Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • New York
  • St Nicholas Fish Market

St Nicholas Fish Market

(212) 740-8999

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 1609 St Nicholas Ave, New York, NY 10040
  • Latin American ,  Seafood
  • $$$$$
  • St Nicholas Fish Market

  • (212) 740-8999
  • Menu
  • Beverages
    • Soda $1.50

    • Spring Water $1.00

    • Homemade Lemonade $3.50

    • Passion Fruit Juice $3.50

  • Appetizers
    • Crab Patty $2.00+

    • Shrimp Patty $2.00+

    • Lobster Patty $3.00

    • Shrimp on a Stick $6.00

    • Raw Clams (8) $9.00

      8 piece.

    • Baked Clams (8) $10.00

      8 piece.

  • Soup
    • Fish Soup $6.00+

    • Seafood Soup $8.00+

    • Shrimp Soup $8.00+

    • Boneless Fish Soup $6.00+

  • Rice Soup
    • Shrimp in Rice Soup $14.95

    • Lobster in Rice Soup $28.95

    • Special Seafood in Rice Soup $39.95

      Serves 2.

    • Fillet Fish in Rice Soup $12.95

    • Fillet Salmon in Rice Soup $16.95

  • Salads
    • Seafood Salad $7.00+

    • Conch Meat Salad $6.00+

    • Conch Salad $8.00+

    • Shrimp Salad $7.00+

    • Octopus Salad $8.00+

    • Jumbo Shrimp Salad $12.00

  • Rice
    • Rice with Seafood $8.95+

      Spanish style.

    • Rice with Shrimp $8.95+

      Spanish style.

    • Rice with Octopus $9.95+

    • Rice with Whole Lobster $28.95

    • Rice with Vegetables $5.00+

    • Rice with Squid $7.95+

  • Fried Fish
    • Crab Stick $6.00

      Five pieces. Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.

    • Fried Shrimp $8.00

      12 pieces. Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.

    • Fried Jumbo Shrimp $12.95

      Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.

    • Fried Flounder $11.95

      Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.

    • Fried Scallops $6.00

      10 pieces. Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.

    • Fried Whiting $8.00

      Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.

    • Fried Blue Snapper $8.00

      Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.

    • Fried Fillet of Blue Snapper $11.95

      Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.

    • Fried Fish Nugget $12.00

      Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.

    • Fried King Fish $9.95+

    • Fried Salmon $12.95

      Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.

    • Fried Fillet of Tilapia $8.95

      Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.

    • Fried Red Snapper $14.95+

      Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.

    • Fried Tilapia (Whole Fish) $9.95

      Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.

    • Fried Porgy $9.95+

      Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.

    • Fried Squid $12.00

      Served with your choice of either fried rice, green plantains, sweet plantains or fries.

    • Fried Tile Fish $8.95+

    • Fried Fillet of Red Snapper $18.95

  • Pescado al Horno
    • King Fish $8.95

    • Blue Snapper $11.95

    • Salmon $12.95

    • Red Snapper $15.00+

    • Filet of Red Snapper $18.00

    • Fillet of Blue Snapper $11.95

    • Fillet of Salmon $15.95

    • Fillet of Flounder $11.95

    • Shrimp $12.99+

    • Fillet of Tilapia $8.95

    • Tile Fish $11.95

  • Steamed Seafood
    • Blue Crabs $12.95+

    • Snow Crab $25.00

      1 1/2 lb. Seasoned with Old Bay, butter and garlic.

    • Shrimps $3.00

      1 lb.

    • Lobster $30.00

      1.5LB

    • Clams $15.00

      One dozen.

    • Little Neck Clams $12.95

    • Mussels $12.95

      2 lbs.

    • Vegetables $3.00

    • Fish $3.00

      1 lb.

    • Steamed Seafood Combo $85.00

      Jumbo shrimp, lobster, snow crab, mussel, blue crab, scallop and squid.

