Heritage Amish Bake Shoppe

• Breads
  Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time.
  • Sourdough Bread $3.95

  • Cinnamon Swirl Bread $4.5

  • Herb Bread $3.95

  • Rye Swirl Bread $4.25

  • Seven Grains Bread $4.5

  • Honey Wheat Bread $3.95

  • Wheat Bread $3.95

    100% freshly ground whole wheat.

• Dinner Rolls
  Per dozen. Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time.
  • Honey Whole Wheat Rolls $4.45

  • White Yeast Rolls $4.45

• Frosted Cinnamon Rolls
  Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time. Nine inch round pan.
  • With Nuts Frosted Cinnamon Roll $7.95

  • Caramel Frosted Cinnamon Roll $6.95

  • Sticky Buns Frosted Cinnamon Roll $7.95

  • Singles Frosted Cinnamon Roll $1.95

• Sweet Breads
  Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time.
  • Banana Nut Sweet Bread $4.95

  • Zucchini Sweet Bread $4.95

  • Pumpkin Sweet Bread $4.95

  • Amish Friendship Sweet Bread $5.95

• Jumbo Muffins
  Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time.
  • Banana Streusel Jumbo Muffin (4) $5.95

  • Blueberry Streusel Jumbo Muffin (4) $5.95

  • Morning Glory Jumbo Muffin (4) $5.95

• Cookies
  Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time.
  • Chocolate Chip Cookie $2.95

  • Oatmeal Raisin Cookie $2.95

  • Cinnamon Oatmeal Crinkle Cookie $2.95

  • Peanut Butter Cookie $2.95

  • Oatmeal Peanut Butter Cookie $2.95

  • Molasses Cookie $2.95

• Whoopie Pies
  Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time. These pies are made in a deep dish ten inch pan. Mini pies six inch.
  • Whoopie Pies $1.95

• Fruit Pies
  Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time. These pies are made in a deep dish ten inch pan. Mini pies six inch.
  • Blackberry Fruit Pie $14.5

  • Rhubarb Fruit Pie $14.5

  • Cherry Fruit Pie (Small) $5.99

  • Apple Fruit Pie $14.5

  • Cherry Fruit Pie $14.5

  • Huckleberry Fruit Pie $14.5

  • Red Raspberry Fruit Pie $14.5

  • Strawberry Fruit Pie $14.5

  • French Apple Fruit Pie $14.5

  • Dark Sweet Cherry Fruit Pie $14.5

  • Black Raspberry Fruit Pie $14.5

  • Peach Fruit Pie $14.5

  • Blueberry Fruit Pie $14.5

• Cream Pies
  Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time. These pies are made in a deep dish ten inch pan. Mini pies six inch.
  • Peanut Butter Cream Pie $14.5

  • Lemon Meringue Cream Pie $14.5

  • Coconut Cream Cream Pie $14.5

• Specialty Pies
  Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time. These pies are made in a deep dish 10 inch pan. Mini pies six inch.
  • Pumpkin Specialty Pie $14.5

  • Chocolate Chess Specialty Pie $14.5

  • Pumpkin Custard Specialty Pie $14.5

  • Shoofly Specialty Pie $14.5

  • Pecan Specialty Pie $14.5

    Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time.

• Seasonal Fresh Fruit Pies
  Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time. These pies are made in a deep dish ten inch pan. Mini pies six inch.
  • Strawberry Seasonal Fresh Fruit Pie $15.95

  • Blueberry Seasonal Fresh Fruit Pie $15.95

  • Peach Seasonal Fresh Fruit Pie $15.95

  • Cranberry Apple Seasonal Fresh Fruit Pie $4.95