
Hard-boiled egg, ham, provolone, onions, tomatoes, and black olives.
-
Greek Salad
-
Calamari Salad $16.00
-
Buffalo Chicken Salad
-
Carlos salad $17.00
Arugula, fried calamari, and feta cheese
-
Arugula salad
-
-
Appetizers
-
Bruschetta Bread $13.00
-
Buffalo fried calamari $19.00
Spicy fried calamari topped with drizzled blue cheese
-
Hot Antipasto $19.00
-
Stuffed Mushroom $14.00
-
Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato $16.00
-
Roasted Pepper and Fresh Mozzarella $17.00
-
Shrimp Cocktail $17.00
-
Baked Clams $15.00
Half dozen.
-
Mussels $17.00
Marinara or white wine.
-
Fried Calamari $16.00
-
Mozzarella Sticks $8.00
Six pieces.
-
Garlic Bread $6.00
-
Garlic Knots $4.50
Six pieces.
-
Buffalo Wings $7.00
Six pieces.
-
French Fries
-
Zucchini Sticks
-
Soup of the Day
-
Spinach Side Order
-
Broccoli Side Order
-
Broccoli Rabe
-
Artichoke $8.00
Call us for availability
-
Calamari Oreganato $19.00
-
Calamari Alla Carlo’s $19.00
Hot cherry peppers, seasoned in fra diavolo glaze
-
-
Hot Heroes
-
Meatball Hero $8.00
-
Veal cutlet with lettuce & tomato hero $14.00
-
Chicken with lettuce & Tomato hero $12.00
-
Chicken Caesar hero $13.00
Your choice of chicken grilled or fried with Romain lettuce, topped with Caesar dressing
-
Drunken meatball hero $12.00
Our homemade meatballs with vodka sauce
-
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Hero $15.00
-
Drunken Veal cutlet hero $15.00
Veal cutlet topped with our famous homemade vodka sauce
-
Drunken chicken hero $13.00
Chicken cutlet topped with our famous homemade vodka sauce
-
Drunken shrimp hero $15.00
Fried shrimp with vodka sauce
-
Veal Cutlet Roasted Pepper Fresh Mozzarella hero $16.00
-
Chicken Cutlet Roasted Pepper Fresh Mozzarella Hero $14.00
-
Sausage Hero $9.00
-
Chicken Cutlet Hero $10.50
-
Sausage and Peppers Hero $11.00
-
Eggplant Hero $9.00
-
Grilled Chicken Hero $10.50
-
Veal Cutlet Hero $12.00
-
Veal and Peppers Hero $13.00
-
Egg Hero $8.00
With peppers or potatoes.
-
Fried Shrimp Hero $11.00
With lemon or tartar sauce.
-
Shrimp Hero $11.00
With marinara sauce.
-
Cheesesteak Hero $13.00
-
Chicken Marsala Hero $12.00
-
Chicken Francese Hero $12.00
-
Chicken Bacon Ranch Hero $12.00
-
Buffalo Chicken Hero $12.00
-
-
Chicken EntréesEntrées are served with your choice of side.
-
Chicken Capriciossa $21.00
Breast of chicken with fresh diced tomatoes, red onions, and balsamic vinegar.
-
Chicken Francese $21.00
Breast of chicken sautéed with white wine, butter, and lemon.
-
Chicken Marsala $21.00
Breast of chicken sautéed with mushrooms and Marsala wine.
-
Chicken Rollatini $24.00
Breast of chicken stuffed with prosciutto or spinach and provolone in white wine.
-
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana $17.00
Breast of chicken in a marinara sauce with Parmigiana.
-
Chicken Cutlet $15.00
Breast of chicken in a marinara sauce.
-
Chicken Pizziola $22.00
Breast of chicken sautéed with mushrooms and a touch of marinara sauce.
-
Chicken Cacciatore $23.00
Breast of chicken sautéed with mushroom, onion, pepper, olive, and a touch of marinara sauce.
-
Chicken Sorentino $24.00
Eggplant, prosciutto, and cheese with mushroom sauce.
-
Chicken Alla Carlo's $24.00
Fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, in a mushroom sauce
-
-
Veal EntréesEntrées are served with your choice of side.
-
Veal Rollatini $24.00
Veal stuffed with prosciutto or spinach and provolone in a white wine sauce.
-
Veal spiedini $25.00
Veal stuffed with chopped prosciutto, bread crumbs, & provolone
-
Veal Francese $23.00
Veal sautéed with white wine, butter, and lemon.
-
Veal Capriciossa $23.00
Veal with fresh diced tomatoes, red onion, and balsamic vinegar.
-
Veal Marsala $23.00
Veal sautéed with mushrooms in a Marsala sauce.
-
Veal Parmigiana $19.00
Veal in a marinara sauce with Parmigiana.