    • 1 lb. Jumbo Shrimp $18.95

    • 1 lb. Large Shrimp $15.95

    • 1 lb. Medium Shrimp $11.95

  • Chef's Specialties
    • Sauteed Conch Meat $18.95

    • Conch Meat $25.95

    • Shrimp with Conch Meat $35.95

    • Shrimp in Garlic Sauce $14.95

    • Shrimp Creole $14.95

    • Crab Meat Creole $14.95+

    • Seafood in Garlic Sauce $23.00

    • Stewed Seafood $23.00

    • Squid with Garlic Sauce $18.95

    • Fillet Fish with Shrimp on Top $25.95

      Covered with chef's special sauce.

    • 16 oz. Lobster Tail in Garlic Sauce $38.00

    • Lobster Tail with Shrimp on Top $48.95

      Covered with chef's special sauce.

    • Sauteed Claw Fish Meat $25.00

    • Crab Meat $2.00+

    • Shrimp Patty $2.00+

    • Lobster Patty $3.00

    • Shrimp on a Stick $5.00

    • Raw Clams $8.00

    • Baked Clams $10.00

      Eight pieces.

    • Raw Oysters $8.00

      Eight pieces.

    • Crab Cakes $3.00+

    • Fish Cake $1.50

      One piece.

    • Octopus with Garlic Sauce $16.95

  • Paella de Italiano
    • Spaghetti with Shrimp $15.95

    • Spaghetti with Squid $14.95

    • Spaghetti with Seafood $23.00

    • Special Spaghetti $39.95

      Includes lobster tail, prawn, squid, mussels, etc.

  • Mofongo
    • Masa de Cangrejo Mofongo $15.95

      Crabmeat with mofongo.

    • Camarones Mofongo $15.95

      Shrimp with mofongo.

    • Fillet Salmon Mofongo $15.95

    • Mariscos Mofongo $24.95

      Seafood combo with mofongo.

    • Chicharron de Pescado Mofongo $12.95

      Fish chunks with mofongo.

  • Sandwiches
    • Whiting Sandwich $6.00

      Two whiting fillets and served with fries.

    • Fillet Tilapia Sandwich $8.00

      Served with fries.

    • Flounder Sandwich $10.00

      Served with fries.

  • From Kitchen (Sushi Menu)
    • Shrimp Gyoza Fried Japanese Dumpling $5.00

    • Shrimp Shumai $5.00

      Steamed Dumpling.

    • Edamame Steamed Soybean Pods $5.00

  • Sushi and Sashimi A La Carte
    • Futo Maki $7.50

    • Shrimp Tempura Roll $8.50

    • Boston Roll $7.00

    • Tiffany Roll $9.00

    • Shrimp and Scallop Poke Bowl $12.00

    • Octupus & Calamari Poke Bowl $12.00

    • Soft Shell Crab Poke Bowl $12.00

    • Crab meat Poke Bowl $12.00

    • Salmon Poke Bowl $12.00

    • Tuna Poke Bowl $12.00

    • Oyster Poke Bowl $12.00

  • Sushi Menu
    • Spicy Shrimp Roll $6.25

      Cooked.

    • Pepper Salmon Avocado Roll $12.00

    • Shrimp Inari $9.95

    • Eel Combo Roll $9.25

    • Pepper Tuna Avocado Roll $12.00

    • California Roll $5.00

    • Californian with Tobiko Roll $5.55

    • Salmon Avocado Roll $6.25

    • Spicy Salmon Roll $6.25

    • Green Dragon Roll $9.25

      Cooked. Eel, avocado, cucumber and crabmeat.

    • Spicy Tuna Roll $6.25

    • Spicy California Roll $6.25

    • Big Salmon Avocado Roll $7.50

    • Rainbow Roll $9.25

      California roll inside, avocado, salmon and tuna on top.

    • Nigiri Combo $9.25

    • California Combo $9.25

    • Maki Combo $9.25

    • Salmon Combo $9.25

    • Salmon Nigiri $9.25

    • Volcano Roll $9.25

      Spicy tuna, avocado inside, salmon, tuna and avocado on top with spicy mayonnaise.

    • Spicy Yellow Dragon Roll $9.25

      Spicy salmon, avocado inside, salmon avocado on top with spicy mayonnaise.

