• New York
  • Tonawanda
  • Mitchell's Tavern

Mitchell's Tavern

(716) 874-8907
  • 734 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, NY 14150
  • $$$$$
  • Grubhub.com
  • Main Menu
  • Starters
    • Mozzarella Sticks $6.25

      Five (5) battered mozzarella cheese sticks, served with a side of marinara

    • Pizza Logs $6.75

      Four (4) cheese & pepperoni logs, served with a side of marinara

    • Buffalo Shrimp $9.5

      Eight (8) hand breaded butterfly shrimp tossed in hot sauce, served with celery & bleu cheese

    • Mitchell's Fries $6.75

      Crispy fries topped with roast beef & our very own steak sauce

    • Pickle Fries $7

      Packing a puckerful punch, our lightly battered pickle fries are served with a zesty Boom Boom sauce

    • Buffalo Fries $4.5

      French fries tossed in hot sauce, served with celery & bleu cheese

    • Pretzel Sticks $4.5

      Ten (10) mini pretzel sticks lightly salted and served with honey mustard

  • Sides
    • French Fries $2.5

      Lightly salted with a crisp

    • Sweet Potato Fries $4.75

      Hand-cut sweet potato fries, served with honey & butter

    • Cajun Fries $3

      Our crisp fries with a kick of cajun seasoning

    • Onion Rings $4

      Thick cut onion rings, lightly breaded

    • Bag of Chips $1.75

      Ask server for choice selection

    • Potato Salad $2.25

    • Coleslaw $2.25

  • Salads
    Dressings: Balsamic, Italian, Honey French, Greek, Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Honey Mustard, Extra Dressing +$0.75
    • Buffalo Chicken Finger Salad $9

      Lettuce with tomatoes, onions, croutons & a pepperoncini topped with breaded chicken fingers tossed in your choice of sauce

    • Greek Salad $8.25

      Lettuce with feta, tomatoes, onions, black olives & a pepperoncini

    • Grilled Chicken Salad $9

      Chicken breast over lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, croutons & a pepperoncini

    • House Salad $5.25

      Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, croutons & a pepperoncini

  • Hand Held Sandwiches
    All sandwiches served on a fresh Costanzo roll (unless otherwise noted) with a pickle spear
    • Roast Beef - Our House Specialty $9

      Lean roast beef, slow roasted to perfection, served with our very own gravy on a plain Costanzo roll or Kimmelweck. Also served on white bread with our homemade gravy smothered on top

    • Spicy Philly Beef - A Mitchell's Specialty $9.25

      Philly style beef, American cheese, fried onions with Carlos hot sauce for an extra kick

    • Roast Beef Melt $9.75

      Roast beef served with Swiss, sautéed onions, homemade gravy on rye bread

    • Carolina BBQ Beef $9.75

      Delicious BBQ sauce with roast beef, topped with coleslaw

  • Burgers & Chicken
    Mitchell's burgers are 1/3 lb. USDA ground beef patties served on a fresh Costanzo roll with a pickle spear. Add Extras: American, Swiss, Feta, Cheddar, Provolone & Crumbly Bleu Cheese, Bacon and/or Sautéed Mushrooms +$0.75
    • Classic Burger $7.25

      Lettuce, tomato & mayo

    • Habanero Burger $9.25

      Hand-pressed with fresh diced habanero peppers, finished with shredded cheddar, jalapenos, lettuce, tomato & mayo

    • Black & Blue Burger $8.75

      Crumbly bleu cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo

    • Mushroom Swiss Burger $8.75

      Sautéed mushrooms, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato & mayo

    • Southwestern BBQ Burger $9

      Bacon, onion ring, American cheese, BBQ sauce, lettuce, tomato & mayo

    • Classic Chicken $7.25

      Grilled or fried chicken with lettuce, tomato & mayo

    • Buffalo Style Chicken $8

      Grilled or fried chicken in your choice of mild, medium or hot, topped with lettuce, tomato & bleu cheese

