• New York
  • Port Jefferson Station
  • Buttercup's Dairy Store

Buttercup's Dairy Store

(631) 928-4607
  • 285 Boyle Road, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776
  • Grubhub.com
  • Menu
  • Speedy Cow's Monday Lunch Specials
    • BH Ham and Swiss Cheese on a Roll $4.99

    • BH Turkey and Meunster Cheese in a Wrap $4.99

    • Italian Panini $4.99

      Ham crappy, genoa, pepperoni and provolone.

  • Speedy Cow's Tuesday Lunch Specials
    • BH Bologna and American Cheese on a Roll $4.99

    • BH Chicken Breast and Cheddar in a Wrap $4.99

    • Pastrami and Baby Swiss Cheese Panini $4.99

  • Speedy Cow's Wednesday Lunch Specials
    • Boar's Head Store Cooked Roast Beef on a Roll $4.99

    • Turkey-Pastrami and Baby Swiss in a Wrap $4.99

    • Roast eef, Mozzarella Cheese, Roasted Red Pepper Panini $4.99

  • Speedy Cow's Thursday Lunch Specials
    • Ham Crappy and Provolone on a Roll $4.99

    • Londonport Roast Beef and Cheddar Cheese $4.99

    • Chicken Cutlet, Bacon and Cheddar Cheese Panini $4.99

  • Speedy Cow's Friday Lunch Specials
    • Genoa Salami and Provolone on a Roll $4.99

    • Low-Salt Turkey and Alpine Swiss in a Wrap $4.99

    • Smokehouse Blues Panini $4.99

      Grilled chicken, smoked Gouda, smoke master ham and BBQ sauce.

  • Buttercup's Classic 8" Signature Pies
    • Apple Signature Pie $4.69

    • Dutch Apple Signature Pie $4.69

    • Coconut Custard Signature Pie $4.99

    • Pumpkin Signature Pie $4.99

    • Peach Signature Pie $4.99

    • Strawberry Rhubarb Signature Pie $4.99

    • Mixed Berry Signature Pie $4.99

    • Lemon Krunch Signature Pie $4.99

    • Blueberry Signature Pie $5.99

    • Cherry Signature Pie $5.99

    • Raspberry Signature Pie $5.99

    • Egg Custard Signature Pie $4.99

    • Minced Fruit Signature Pie $5.99

    • Sweet Potato Signature Pie $5.99

    • Pecan Signature Pie $7.99

  • 8" No Sugar Added Pies
    • Apple No Sugar Pie $5.99

    • Cherry No Sugar Pie $5.99

    • Blueberry No Sugar Pie $5.99

  • 10" Fresh Baked Pies
    • Apple Fresh Baked Pie $6.49

    • Dutch Apple Fresh Baked Pie $8.99

    • Coconut Custard Fresh Baked Pie $6.99

    • Pumpkin Fresh Baked Pie $6.99

    • Blueberry Fresh Baked Pie $10.99

    • Cherry Fresh Baked Pie $10.99

    • Pecan Fresh Baked Pie $10.99

  • 10" Cream Pies
    • Chocolate Cream Pie $7.99

    • Lemon Meringue Cream Pie $8.99

  • 9" Premium Pies
    • Old Fashioned Apple Premium Pie $7.99

    • Caramel Apple Premium Pie $8.99

    • Peach Premium Pie $8.99

    • Pina Colada Premium Pie $8.99

    • Peach Praline Premium Pie $9.99

    • Very Berry Premium Pie $9.99

    • Blueberry Crumb Premium Pie $9.99

    • Cherry Crumb Premium Pie $9.99

    • Peach Crumb Premium Pie $9.99

    • Sweet Potato Krunch Premium Pie $9.99

    • Chocolate Chip Pecan Premium Pie $10.99

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.