-
Veal Cutlet $17.00
Veal in a marinara sauce.
-
Veal Sorentino $26.00
Veal, eggplant, prosciutto, and cheese sautéed with mushroom sauce.
-
Veal Pizziola $24.00
Veal sautéed with mushrooms and a touch of marinara sauce.
-
Veal Alla Carlo’s $26.00
Fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, in a mushroom sauce
-
-
Seafood EntréesEntrées are served with your choice of side.
-
Shrimp Oreganato $23.00
Broiled with bread crumbs and a touch of clam sauce.
-
Fish & Chips $15.00
Fried flounder fish filet, French fries, with a side of tarter sauce
-
Salmon Oreganato $26.00
-
Calamari Oreganato $21.00
Broiled with breadcrumbs and a touch of clam sauce.
-
Shrimp $18.50
Sautéed with a marinara sauce or tartar sauce.
-
Shrimp Scampi $23.00
Sautéed with white wine, butter, and lemon.
-
Shrimp Francese $23.00
Sautéed with white wine, butter, and lemon.
-
Shrimp Parmigiana $20.00
Sautéed in a marinara sauce and Parmigiana.
-
Shrimp and Calamari $25.00
Sautéed in a marinara sauce.
-
Scungilli and Calamari $26.00
Sautéed in a marinara sauce.
-
Scungilli and Shrimp $27.00
Sautéed in a marinara sauce.
-
Scungilli $21.00
Sautéed in a marinara sauce.
-
Calamari Marinara $20.00
Sautéed in a marinara sauce.
-
Seafood Marinara $28.00
-
Seafood Fra Diavolo $28.00
-
Fish Fillet $24.00
Broiled or fried.
-
Fish Fillet Francese $26.00
Sautéed with white wine, butter, and lemon.
-
Shrimp & Chicken Alla Francese $28.00
-
-
Vegetarian EntréesEntrées are served with your choice of side.
-
Eggplant $13.00
With marinara sauce.
-
Eggplant Parmigiana $15.00
Eggplant with marinara and Parmigiana.
-
Eggplant Rollatini $18.00
Eggplant with ricotta and Parmigiana in a marinara sauce.
-
-
Steak
-
Skirt Steak $26.00
-
Carlo's Skirt Steak $29.00
Cherry peppers & onions
-
Skirt Steak & Broccoli Rabe $30.00
-
-
Pasta Dishes
-
Pasta with Pesto $16.00
Your choice of pasta with our homemade pesto sauce
-
gnocchi $13.00
-
Cavatelli $16.00
-
Lasagna $14.00
-
Baked Ziti $14.00
-
Baked Ziti Sicilian-Style $16.00
Eggplant.
-
Cheese Ravioli $14.00
-
Meat ravioli $14.00
-
Tortellini $14.00
Cheese or meat.
-
Manicotti $13.00
-
Pasta with Meatball $13.00
-
Stuffed Shells $14.00
-
Pasta with Fried Chicken and Broccoli $17.00
-
Pasta with Grilled Chicken & Broccoli $17.00
-
Pasta Alfredo $14.00
-
Pasta with Sausage $13.00
-
Pasta Primavera $16.00
-
Pasta Vodka Sauce $16.00
-
Linguine with Clam Sauce $18.00
-
Pasta with Spinach and Fresh Tomatoes $17.00
-
Pasta with Garlic and Oil $11.00
-
Pasta with Broccoli Rabe and Sausage $17.00
-
Pasta Bolognese $15.00
With meat sauce.
-
Pasta Carbonara $17.00
-
Pasta with Broccoli $14.50
-
Pasta with tomato Sauce $10.00
-
Tortellini with Alfredo $17.00
-
Pasta al Carlo's $15.00
Meat sauce and peas.
-
Spinach Lasagna $16.00
-
Money Bag Alla Vodka $16.00
-
-
Sides
-
Hot Cherry Peppers $6.00
-
Meatballs with Sauce $7.00
-
Sausage with Sauce $7.00
-
-
Brick Oven Pizza
-
Brick Oven Regular Pizza
Plum tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil.
-
Brick Oven Arugula and Prosciutto Pizza
Arugula, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella cheese, and fresh basil
-
Brick Oven Bianca Pizza
Artichokes, ricotta, fresh mozzarella, and basil
-
-
specialties
-
Chicken Roll $9.00
-
Sausage Roll $9.00
-
Broccoli Roll $9.00
-
Eggplant Roll $9.00
-
Cheese Calzone $9.00
-
Cheese Calzone with a Filling $11.00
-
Rice Ball $7.50
-
Pepperoni Roll $5.50
-
Spinach Wheel $5.50
-
Stromboli $9.00
-
Spinach Roll $9.00
-
Potato Croquette $2.00
One piece.