    • Southwestern BBQ Chicken $9

      Grilled or fried chicken topped with bacon, onion ring, American cheese, BBQ sauce, lettuce, tomato & mayo

  • Old School Favorites
    • Meatloaf $8.5

      Two slices of homemade meatloaf served with our very own gravy on a Costanzo roll. Also served on white bread with our homemade gravy smothered on top

    • Mitchell's Texas Hot $3.5

      Sahlen's hot dog with onion, mustard & Nick's homemade Texas sauce, same as Dad served over 50 years ago

    • Fried Bologna $6.75

      An American Classic - bologna covered with fried onions & your choice of cheese on a Costanzo roll

    • Mitchell's Royal $8.75

      Italian sausage topped with spicy capicola & melted provolone cheese with lettuce, tomato & mayo on a Costanzo roll

    • Fish Fillet $8.25

      Beer battered cod fillet deep fried, served with lettuce, tomato & tartar sauce on a Costanzo roll

  • Wraps
    Served on your choice of wheat or spinach wrap
    • Mitchell's Wrap - A Mitchell's Specialty $9

      Roast beef, fried onions, sautéed mushrooms, Swiss cheese, horseradish sauce & a touch of gravy

    • Stinger Wrap $9.75

      Roast beef, chicken fingers tossed in your choice of sauce with bleu cheese, lettuce, tomatoes & onions

    • Greek Wrap $8.75

      Grilled chicken, black olives, onions, lettuce, tomatoes, feta & Greek dressing

    • Chicken Ranch Wrap $8.75

      Grilled chicken, bacon, ranch, lettuce tomatoes & onions

    • Chicken Finger Wrap $8.75

      Chicken fingers tossed in your choice of sauce with bleu cheese, lettuce, tomatoes & onions

  • Wings & Things
    Served plain, mild, medium & hot. Specialty Sauces (+$0.75): Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ, Carlos Hot, Cajun, Jack Daniels BBQ, Deep Eddy's Garlic Parmesan & Honey Mustard
    • Chicken Fingers $9.5

      Four (4) fingers tossed in your choice of sauce, served with French fries, celery & bleu cheese

    • Chicken Wings $14

      Ten (10) wings in your choice of sauce, served with bleu cheese & celery

    • Boneless Wings $10.5

      Ten (10) wings in your choice of sauce, served with bleu cheese & celery

  • Seafood
    Served Daily with French fries, potato salad, coleslaw tartar or cocktail sauce & lemon wedge
    • Fish Fry $14

      Beer battered haddock fillet

    • Shrimp $13.75

      Ten (10) hand breaded butterfly shrimp

  • Seasonal
  • Fall / Winter
    • Award Winning Homemade Chili $4

      Best of show 2012 Ballpark Brew Bash Chili cook-off

  • Pork
    • Pulled Pork Sandwich $8.75

      BBQ homemade pulled pork topped with coleslaw on a Costanzo roll

    • Pulled Pork Hot Dog $5

      Bacon wrapped Sahlen's hot dog with BBQ pulled pork & shredded cheddar cheese on a hot dog bun

    • BBQ Pork Cheeseburger $12.25

      BBQ pulled pork, burger, American cheese, bacon, onion ring, lettuce, tomato & mayo on fresh Costanzo roll

    • Pig Skin BBQ $9.75

      BBQ pulled pork, bacon, bologna & shredded cheese on a fresh Costanzo roll

  • Kids Menu
    $6.50; Children 12 & under. All kids meals include French fries & a beverage
    • Chicken Fingers $6.5

    • Hot Dog $6.5

    • Grilled Cheese $6.5

    • Pizza Logs $6.5

  • Beverages
    Ask Your Server About Our Beer, Liquor & Wine Selection
    • Soda $2.5

      Free refills with a meal! - Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Ginger Ale, Mountain Dew, Sierra Mist, Lipton Iced Tea, Unsweetened Tea, Lemonade, Loganberry & Eroquois Keg Birch Beer

    • Bottled Water $2.5

    • Energy Drinks

      Red Bull & Sugar Free Red Bull

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.