• Ohio
  • Worthington
  • Over the Counter

Over the Counter

(614) 846-1107
  • 5596 North High Street, Worthington, OH 43085
  • Grubhub.com
  • Menu
  • Appetizers
    • Fried Veggies $5.99

      Crimini mushrooms, kosher housemade dill pickles and broccoli served with buttermilk ranch.

    • Chicken Tenders $7.89

      Juicy tempura-breaded tenders served with buttermilk ranch.

    • Loaded Fries $7.59

      Ries smothered with melted Cheddar, bacon and green onion, served with sour cream.

    • Quesadilla $7.79

      Grilled flour tortilla, layered with melted cheese, mushrooms, red pepper, cilantro and onion with chipotle sour cream.

    • Pretzel Bites $5.99

      Salted soft pretzels served with guinness beer cheese.

    • Chicken Wings $5

      Rubbed, baked, then deep fried hot sauce, bourbon bacon Barbeque or garlic Parmesan served with ranch, Bleu cheese and celery upon request.

    • Corn Dog Bites $6.79

      Salty and sweet, corn-breaded Angus hot dog bites served with spicy mustard.

    • Appetizer Platter $14.89

  • Soups
    • Chilic Soup $3.99

      Lean beef, bell peppers, black beans, corn, onion and chunky tomato, topped with Cheddar, sour cream and red onion.

    • Chicken & Rice Soup $3.99

      Hearty blend of chicken breast, veggies and rice.

  • Salads
    • Spinach Salad $4.79

      Baby spinach, bacon, Bleu cheese, tomato with balsamic vinaigrette.

    • Route 23 Salad $4.79

      Spring mix, fried herbed goat cheese medallions, balsamic marinated shallots, strawberries and candied walnuts with our signature house23 dressing.

    • Caesar Salad $4.79

      Romaine, bacon, garlic croutons and Parmesan crisps with Caesar dressing.

  • Sandwiches
    All sandwiches served with local potato chips.
    • Sloppy Joe Sandwich $6.99

      Thick and saucy lean beef, red pepper and onion on a split-top bun with a side of creamy cole slaw.

    • Sweet & Spicy BLT Sandwich $7.99

      Candied bacon, lettuce, tomato, with roasted red pepper aioli on lucky cat multi-grain.

    • Grilled Cheese Sandwich $6.99

      Cheddar, provolone and Swiss with tomato and spicy mayo on lucky cat sourdough.

    • Tuna Melt Sandwich $8.49

      Dolphin-safe albacore, cheddar and Swiss on lucky cat sourdough.

    • Chicken Caesar Wrap Sandwich $8.99

      Marinated grilled chicken breast, romaine, tomato and Caesar dressing wrapped in a flour tortilla.

    • The Counter Burger $7.29

      88% lean beef patty, lettuce, tomato, red onion, housemade dill pickles with mad sauce on a split-top bun.

    • Charlie Dog $8.99

      Quarter pound Angus all beef hot dog wrapped in bacon, stuffed with cheese.

    • Hot Dog $6.29

      Quarter pound Angus all-beef hot dog on a classic bun served with a side of spicy mustard.

    • Sloppy Dog $8.29

      1/4 lb. Angus all-beef hot dog with sloppy joe sauce, cheese, onion and sweet relish.

    • Fish and Chip Sammy Sandwich $9.99

      Breaded and fried cod on a bed of french fries topped with housemade tartar sauce and housemade dill pickles on a split-top bun, served with a side of creamy coleslaw.

    • Turkey Club Sandwich $10.49

      Thin-sliced peppercorn turkey breast with bacon, Swiss, spring mix, tomato and roasted red pepper aioli on tomato swirl bread.

    • Patty Melt Sandwich $8.79

      88% lean beef patty, Swiss and bourbon caramelized onion with housemade Thousand island dressing on lucky cat sourdough.

    • Italian Chicken Sandwich $10.49

      Grilled chicken breast, roasted red pepper, spring mix, tomato, Provolone and pesto aioli on tomato swirl bread.

    • Buffalo Chicken Wrap $8.99

      Chicken tenders, Buffalo sauce, Bleu cheese crumbles, tomato, romaine and buttermilk ranch wrapped in a flour tortilla.

    • Pulled Pork Sandwich $8.49

      Slow roasted, Coca Cola brown sugar pulled pork, onion rings on top, split top bun and housemade pickle chips with a side of creamy cole slaw.

    • Black Bean Burger $7.49

      Hand-made vegan patty, spring mix, tomato and avocado with chipotle sour cream on split-top bun.

    • Grilled Pb & J Sandwich $5.89

      Crunchy peanut butter, strawberry jelly and fresh sliced strawberries on lucky cat sourdough.

  • Sides
    • Mac-N-cheese $4.79

      Provolone, Cheddar, Swiss and cream cheese topped with buttery herb bread crumbs.

    • French Fry Basket $4.49

      Shoestring cut with rosemary oil and seasoning salt.

    • Creamy Cole slaw $2.49

    • Onion Rings $4.49

      Hand dipped and beer battered.

  • Drinks
    • IBC Rootbeer Bottle $2.99

    • Fountain Soda $1.89

      Coke, Diet Coke, caffeine free Diet Coke, Sprite, seagram's ginger ale, Fanta orange soda, minute maid lemonade.

    • Petali Hot Tea Selection $2.29

    • French Press Coffee $2.99

      One line regular and decaf.

    • Iced Tea $1.89

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.