    • New York Combo $10.25

    • Sushi Deluxe $14.50

    • Avocado Panini Roll $14.95

      Spicy tuna inside and avocado on top.

    • Spicy Combo $12.50

      Spicy salmon, spicy tuna.

    • Avocado Roll $5.50

      Sliced avocado.

    • Avocado and Cucumber Roll $5.80

  • Vegetable Rolls
    • Cucumber Roll $5.00

    • Avocado Roll $5.00

    • Sweet Potato Roll $5.50

    • Sweet Dried Tofu Roll $5.50

    • Mixed Vegetables Roll $6.00

    • Seaweed Salad Roll $5.00

    • Oshinko Roll $5.00

  • Poke Bowl
    • Hawaiian Classic Poke Bowl $12.00

      Ahi tuna, sesame seeds, ogo seaweed, cucumber, green and sweet onion, chili flakes, roasted sesame oil, Hawaiian salt, pokeworks classic sauce.

    • Spicy Ginger Chicken Poke Bowl $12.00

      Free range chicken breast, edamame, cilantro, green and sweet onion, sesame seeds, spicy ginger sauce.

    • Shiso Salmon Poke Bowl $12.00

      Atlantic salmon, green and sweet onion, edamame, cucumber, sesame seeds, fresh shiso, ponzu fresh sauce.

    • Umami Classic Poke Bowl $12.00

      Ahi tuna, green and sweet onion, hijiki seaweed, cucumber, sesame seeds, umami shoyu sauce.

    • Spicy Ponzu Albacore Poke Bowl $12.00

      Albacore tuna, green and sweet onion, mango, spicy furikake, sesame seeds, ponzu fresh sauce.

    • Sweet Chili Tofu Poke Bowl $12.00

      Organic tofu, blanched kale, green and sweet onion, cucumber, edamame, sesame seeds, sweet chili gochujang sauce.

    • Spicy Ahi Poke Bowl $12.00

      Ahi tuna, green and sweet onion, cucumber, masago, sesame seeds, sriracha Aioli.

    • Wasabi Shrimp and Scallops Poke Bowl $12.00

      Shrimp, scallops, green and sweet onion, cucumber, masago, sesame seeds, wasabi aioli.

    • Jumbo Lump Crabmeat Poke Bowl $12.00

      Avocado, diced mango, seasonal veggies, cucumber, masago, seaweed, pickled ginger, edamame, oshinko, micro mix, toban djan aioli, ginger umami.

    • Octopus and Calamari Poke Bowl $12.00

    • Soft Shell Crab Poke Bowl $12.00

    • Tuna Poke Bowl $14.00

    • Oyster Poke Bowl $12.00

    • Salmon Poke Bowl $14.00

    • Seafood Poke Bowl $14.00

    • Chicken Poke Bowl $14.00

    • Octopus and Calamari Poke Bowl $14.00

  • Sushi Poke Bowl
    Poke Bowl
    • 1. Shrimp and Scallops Poke Bowl $12.00

      Shrimp, scallops, masago, green onions, cucumber, sesame seeds, sesame oil, avocado, edamame, and seaweed.

    • Shrimp and scallops $12.00

      Camarones, scallops, masago, cebollin, pepino, semillas de sesamo, aceite de sesamo, aguacate, edamame and seaweed.

    • 2. Octopus and Calamari Poke Bowl $12.00

      Calamari, octopus, avocado, edamame, sesame seeds, green onion, masago and seaweed.

    • Octopus and Calamari $12.00

      Calamares, pulpo, agucame, edamame, semillas, de sesamo, cebollin, masago and seaweed.

    • 3. Soft Shell Crab Poke Bowl $12.00

      Fried soft shell crab, avocado, cucumber, lettuce, edamame, masago, sesame seeds, and sesame oil.

    • Soft Shell Crab $12.00

      Cangrejo de piel suave, aguacate, pepino, lechuga, edamame, masago, semillas de sesamo, aceite de sesamo.

    • 4. Crab Meat Poke Bowl $12.00

      Crab meat, lettuce, avocado, cucumber, masago, edamame and seaweed.