-
Broccoli Rabe and Sausage Panini $13.00
-
Grilled Chicken Panini $10.00
-
Beef Patties $5.00
-
Beef Patties with Cheese $6.00
-
Pepperoni Bites $5.50
five pieces
-
Buffalo Chicken Roll $9.00
-
Stuffed artichoke $8.00
-
-
Speciality Slices
-
Specialty Slice $5.50
-
-
Carlo's Original Pizza and Slices
-
Cheese Pizza
-
Sausage Pizza
-
Meatballs Pizza
-
Pepperoni Pizza
-
Anchovies Pizza
-
Green Peppers Pizza
-
Black Olives Pizza
-
Extra Cheese Pizza
-
Mushrooms Pizza
-
Spinach Pizza
-
Broccoli Pizza
-
Chicken Pizza
-
Eggplant Pizza
-
Sicilian Pie $23.00
-
Carlo's Upside-Down Sicilian Pizza $24.00
Twelve slices.
-
Slice $3.25
-
Sicilian Slice $3.50
-
Grandma Slice $3.50
-
Carlo’s Upside-Down Sicilian Slice $3.50
-
Onion Sfingione Slice $3.50
-
-
Special Pies
-
Vodka Sauce Grandpa Pie $29.00
-
Eggplant Rollatini Pie
Fried eggplant with mozzarella cheese, tomato sauce, and ricotta
-
Carlo’s Money Bag Pie
Cheese filled pasta with your choice of sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese
-
Buffalo Chicken Salad Pie
-
Chicken Marsala Pie
-
Chicken Francese Pie
-
Drunken Grandma Pie $30.00
Grandma pie with vodka sauce
-
Carlo’s Tri Color Grandma pie $30.00
Grandma pie with Pesto, vodka, and marinara sauce
-
Drunken Regular Pie
Regular pie with vodka sauce
-
Drunken Sicilian Pie $30.00
Sicilian pie with vodka sauce
-
Pesto Pie
-
White Pie with Ricotta and Spinach
-
Arugula and Prosciutto Pie
-
White Clam Sauce Pie
-
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pie
-
Artichoke & Spinach Pie
Artichokes, spinach, mozzarella cheese, drizzled in heavy cream
-
Philly Cheese Steak Pie
-
Red Clam Sauce Pie
-
Carlo's Special Pizza
-
White Pizza
Ricotta.
-
Vegetarian Pizza
-
Chicken and Tomato Pizza
-
Fresh Mozzarella and Sliced Tomato Pizza
-
Baked Ziti Pizza
-
Lasagna Pizza
-
Sfingione Pizza $18.00
Onions and bread crumbs.
-
Sicilian Special Pizza $31.00
-
Grandpa Pie $28.00
Pie with Fresh mozzarella topped with marinara sauce
-
Chicken Broccoli Pizza
-
Stuffed Pizza Pie $27.00
Ham or spinach.
-
Grandma Pie $23.00
-
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza
-
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
-
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
-
Penne Vodka Sauce Pizza
-
Hawaiian Pizza
-
BBQ Chicken Pizza
-
Calamari Pizza
-
Salad Pizza
-
Tostino Pizza $31.00
Fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, tomato, basil, and olive oil.
-
White prosciutto pie
Pie with mozzarella, ricotta cheese, and prosciutto
-
-
Pan Pizza
-
Deep Dish Pizza $11.00
"10" inch personal deep dish pizza made to your liking
-
-
Gluten Free Pizza12 inch personal size
-
Gluten Free Pizza $15.00
12 inch personal size pie with mozzarella cheese and sauce
-
-
Daily SpecialsNo substitutions.
-
$1.00 Off Regular Pie Monday Special $18.00
Plum tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil.
-
Pasta with Broccoli Monday Special $13.50
-
Pasta with Bolognese Monday Special $14.00
-
Pasta with Meatballs Tuesday Special $12.00
-
Baked Ziti Tuesday Special $13.00
-
Cheese Ravioli Tuesday Special $13.00
-
Lasagna Wednesday Special $13.00
-
Tortellini Wednesday Special $13.00
-
Manicotti Wednesday Special $12.00
-
Tortellini Alfredo Wednesday Special $16.00
-
Chicken Parmigiana with Pasta Thursday Special $16.00
-
Eggplant Parmigiana with Pasta Thursday Special $14.00
-
Stuffed Shells Thursday Special $13.00
-
-
Desserts
-
Rainbow Cookie Cake $6.00
-
Cannoli $5.50
-
Ice Cream Truffles $7.00
-
Chocolate Mousse Cake $5.50
-
Nutella Pie $14.00
14". Nutella and marshmallows with powdered sugar on top.
-
Tiramisu $5.50
-
Menu for The Original Carlo's Pizzeria provided by Allmenus.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.