- New York
- Water Mill
- Silver Lining Diner
What is Grubhub
Through online ordering, we connect hungry people with the best local restaurants. Explore restaurants near you to find what you love.
Why use Grubhub
Order popular dishes from a variety of restaurants. Get your order delivered or pick it up.
Silver Lining Diner
We make ordering easy. Learn more
- 32 Montauk Highway, Water Mill, NY 11976
-
No cuisines specified
-
Grubhub.com
-
Silver Lining Diner
-
We make ordering easy.
- Menu
-
Breakfast ClassicsServed with crisp golden home fries, your choice of toast. Egg whites for an additional charge.
-
Eggs Your Way $10.50
2 eggs
-
Avocado Toast $12.50
Honey grain bread, satur farms field greens.
-
-
SaladsAdd organic chicken, salmon, grilled steak or chilled shrimp for an additional charge.
-
Bowls
-
EggiesServing the best breakfast sandwiches in America, on a roll or soft tortilla. Egg whites for an additional charge.
-
Classic Scrambled $10.00
With American cheese.
-
Egg Melt $11.00
Grafton cheddar, caramelized onions,and roasted tomato.
-
-
Benedicts2 poached eggs, tarragon hollandaise over toasted English muffin, and crisp golden home fries.
-
Smoked Country Ham $15.00
-
Spinach and Kale $14.00
-
Catsmo Smoked Salmon $16.00
-
Spanish Scramble Platter $16.00
3 eggs, chorizo, onions, peppers, jack cheese & jalapeño.
-
-
All Day Breakfast
-
Buttermilk Hot Cakes $14.00
-
Brioche French Toast $14.00
-
Buttermilk Belgian Waffles $14.00
-
Fried Chicken & Waffles $17.00
All buttermilk with salted butter and maple syrup.
-
Eggs Any Style $13.00
With home fries and toast.
-
Omelet Your Way $17.00
3 eggs, crisp golden home fries, your choice of toast
-
-
Farm Fresh Organic Omelets
-
Omelet Your Way $12.00
3 eggs, crisp golden home fries, your choice of toast.
-
-
From the GriddleServed with sweet butter and Vermont maple syrup.
-
Buttermilk Hot Cakes $11.50
-
Brioche French Toast $11.50
-
Buttermilk Belgian Waffles $11.50
-
Fried Chicken & Waffles $15.00
All buttermilk with salted butter and maple syrup.
-
Catsmo Smoked Salmon Platter $16.00+
-
-
Small Plates
-
SandwichesMake it deluxe with hand-cut fries and Alabama slaw for an additional charge.
-
Eric's Incredible BurgersComes with lettuce, tomato, and pickle. Make it deluxe with hand-cut fries and Alabama slaw for an additional charge
-
Pick Your Snake River Farm beef Burger $16.00
-
Pick Your Turkey Burger $14.00
-
Pick Your Superior Veggie Burger $14.00
-
-
From the FryerPerfectly anson mills corn flour-fried. Served with cider vegetable slaw and tartar sauce.
-
Montauk Fish N' Chips $18.00
-
Deluxe Mixed Fry Seafood Combo $21.00
With crispy potato fries
-
Jumbo Atlantic Shrimp $21.00
With crispy potato fries.
-
Montauk Sea Scallops $22.00
With crispy potato fries.
-
-
Entrees
-
Breakfast Sides
-
Applewood Smoked Bacon $5.00
-
Maple Cured Country Ham $5.00
-
Pork Sausage Links $5.00
-
Chicken Sausage Links $5.00
-
Crisp Golden Home Fries $3.00
-
Bagel $4.00
-
-
Sides
-
Mesclun Greens $7.00
-
Mashed Potatoes with Parmesan and Cream $7.00
-
Crisp Potato Fries $7.00
-
Farm Stand Vegetables $7.00
-
BBQ Rubbed Sweet Potato Fries $7.00
-
-
Desserts
-
Key Lime Pie $12.00
Graham cracker crust, French meringue.
-
Key Lime Pie a la Mode $16.00
Graham cracker crust, French meringue.
-
Chocolate Marquis $12.00
Vanilla soft serve ice cream.
-
Chocolate Marquis a la Mode $12.00
Vanilla soft serve ice cream.
-
Fresh Berry Cheesecake $12.00
Blueberry and raspberry sauce.
-
Fresh Berry Cheesecake a la Mode $16.00
Blueberry and raspberry sauce.
-
House Made Carrot Cake $12.00
-
House Made Carrot Cake a la Mode $16.00
-
Banana Cake Sundae $12.00
-
Banana Cake Sundae a la Mode $16.00
-
-
Soft Serve, Hand Spun Daily
-
Soft Serve $5.00+
-
-
Milkshakes
-
Tahitian Vanilla $10.00
-
Black N White Swirl $10.00
-
Fresh Local Berry $10.00
-
Coffee Milkshake $10.00
-
Chocolate Milkshake $10.00
-
Vanilla Milkshake $10.00
-
Vanilla Milkshake $10.00
-
Strawberry Milkshake $10.00
-
-
Joe and Liza's Ice Cream
-
Kids Scoop Ice Cream $4.00
-
2 Scoops Ice Cream $6.00
-
3 Scoops Ice Cream $8.00
-
-
Signature Smoothies
-
Floats & Sodas
-
Classic Egg Cream $7.00
-
Kombucha Float $11.00
-
Mexican Coca Cola $5.00
-
Fanta Orange Pure Cane Sugar $5.00
-
Root Beer Float $9.00
-
-
Coffee
-
House Blend Drip $3.50
-
Double Espresso $4.50
-
Cappuccino $5.00
-
Latte $5.00
-
Americano $5.00
-
Macchiato $5.00
-
Cortado $5.00
-
Flat White $5.50
-
Cold Brew Coffee $4.50
-
Iced Double Espresso $6.00
-
Iced Latte $6.50
-
Iced Americano $6.50
-
Iced Unsweetened Black Tea $4.00
-
-
Tea
-
Chamomile $3.00
-
Chai Latte $6.00
-
Chai Tea $4.50
-
Earl Grey $3.00
-
English Breakfast Assam $3.00
-
Matcha $6.00
-
Mint $3.00
-
Yorkshire Gold $3.50
-
Jasmine Pearl Green $3.00
-
-
Non-Alcoholic
-
Iced Unsweetened Black Tea $4.00
-
Lemonade $5.00
-
Mexican Coca Cola $5.00
-
Fanta Orange Pure Cane Sugar $5.00
-
Fanta Pineapple Pure Cane Sugar $5.00
-
Fanta Grape Pure Cane Sugar $5.00
-
Abita Root Beer $5.00
-
Ting, Grapefruit Soda $5.00
-
Apple Juice, R.W. Knudsen $5.00
-
Pomegranate Juice, R.W. Knudsen $5.00
-
Tomato Juice, R.W. Knudsen $5.00
-
Still Water, Acqua Panna $7.00
-
Sparkling Water, San Pellegrino $7.00
-
Hot Chocolate $4.00
-
-
Juices
-
Just Squeezed 8oz Florida Orange $7.00
-
Just Squeezed 8oz Ruby Red Grapefruit $7.00
-
Fresh Pressed Pure Green Juice $9.00
-
Menu for Silver Lining Diner provided by Allmenus.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.