• New York
  • New Windsor
  • Brothers Barbecue

Brothers Barbecue

(845) 534-4227
  • 2400 New York 32, New Windsor, NY 12553
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

(845) 534-4227
  • Menu
  • Appetizers
    • Brothers Cheese Fries $10.95

      Fresh-cut fries smothered with melted monterey jack and cheddar cheeses and topped with applewood bacon.

    • Becca's Fried Green Tomatoes $8.95

      Breaded and fried golden brown just like our sister makes.

    • Smoked-Up Onion Strings $8.95

      Smoked onion strips fried golden brown and served with Cajun ranch.

    • Sticky Ribs $13.95

      Smoked ribs caramelized in your choice of our house Barbeque sauce or our Asian Barbeque sauce.

    • Beaufort Shrimp $12.95

      Our delicious shrimp seasoned with our rub and glazed with our famous Barbeque sauce.

    • Hungry Helpers $9.95

      Smoked sausage wrapped in applewood bacon tossed in our Barbeque sauce.

    • Southern Fried Pickles $8.95

      Sour dill pickles breaded and fried golden brown.

    • Uncle Bo's Shrimp $12.95

      Buttermilk-fried then tossed in our homemade buffalo sauce.

    • Down East Poppers $8.95

      Smoked jalapenos stuffed with monterey jack and applewood bacon.

    • Sausage Cheese Plate $8.95

      A delicious selection of cheeses served with smoked sausage and peperoncino.

    • Traditional Brothers Wings $11.95

      Wings smoked with hickory wood 'til juicy and tender, deep fried 'til crispy then tossed in 1 of our homemade sauces: Barbeque, spicy Barbeque, mild, smoked garlic thyme, hot or smoken hot.

    • Boneless Brothers Wings $11.95

      Wings smoked with hickory wood 'til juicy and tender, deep fried 'til crispy then tossed in 1 of our homemade sauces: Barbeque, spicy Barbeque, mild, smoked garlic thyme, hot or smoken hot.

  • Soups & Salads
    • Brothers Tasty Chili $6.95

    • Greek Salad $9.95

    • Dad's Ice Burg Wedge $9.95

      Half a head of lettuce with diced tomatoes, applewood bacon, blue cheese dressing and crumbles.

    • Caesar Salad $8.95

    • Brothers Greens $9.95

      Our house salad greens and veggies.

  • Sandwiches
    All sandwiches come with choice of 1 side and pickles.
    • Smoked Rooster Sandwich $10.95

      Chicken breast seasoned with our rub, grilled and glazed in our famous Barbeque sauce.

    • Gavino Gunslinger Sandwich $14.95

      Juicy grilled chicken breasts topped with applewood bacon, fresh-cut fries and melted American cheese, finished with mayo, lettuceand tomatoes, piled high on a hero.

    • Shrimp Po' Boy $14.95

      Buttermilk-fried gulf shrimp on a hero topped with dijonniase, iceberg lettuce and tomatoes.

    • Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich $12.95

      Buttermilk-dipped fried chicken cutlet on a brioche bun topped with cheddar and applewood bacon.

    • Big Daddy's Steak Sandwich $15.95

      Our in-house hand-cut strip steak sauteed and smothered with smoked onions, peppers, au jusand your choice of cheese.

    • Frankie Boy $13.95

      House-smoked sweet Italian sausage served on a hero with smoked onions and peppers.

  • Burgers
    Our classic half pound burger topped with cheese on a brioche bun is a premium mix of black Angus chuck, porterhouse tips and beef brisket. All our burger are a half-pound and served with fries and choice of cheese.
    • Brothers Classic Burger $10.95

      Our classic burger with cheese on a bun.

    • Stuffed Burger $11.95

      1/2 lb. burger with your choice of cheese stuffed inside and on top, served on a brioche bun. Perfectly melted to ooze when you sink your teeth in.

    • The Porko Burger $15.95

      1/2 lb. burger topped with pulled pork and drizzled with Barbeque sauce, applewood bacon, cheddar and fried onions.

    • The Smokehouse $13.95

      1/2 lb. burger, applewood bacon, smoked onions and smoked jalapenos with age cheddar on a brioche bun.

    • The Big Tex Melt $14.95

      1/2 lb. burger topped with cheese and applewood bacon then sandwiched between 2 grilled cheese sandwiches.

  • From The Pit
    All of our meats are smoked fresh daily using our special blend of woods and spices. All of our meats will have a pinkish tint due to the smoking process. All sandwiches come with choice of one side. All of our plates are served with choice of two sides and pickles.
    • Brisket Sandwich $14.99

      Hand-carved pepper-crusted beef brisket piled on a brioche bun.

    • Chopped BBQ Plate $17.95

      A Southern favorite. The brothers grew up on chopped. Our fresh-smoked pork, chopped and dressed with our Eastern carolina vinegar-based sauce.

    • Bro Ribber $12.95

      Chunks of tasty rib meat caramelized in our Barbeque sauce and served on a brioche bun.

    • Pulled Pork Plate $17.95

      Tender pork smoked low and slow, then hand-pulled to order and drizzled with Barbeque sauce.

    • Brothers Famous Brisket $19.99

      Texas-style dry rub smoked low and slow for over 15 hours 'til it's mouth-watering tender.

    • Meat Combo (2) $20.99

      Choose 2 smoked meats. Brisket, ribs, pulled pork, chopped Barbeque, smoked chicken or sausage.

    • Chopped BBQ Sandwich $13.99

      Our slow-smoked pork chopped and dressed with our Eastern North Carolina vinegar-based sauce, then topped with fresh slaw and pickles on a brioche bun.

    • Pulled Pork Sandwich $12.99

      Our tender pork pulled fresh to order, lightly drizzled with our Barbeque sauce and piled high on a brioche bun.

    • Smoked Chicken Plate $16.95

      Half chicken seasoned with our dry rub, then smoked under tender and juicy.

    • Smoked Rooster Plate $14.95

      Chicken breast seasoned with our rub, grilled and glazed in our famous Barbeque sauce.

    • Smoked Sausage Plate $14.99

      Links of juicy, sweet Italian sausage smoked 'till juicy then kissed on the grill.

    • Sausage Sandwich $10.95

      Juicy links of house-smoked sweet Italian sausage served on a brioche bun.

    • Meat Combo (3) $25.99

      Choose 3 smoked meats. Brisket, ribs, pulled pork, chopped Barbeque, smoked chicken or sausage.

    • The Uncle Dave $32.99

      A sampler of our fine smoked meats: ribs, pulled pork, brisket, chickenand sausage.

  • Family Meals
    • Eat Like a King $62.95

      Full rack of ribs, half a chicken, half pound of brisket and half pound of pulled pork served with 2 large sides. Serves 2 to 4.

  • Southern Specialties
    Some of our family's favorite dishes to share around the dinner table.
    • Mama's Shrimp-N-Grits $19.95

      Gulf shrimp sauteed with bacon, onions and peppers served on a bed of cheese grits. Mmmm, just like mama makes.

    • Aunt Edna's Fried Chicken $15.95

      Just like our great-aunt used to make for us, crispy, golden brown, juicy and delicious with a choice of 2 sides.

    • Aunt Carline's Fried Shrimp $17.95

      Gulf shrimp dredged in our seasoned flour, then fried golden brown and delicious with a choice of 2 sides.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.