    • Crab Meat $12.00

      Masa de cangredo, lechuga, aguacate, pepino, masago and edamame seaweed.

    • 5. Tuna Poke Bowl $12.00

      Tuna, masago, avocado, cucumber, seaweed, sesame seeds, sesame oil and edamame.

    • Tuna $12.00

      Atun, masago, aguacate, pepino, seaweed, semillas de sesamo, aceite de sesamo and edamame.

    • 6. Salmon Poke Bowl $12.00

      Salmon, masago, avocado, cucumber, seaweed, sesame seeds and sesame oil.

    • Salmon $12.00

      Salmon, masago, agucate, pepino, seaweed, semillas de sesamo and aceite de sesamo.

    • 7. Oyster Poke Bowl $12.00

      Fried oyster, kani, avocado, edamame, seaweed and sesame seeds.

    • Ostras $12.00

      Ostras fritas, kani, aguacate, edamame, seaweed, semillas de sesamo.

    • 8. Eel Poke Bowl $12.00

      Eel, lettuce, avocado, cucumber, ginger, sesame seed, and seaweed.

    • Eel Bowl $12.00

      Anguilla, ahumada, lechuga, agucate, pepino, jengibre, semillas de sesame and seaweed.

    • Shrimp Tempura $12.00

      fried shrimp,cucumber,avocado,lettuce, mayo with eel sauce

    • Futo Maki $8.00

      Kani, cucumber,avocado,tomago

    • Hot Lover $12.00

      Spicy kani,avocado,fried shrimp,cilantro with eel sauce spicy mayo on top

    • Romantic Date $12.00

      spicy tuna,fried shrimp,avocado, spicy mayo and spicy kani on top

    • Banana Roll $11.00

      fried banana,eel, avocado with eel sauce on top

    • Boston Roll $8.00

      Steamed shrimp,lettuce,cucumber,mayo inside

    • Godzilla Roll $12.00

      spicy tuna ,avocado,cucumber, mozzarella cheese,eel sauce,spicy mayo with masago on top

    • Tiffany Roll $10.00

      Kani,cucumber,avocado, with eel spicy mayo,masago on top

    • Fish Tempura $7.00

      Fried fish,cucumber,avocado,lettuce,mayo inside, eel sauce with masago on top

    • Yummy Roll $8.00

      spick kani ,spicy shrimp and avocado

  • Sides
    • Side of Plantains $3.00

    • Side of French Fries $2.00

    • Side of Fried Sweet Plantains $3.00

    • Side of Fried Rice $3.00

    • Side of White Rice $2.00

    • Side of Mashed Potato $3.00

    • Side of Fried Sweet Potato $3.00

  • Desserts
    • Flan $4.00

    • Tres Leches $4.00

    • Chocolate Cake $4.00

  • Sushi for Catering
    • Choice A. $58.99

      California with Tobiko Roll, Dragon Roll, Vegetable Roll, 3-pieces Shrimp Nigiri, 3-pieces Salmon Nigiri, 3-pieces Red Snapper, 1-piece Eel Nigiri, 3-pieces Tuna Sashimi.

    • Choice B $69.99

      Spice Yellow Dragon, Salmon Roll, California Hand Roll, Vegetable Roll, 18-pieces Combo Nigiri, California Roll w/ Tobiko.

    • Choice C $69.99

      7-pieces Salmon Nigiri, 8-pieces Red Snapper, 4-pieces Eel Nigiri, 4-pieces Shrimp Nigiri, Salmon Roll, Tuna Roll, 7-pieces Tuna Nigiri.

    • Choice D $69.99

      30-pieces Spicy Kani Roll, 4-pieces Eel Nigiri, 4-pieces Shrimp Nigiri, 1 Green Dragon, 2 Yellow Dragon Rolls, 1 Red Dragon Roll, 1 Rainbow Roll.

  • Catering Especial Para Fiesta
    special for party
    • Catering Rice with Seafood for 8 People $75.00

    • Catering Rice with Seafood for 15 People $135.00

Menu for St Nicholas Fish Market provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.